5 ms·
When I worked at Angel Studios about 15 years ago (doing projects for Nintendo and Disney), one of the many things that I liked about the company was a consciou
by mark_l_watson 12y ago
When I worked at Angel Studios about 15 years ago (doing projects for Nintendo and Disney), one of the many things that I liked about the company was a conscious decision by the four owners of the company to not create violent content. They were a class act.
Not too far off topic: my brother and my grandson absolutely love violent games. I don't understand the appeal. What I do like are driving games and strategy games.
- jiggy2011 12y agoOnly non violent strategy games?
- saraid216 12y agoWhen you're at the thousand-foot view, the fact that a baneling hit causes marine gore to fly several yards to the edge of the map is sort of... beside the point.
- darkFunction 12y agoThe appeal is in infinite possibilities, sport and teamwork. Single player games don't appeal to me as an adult, the outcome is scripted and the characters are hollow for the most part. It's entirely passive and a film or book gets to the point quicker for me. Violent multiplayers though- Counter Strike or Battlefield- give rise to fluid, human, tense stories. Stories in the context of violence sure, but real and non-scripted. It's yours and not the developers'.
- cyounkins 12y agoPlease describe the story of Counter Strike, because I've logged hundreds of hours on the game and have no idea what you're talking about.
- darkFunction 12y agoStory in the sense a game of football has a story.
- sgarman 12y agoI think by stories the author means real adventures with you and your teammates for that specific match - not some sort of CS lore. Each match brings new humans that will play, react, chat differently then an AI in a single player game.
- stonemetal 12y agoAs per what he said there is no "Story of Counter Strike" and that is what he likes about it. It is a framework for him and his team mates to invent a story of struggle told in near misses and heroic wins. Why he has trouble inventing the same stories with robotic team mates and opponents I am not sure, but he seems to find value in the shared experience.
- gknoy 12y agoAs others have mentioned, it's not about the game, but specific experiences you had. I have memories of intense stand-offs when rescuing hostages, or the one time I had an __absurd__ streak of luck and managed to single-handedly wipe out the entire other team (never since repeated). Some of my strongest gaming memories are of the first (?) level of Rogue Spear (one of the Rainbow Six games), where I was hunting terrorists in the Met. It was fifteen years ago, but I still remember how upset I felt when I saw a virtual character fall down after being shot, and I can still remember the intense despair that crushing my elation when a hostage panicked and ran in between me and the terrorist (and I shot him). I played that level so many times that I can probably still sketch the map. I remember nothing else about the game, but the experience of playing that one map stays with me. This is a completely different kind of "story" or memory than one's going to get from a game like Borderlands.
- Hytosys 12y agoWith all due respect, it doesn't sound like the simulated violence had much to do with the nostalgia you're describing. Not that I don't believe that violence can't be a tool used to evoke empathy, but effective stories can certainly be devised without hyperrealistic violence.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- mark_l_watson 12y agoOK, thanks, that makes sense. That said, I worked on some prototypes of multi-player racing games and "dicing" with friends around a racetrack has a bit of the appeal you mentioned. I do watch a few fairly violent movies a year, it is just the violent games that I don't enjoy.
- Retric 12y agoI have been thinking you could probably build an open ended world with a reasonably deep autogenerated quest system. there are already weak AI systems that can respond to open ended text fairly well. Start with some basic relationships and the game could decide the second son wants to kill his older brother to take the therone but needs to frame someone to take the fall... Ect. You can Restrict dialog choices while still giving the player real choices.
- EpicEng 12y agoAngel Studios released Resident Evil 2 in 1999. Non-violent you say?
- mark_l_watson 12y agoThat was after I left :-)
- EpicEng 12y agoAhh, yes, it does seem to be their first violent game. It was 15 years ago, so I wasn't sure.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- hcarvalhoalves 12y agoIMHO, I don't think violence is the main point of Resident Evil, it's more about the horror/suspense. A bit different than mindless violence as in e.g., GTA, Call of Duty, Battlefield, etc.
- EpicEng 12y agoI agree that RE is not as bad as GTA, but I don't care what adults do in their free time, and children shouldn't be playing GTA period. I don't think you can seriously make the argument that RE isn't a violent game though. The "point", or motivation, isn't all that relevant. You're still shooting things in the face and getting your throat torn out while you writhe in pain, so let's keep the goalposts in place.
- loup-vaillant 12y agoInterestingly, even extremely graphically violent games on the surface can be felt as non-violent in a competitive setting. I recall this "playing to win" essay, talking about Street Fighter. (If characters punching each other to unconsciousness is not violent, I don't know what is.) In fighting games, competitive players tend to concentrate on the structure behind punches and suffering. They see a game of anticipation, dexterity, and timing. They talk about hit boxes, priorities, frame advantage… Those players would probably enjoy an abstract version of those fighting games. Hmm… we could even test that: could we make a game that have a similar structure to Mortal Kombat, only it doesn't even look like 2 characters punching each other to death?
- cwyers 12y agoIt's interesting that you bring up Mortal Kombat, which wasn't the first fighting game, or necessarily even the best fighting game, but it certainly was the one that looked the most like two characters punching each other to death.
- loup-vaillant 12y agoActually, I choose to name that one precisely because of its violence. Hopefully helps make my point. I would have liked to select another name for its underlying mechanics, but I'm not knowledgeable enough.
- wrthomps 12y agoHi, fighting game player here. You're very right about the way we see the games: Ryu's Shoryuken isn't a stylish kung-fu uppercut, it's an attack that's invincible on startup and with a strong vertical hitbox, making it useful against jumping attacks and to beat careless attacks from the opponent, but which is easily punishable if blocked. The essay you're referring to is written by a man named David Sirlin, and he runs a website where he talks about his ideas on game design[1]. He's perhaps most known in the community for helping to bring to light the concept of "yomi," (lit. "reading"), the process of taking actions specifically to get a grasp on your opponent's thought process and be able to predict it. To him, that's the one pure essence of fighting games (though this view is not universally held). In fact, he's already done something like you describe. He designed a card game named, appropriately enough, Yomi[2], that attempts to bring the core of a fighting game into a card game format. Much like in fighting games, attacking beats throws, throws beat blocking, and blocking beats attacks. Hitting a player allows you to attempt to combo them, but the opponent can play cards (that may be bluffs) which can break the combo. He did something similar with chess, calling it Chess 2, though it's much less popular than Yomi. [1] http://www.sirlin.net http://www.sirlin.net [2] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Yomi_(card_game) http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Yomi_(card_game)
- 10098 12y ago> I don't understand the appeal. What's the appeal of action movies? It's fun. Haven't you ever tried blowing something up when you were a kid?
- morsch 12y agoThat's begging the question. Why is it fun?
- oldmanjay 12y agoAsking people why they like what they like is a pointless exercise. And generally, in my experience, it comes from a place of arrogance on the part of the person doing the asking, because the next phase is talking down about how the "reasons" aren't valid.
- saraid216 12y agoGame designers can answer the question. http://www.theoryoffun.com/ http://www.theoryoffun.com/ http://www.gamasutra.com/view/feature/129948/the_chemistry_of_game_design.php http://www.gamasutra.com/view/feature/129948/the_chemistry_o... http://www.gamasutra.com/view/feature/131802/glory_and_shame_powerful_.php http://www.gamasutra.com/view/feature/131802/glory_and_shame... Off the top of my head.
- 10098 12y agoIt's just the way we are. We like dominating and winning. There's at least a little bit of bloodlust in everyone, without those traits we wouldn't be able to become the dominant species on our planet.