8 ms·
How you will not uncover Satoshi
- mcherm 12y agoNote to self: If I need to publish something and have it remain completely anonymous, convert it to ASCII TEXT. That is one of the few formats I understand well enough to be CERTAIN that it is free of metadata. Now all I have to worry about is how I can anonymously publish it, text style analysis, and how to include diagrams without resorting to ASCII drawings.
- supergauntlet 12y agoYou could always just release the raw LaTeX source and let people compile it themselves or something.
- lallysingh 12y agoOr build the latex in a clean VM
- willvarfar 12y agohttp://cm.bell-labs.com/who/ken/trust.html http://cm.bell-labs.com/who/ken/trust.html suggests you cannot trust anything!
- VMG 12y agoI'd imagine you reveal too much information with your personal latex writing style.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- alex_doom 12y agoThat's why I compose all my top secret documents in emoji. If anyone finds them they'll just assume it's gibberish from a 13yr old girl.
- dasil003 12y ago13-year-old girls are more fluent digital communicators than you or me.
- reitanqild 12y agoStrongly disagree. This is something you will hear from a lot of places, often from people who never were early adopters of neither mail, sms or skype etc.
- dasil003 12y agoYeah well that's not me... I've been on BBSes since 1988 and got my first proper internet shell account in 1991 when, incidentally, I was 13. The reason I made the comment is because it rubbed me the wrong way to cite 13-year-old girl talk as prototypical gibberish. Are 13-year-old girls generally excitable and potentially annoying? Yes. Do they talk in gibberish as a matter of course? No, that's a thoughtless sexist trope. And I'll place a blind bet that they text faster than you.
- reitanqild 12y agoAgree that the girl part should have been left out. Still think an average hn-er should be able to type faster and more correct on a normal keyboard than the average 13yo, regardless of gender.
- dasil003 12y agoYou're stacking the deck. Physical keyboards are ancient technology ;)
- 12y ago
- keithpeter 12y agoMight markdown be sufficiently basic to reduce style based fingerprinting? I suspect that the actual writing style apart from the markup would provide some clues.
- x1798DE 12y agoIt's not foolproof, but that does require that you have released a sufficiently large sample of LaTeX source under your real name (or something that can be traced to your real name) for comparison. Additionally, if you really want to release something typeset like that, but you're worried about fingerprinting, my guess is that it's not that hard to deliberately change your personal style by using a minimal set of packages and when necessary restricting yourself to the most popular packages. Even if your new personal style still ends up unique, it wouldn't match the fingerprint of anything you've released under your own name.
- chaos0 12y agoI wonder if there is a tool to obfuscate text to prevent analysis. one way I could think of is to use any online translation tool to translate to a foreign language and then back to english. and then fix the grammar slightly. the structure of the text should hopefully be different enough for any tool/human to recognize it's your style. is there an easier way to do this?
- graedus 12y agoYeah, some work has been done in this area, but I only know about it in passing via a mention in one of Jacob Appelbaum's talks. This seems like it might be a decent place to start: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-b0Ta9h62_E https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-b0Ta9h62_E
- bumblebeard 12y agoThere was an interesting talk about this (adversarial stylometry) at 28C3: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=C9SgAOcCm0I https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=C9SgAOcCm0I One of the methods they mentioned is machine translation, but they found that it wasn't terribly useful. It's a really neat talk and I highly recommend it. They also wrote some software to anonymize texts (Anonymouth) and their stylometry software (JStylo) is also freely available: http://events.ccc.de/congress/2011/Fahrplan/events/4781.en.html http://events.ccc.de/congress/2011/Fahrplan/events/4781.en.h...
- privong 12y agoThere is some free software available[0] to do stylometry analysis. And some software which purports to assist in anonymizing writings[1]. I've not really played around with either, so I can't speak to their ease of use and/or effectiveness. But it's at least somewhere to start. [0] http://evllabs.com/jgaap/w/index.php/Main_Page http://evllabs.com/jgaap/w/index.php/Main_Page [1] https://github.com/psal/anonymouth https://github.com/psal/anonymouth
- TeMPOraL 12y agoReminds me of a concept of "google translate fixed point", i.e. you translate between english and an foreign language back and forth until the translation stops changing.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- kruczek 12y agoDon't be too sure about ASCII text file either, it may still contain a bit of metadata like the BOM (although then technically it's not pure ASCII, but rather UTF, but still it means you have to check the encoding used by your favourite text editor).
- mcherm 12y agoThe BOM isn't exactly identifying information, but it's things like that (and encodings) that made me specify ASCII.
- jarman 12y agoIn case of UTF8, BOM isn't information at all, it's always the same 3 bytes (endianness mark is meaningless on byte-based encoding). And being added by default Windows plain text editor, it's fingerprinting usefulness is rather limited.
- slashdotaccount 12y agohttp://www.darkside.com.au/snow/ http://www.darkside.com.au/snow/ https://mat.boum.org/ https://mat.boum.org/ https://psal.cs.drexel.edu/index.php/JStylo-Anonymouth https://psal.cs.drexel.edu/index.php/JStylo-Anonymouth
- solomania9 12y agoAnd that's why I created Bitcoin Megaphone! http://bitcoinmegaphone.com http://bitcoinmegaphone.com
- rwallace 12y agoI think you'd be okay with any format, such as HTML, that you can eyeball in a plain text editor; you just need to eschew binary formats. So diagrams in SVG in preference to PNG?
- userbinator 12y agoAlthough the PDF spec says that the ID field is "optional", a lot of PDF-producing apps put it in anyway, and the way OoO calculates the ID is basically what the spec recommends, although it does say "Note that the calculation of the file IDs need not be reproducible. All that matters is that the file IDs are likely to be unique." This means that a CSPRNG would be a better choice, or even omitting the ID entirely. The Author/CreationDate/Creator/Producer/etc. fields are also completely optional despite, once again, the insistence of applications to put them in. There are "PDF anonymisers" out there, and I've written one myself too, but not all of them remove all this information. Interestingly enough there's a PDF from the NSA about removing metadata, which itself has most of the metadata removed, but not the ID nor creation/modification dates: http://www.nsa.gov/ia/_files/app/pdf_risks.pdf http://www.nsa.gov/ia/_files/app/pdf_risks.pdf
- vijayboyapati 12y agoThe author of the blog post makes the claim that Satoshi used Tor. I'm interested in what evidence there is for that. I googled and found a few people mentioning it, but no direct quote from Satoshi himself. I also searched the archives of his posts: https://www.google.com/webhp?sourceid=chrome-instant&ion=1&espv=2&ie=UTF-8#q=site:nakamotoinstitute.org+tor https://www.google.com/webhp?sourceid=chrome-instant&ion=1&e... Suppose that claim is not true, or that he was not fastidious in his use of Tor, it seems to me the email service provider would have logs on where his emails were originating from. From his original paper his email is satoshin@gmx.com I'm not sure who owns gmx.com, but I think it likely that if a sovereign state went after them, they would probably divulge the information. Not that I want this to happen, of course. I hope he's never uncovered and his legend grows with the success of Bitcoin. I hope he did use Tor. I'm just not certain there is evidence for it. Edit: I am not Satoshi Nakamoto, although I wish I was
- octotoad 12y agoI've been using GMX for a few years. It's owned by German ISP 'United Internet'.
- Taek 12y agogmx is very popular among tor users because you can create an account with no strings attached. No other emails are needed, no other phone numbers are needed, and signup takes only a few webpage loads (important when dealing with latencies of up to 45 seconds). This of course doesn't mean that Satoshi is a tor user, but a gmx account is consistent with typical tor behavior.
- mahouse 12y agoLast time I tried to create a gmx account under Tor, it told me I could not do it because my IP address was blacklisted.
- adamnemecek 12y agoWhat's your point? The fact that one exit node was blacklisted does not disprove anything.
- callesgg 12y agoIf someone finds Satoshi and publishes Satoshi's identity and Satoshi is a regular person. It would probably led to the destruction of Satoshi's life and not that unlikely Satoshi's death. With that in mind, i think it is kind of stupid to look for Satoshi.
- bruceb 12y agoHow would it lead to his death? Would his life change? Yes but there is no reason to think he would die.
- hellodevnull 12y agoThis is funny, a couple of months ago everybody was saying how publishing the identity of a man who holds millions in an anonymous virtual currency would most likely lead to somebody attempting to extort him and put his life great danger. Now this comment is getting downvoted.
- slashdotaccount 12y agohttps://www.techdirt.com/articles/20140224/17054826340/new-snowden-doc-reveals-how-gchqnsa-use-internet-to-manipulate-deceive-destroy-reputations.shtml https://www.techdirt.com/articles/20140224/17054826340/new-s...
- bruceb 12y agoPeople seem to forget there are lots of millionaires, multi millionaires, and billionaires around. For the most part in America, Europe, Japan, etc they are safe. But I guess at least being downvoted means someone is reading it.
- corpselord420 12y agoconsidering that bitcoin's prime utility over other virtual means of moving money is that you can launder it trivially, this places a little more incentive on it as a prize than real world assets
- erikb 12y agoWasn't there some article some time ago that Satoshi has been discovered? Was it shown to have been fake? At least on FB/G+ it went quite viral and I haven't seen anything since.
- damian2000 12y agoWrong guy ... from wikipedia ... The most high-profile speculation to date came in a March 6, 2014, article in the magazine Newsweek,[30] when journalist Leah McGrath Goodman identified Dorian Prentice Satoshi Nakamoto, a Japanese American man living in California, whose birth name is Satoshi Nakamoto. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Satoshi_Nakamoto#Dorian_Nakamoto http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Satoshi_Nakamoto#Dorian_Nakamot...
- MrBuddyCasino 12y agoStill seems fishy to me. The real Satoshi could have proved that he couldn't be that guy (using the blockchain or something else), but he didn't.
- nawitus 12y agoWhat's in it for the real Satoshi in that? By the way, Satoshi's old accunt was used to deny it. http://p2pfoundation.ning.com/profile/SatoshiNakamoto http://p2pfoundation.ning.com/profile/SatoshiNakamoto
- MrBuddyCasino 12y agoI know that, but that doesn't prove anything. - If Dorian was the real Satoshi, he would of course have used his 'real' account to try to disprove the claim. - If not, the only to way to know for sure that he is not the guy is for the other 'real' Satoshi to prove that it couldn't be Dorian. Simple as that. I agree that in the second case, the real Satoshi would not have a lot of incentive to prove the mistake. I'm not a conspiracy nut, I'm just saying that it has not been proven that Dorian is not the guy.
- nebulous1 12y agoI would have thought he'd use a computer solely for his Satoshi identity, in which case his username probably is satoshi. This is the best way to ensure your computer doesn't leak anything you don't want it to: don't give it the information in the first place.
- tomjen3 12y agoThen somebody stumbles over the computer and you are outed.
- nikcub 12y agoIt is somewhat good news for online anonymity that we don't know who Satoshi is. The amount of resources that have been poured into trying to uncover his identity is the equivalent of a medium-sized open source project. He has survived the army of geeks. The state of user-user or user-corporation anonymity is good. If you want to stay anonymous from other users or a corporation then you can gain anonymity by spending a few hours reading tutorials/guides online and then installing Tails or Whonix (both which solve the metadata problem in OP and a variety of other attacks) or an alternative homebrew solution (machine isolation/snapshots) and apply a level of discipline to isolate your identity. Last best OPSEC move Nakamoto made was to disappear - removes so many options in tracking him down. Hanging around and living off the credibility you've built with your anonymous persona is likely only going to breed complacency and the odds of slipping up increase each day (you see this in many cases) I doubt he'll ever be tracked down. I doubt even a gov investigation starting today (for whatever reason) with all the power it has would achieve it (unless more than one person knows the secret, in which case a US investigation has a broad range of legal methods to compel testimony and reveal it). I know a lot of people are sick of talking about Nakamoto and prefer to focus on what he produced (you can't even google his name anymore without 50% of the hits being about the Newsweek article), but being able to invent such an important piece of transformative technology and remain anonymous for so long, possible forever - is a brilliant accomplishment worthy of its own attention.
- coldpie 12y ago> installing Tails or Whonix (both which solve the metadata problem in OP and a variety of other attacks) I was surprised the article claims he was using Windows XP. There's a surprising number of leaks when using Windows software. These leaks are functional and can provide cool features, sure, but they're leaks nonetheless. For example, if you embed a file in a Powerpoint presentation, the PPTX file includes the original full path to the file. "C:\Users\JLewis\SecretWorkForTheNSA\FormattedForPublicRelease.txt". Obviously this isn't exclusive to Windows operating systems, but I feel other OS environments generally don't encourage oversharing like Windows does.
- superuser2 12y ago>I doubt even a gov investigation starting today (for whatever reason) with all the power it has would achieve it (unless more than one person knows the secret, in which case a US investigation has a broad range of legal methods to compel testimony and reveal it). As much as members of the Bitcoin community like to think of themselves as agitators, there were very clearly no laws broken here.
- hotpockets 12y agoAccording to I believe mike hearn, the whitepaper was not originally published as a pdf by satoshi. Someone else made the pdf.
- gwern 12y agoLink? I've never heard that, and the very first draft of the whitepaper (hosted on a now dead filesharing website) was also a PDF.
- Relys 12y agoWhy does everyone assume that Satoshi is a singular entity? What if Satoshi is legion? :/ Given that initial assumption, which large/government entities would be most likely to start such a project?