3 ms·
>I did not know the phrase had commonly held definition. "Social proof" refers to the general phenomenon of people forming opinions in alignment with what they
by SilasX 12y ago
>I did not know the phrase had commonly held definition.
"Social proof" refers to the general phenomenon of people forming opinions in alignment with what they observe others believing. I understand what you meant, but it's confusing to frame that as a social proof issue, given its common usage.
>My comment was not about a group representing the population, but rather representative of the possible solutions weighted by relevance or similar metric.
I know, but that's it's wrong: the group was representative of the typical arguments and reasoning offered regarding how to model government policy. Most people lack the understanding to articulate what's wrong with unfamiliar or "absurd" proposals; casting his net wider wouldn't have helped much, even in the internet age.
>hamburglar should have/be use heuristics that do not depend on encountering the right people to gather and judge evidence when possible.
Then what should they depend on? Again, you can't update on evidence that even interested adversaries can't find! At most, it means you should lower your confidences all around, but even then, the people he argued with should have lowered them even further, for the very same reasons.
- davorak 12y ago> I know, but that's it's wrong: When I read your response it does not seem to be about the argument I am trying to communicate. > the group was representative of the typical arguments I was not talking about typical arguments. > Then what should they depend on? There are multitude of domain specific heuristics that can be used to gather and judge evidence. My post: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7969283 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7969283 is about how hamburglar seemed at one point overly reliant on one heuristic.