3 ms·
Your calculation doesn't take into account cost of production. Which is close to zero, provided you're willing to lock up a whole bunch of women as baby factor
by XorNot 12y ago
Your calculation doesn't take into account cost of production.
Which is close to zero, provided you're willing to lock up a whole bunch of women as baby factories and go bottom-dollar of keeping the livestock fed.
Organs are considered valuable because it's illegal to sell them, the black market price doesn't reflect a potential market price. You also aren't de-rating the general worth of human lives in a society where organ harvesting like this were common place.
Or to put it another way: there's so much insanely wrong with this that it's the height of tech-minded naivete to think what you've come up with is a meaningful number.
- YokoZar 12y agoLet's not conflate cost and value here. The price people pay for my blood is at least the value to them. The same goes for my labor. I'd say the buyer gets a greater value per dollar paid from my lifesaving blood than they do from my relatively mundane laboring. By that reasoning I'm more valuable as spare parts, not less. The implication of the calculation isn't nearly as sweeping as you think, it's merely that more people should donate blood. Especially if it has low "cost" to them compared to others (say, because they're not queasy about it). Given what we know about what people are willing to pay for both, I think it's fairly clear what society values more. If an evil genie forced me to choose between reliving my life in a way that either deprived the world of my blood products or of my labor, and I knew that on the basis of money alone my blood was more valuable, then unless I was doing some particularly civic-minded work it would seem obvious I'd contribute more as an unemployed blood donor.
- XorNot 12y agoOf course then there'd be relatively few people doing your mundane laboring... That's my point: this calculation doesn't produce a meaningful number. It's why we regulate and exclude it from the market to start with: its get weird quickly, and its why my example is as it is - because it you really start thinking about it, making more blood isn't that difficult.