4 ms·
They're also an eyesore. Not to worry, over the next several decades large cities will build out effective mass transit systems. High-speed rail will eventuall
by melling 12y ago
They're also an eyesore.
Not to worry, over the next several decades large cities will build out effective mass transit systems. High-speed rail will eventually come to America after years of debate.
Look to China to lead the way. What's this low-speed maglev that they're building now?
http://usa.chinadaily.com.cn/epaper/2014-02/19/content_17291903.htm http://usa.chinadaily.com.cn/epaper/2014-02/19/content_17291...
- pdonis 12y agoover the next several decades large cities will build out effective mass transit systems Which, as the article points out, won't fix the traffic congestion, because as some people switch from driving to mass transit, other people will take their place by driving when they previously walked or just didn't make the trip at all. So mass transit can increase the total number of trips made, but it won't decrease road usage.
- personZ 12y agohttp://www.theonion.com/articles/report-98-percent-of-us-commuters-favor-public-tra,1434/ http://www.theonion.com/articles/report-98-percent-of-us-com... It is the onion, and is flippant, but as a general belief it touches upon a basic truth -- everyone would love if everyone else used public transit, leaving the roads available for our use.
- _delirium 12y agoThis is occasionally used as an argument in favor of cheaper or free public transit: that even from a self-interest perspective, it makes sense for road users to subsidize public transit, as a way of effectively paying other people to get off the roads and out of their way. However most road users don't seem to see it that way.
- TheCoelacanth 12y agoAs with most articles from the Onion, there is an element of truth, but if you look at a city with good public transit options (NYC is the only one in the US) over 50% of commuters travel by public transit. If you look at cities with adequate but not great public transit options (DC, Boston or San Francisco) more than 30% of commuters travel by public transit.
- tormeh 12y agoPeople like me, who use mass transit, don't care about traffic congestion. Queue all you want. I just want more mass transit because travel by mass transit happens in constant time regardless of the amount of travelers (within reasonable bounds. Carriages do get full eventually).
- martinald 12y agoThe other benefit is being able to do something useful on the commute too. I can usually get through all my morning's emails on the train into work. This is much better than sitting behind a wheel for 1hr+ a day doing nothing.
- melling 12y agoPeople drive usually because it's either faster and/or cheaper. Right? I'd rather not intentionally make it expensive to drive so solve for X... Faster and cheaper... Everyone wants to save money and get home sooner.
- pdonis 12y agoPeople drive usually because it's either faster and/or cheaper. Right? Or because it gives more freedom--you're not restricted to particular routes or particular times. Mass transit can beat driving on all these metrics (speed, price, and freedom of travel) when the population density is high enough that it's cost-effective for mass transit to have dense coverage, so that you're never more than a short walk from a train station or a bus stop. But many people (including me) don't want to live in a place with that high a population density. That's ultimately why mass transit hasn't caught on in the US the way it has in other countries.
- melling 12y agoI thought that it went without saying that we were discussing mass transit in densely populated areas. If you don't live in such a place, you probably don't have 9 lanes of road either. As for why it hasn't caught on, it's because it's incomplete and inconvenient for most people. Even where it works, it's still not great. Ever take a slow bus across town in Manhattan? It's faster to walk.
- pdonis 12y agoI thought that it went without saying that we were discussing mass transit in densely populated areas. If you don't live in such a place, you probably don't have 9 lanes of road either. The 9-lane roads in metropolitan areas aren't confined to the densely populated areas; in fact, many of them are there only because so many people commute from the less densely populated suburbs to the densely populated inner city to work, instead of living in the inner city where they could easily take mass transit.
- ido 12y ago