5 ms·
I believe this is what Chevy Volt does, and it's brilliant. There are two reasons I like this design. First, the fossil fuel engine in the Volt spins at only th
by IgorPartola 12y ago
I believe this is what Chevy Volt does, and it's brilliant. There are two reasons I like this design. First, the fossil fuel engine in the Volt spins at only three pre-defined speeds so it can be optimized better. By contrast, your normal car engine has to run at both 900 RPM and 6500 RPM, with the best fuel economy somewhere between 2000 and 3000 RPM. Heck, you could shut the Volt's engine entirely while it's "idling" and not have to worry about stop & go traffic: the engine is independent of the wheels.
Second, and this is admittedly more long term, it doesn't really matter what type of engine you put into the Volt. This thought was presented to me by one of their dealers, but it makes a lot of sense. The current engine is a "tried and true" gasoline job. But if Chevy found that diesel or bio fuel, or natural gas worked better, they could swap it out without redesigning the rest of the drivetrain.
I may sound like a walking billboard for the Volt, but I am honestly not. I don't own one, and do not work for Chevy/GM. I do happen to think that the Volt is the best compromise between price, range on batteries, and ability to drive long distances. While Tesla's are very cool, I think the Volt is a much more gradual transition from gas to electric.
- maxerickson 12y agoThis article is more about using the linear electrical generator on the piston than it is the configuration of the power train. No vehicles on the road today have anything similar to what is discussed in the article. Also, I'm not sure about the current model, but there was a bunch of kerfuffle over the Volt not really being a strict electric hybrid: http://www.plugincars.com/exclusive-chevrolet-volt-chief-engineer-explains-volt-drivetrain-says-volt-electric-vehicle-90758.ht http://www.plugincars.com/exclusive-chevrolet-volt-chief-eng... Some of the time, at least in the edition discussed there, energy from the engine goes to the wheels without ever becoming electricity. Maybe they changed it in later models (but I sort of doubt it, the capability is there because it can be the most efficient way to use the engine).
- IgorPartola 12y agoI did not know that. Looking at the Wikipedia article for the Volt [1] I can see that the gasoline engine may provide additional mechanical energy to turn the wheels, but it's only to assist the primary and secondary electric motors. In either case, I am not a purist going after a 100% electric car. I want to get more miles per dollar, and I want to produce less CO2 per mile. The Volt seems to do that, while still letting me drive from NYC to LA and back without having to spend more than three minutes at any given gas station. More importantly, any gas station will do, since it can run on just gas. For a daily commute, it will likely run 100% electric since the battery won't be depleted. To me, this is a great combination. [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chevrolet_Volt#Drivetrain http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chevrolet_Volt#Drivetrain
- mikeash 12y agoNothing in your first paragraph is special to the Volt. Any hybrid, aside from the less advanced "motor assist" designs (found in earlier Honda hybrids) get the same advantages. A Prius can keep the engine at a happy RPM throughout due to effectively having a CVT, and it can not only shut off the engine when stopped, but even when moving up to 40+MPH. There are some interesting consequences of a pure serial hybrid design like the Volt (although the Volt isn't quite a pure serial design), but friendlier RPM and the ability to shut the engine down aren't it.
- graycat 12y agoIt's simple: A car needs a source of energy. Then a 15 gallon tank of gasoline is just super tough to beat. Can beat it a little with a 15 gallon tank of Diesel oil. A few hundred pounds of batteries with a charge from the electric grid? You gotta be kidding. Now, what to do with that liquid in that 15 gallon tank is a question, but the basic fact remains. Did I mention that that fact is simple? A car needs energy, and that 15 gallon tank is tough to beat. For the rest, we have a lot of possibilities, but that 15 gallon tank is tough to beat.
- graycat 12y agoGee, some people need some help: Did I mention, a 15 gallon tank is tough to beat? Electric power, that is, without a tank of gasoline or Diesel, for the energy for a car, is tough, super tough, for now and a long time, too tough to store. It's tough. Storing electric energy is tough, too tough for a car and likely also for wind and solar to feed the grid. Yes, there are ways to store the energy from wind and solar for the grid, but those ways are too expensive, by a factor of about 2, over other means of electric power generation that do not need storage, even if the power from wind and solar are just free, as in totally free, as in $0.00 per megawatt year. So, let's look at an example, say, Tesla. I just went to their Web site and looked at charging time and saw > During the work week I charge only at work during an 8hr shift from a 110 outlet. I only live 6 miles from work. I usually get ~30 miles of charge in 8 hours So, right, 8 hours of charging for 30 miles of driving. Lots of cars can go 30 miles on one gallon of gasoline that takes about, what, 20 seconds, to pump. Diesel, maybe 45 miles. The car, sure, it can still drive the wheels with electric motors, but, to make any sense, we store little or no electric energy in the car. Instead, the energy for the car is stored in a 15 gallon tank of gasoline or Diesel. We had electric cars going way back to the beginning of cars. Why? Because lead acid batteries and electric motors were already old things. And, a battery much better than lead acid is still tough to get; indeed, we still use lead acid batteries in cars for, say, the starting motor. The main problem with electric cars remains the batteries. As a Ford executive said long ago, build me a good battery and I will build you a good electric car. We are still waiting for a good battery, say, comparable with a 15 gallon tank of gasoline, in range, capital expense, operating expense, durability, and 'recharging' time. So far, a Tesla is a toy for rich people. Sorry 'bout that. I could like an electric car; it would have a lot of advantages. The problem is the battery. And that's been the problem for about 100 years.
- masklinn 12y ago> I believe this is what Chevy Volt does The article's point is not to about "diesel-electric" systems (where the ICE acts solely as a prime mover for a generator and the wheels are always driven electrically). That's old news in both transportation in general (it's been in use in trains and ships since the early 20th century) and in hybrids ("diesel-electric" is sometimes called "series hybrid" or "range-extended electric vehicle" in cars). It's about a new engine design[0] where electric generation is merged into the piston itself: a "normal" diesel-electric engine has a regular diesel engine (or more generally ICE) with pistons driving a crankshaft which drives the driveshaft, which is connected to a generator. Here the design does away with the crank and driveshaft: the piston itself is a rotor, and the casing becomes the stator, doing away with mecanical transmission altogether: the piston and its cylinder become a linear generator. [0] not quite that new, the first patent on free-piston engines[1] for linear generators dates back to 1959. The new part is getting a design to actually work in a vehicle[2]. [1] a free-piston engine is an engine without a crankshaft transforming the piston's linear movement into rotational movement [2] the crankshaft does not just transform motion and lose energy, it also synchronises pistons and limits the piston's course. But if the piston+cylinder is a self-contained generator, I guess you can treat each piston as a single-piston linear engine? Which would limit the usual issues of multiple free-piston engines. edit: formatting, footnotes
- IgorPartola 12y agoThanks for the explanation.