5 ms·
Misleading reporting. What he is an opponent of is bad patent reform. What people in software often forget is that patent trolls are almost always using softwa
by tzs 12y ago
Misleading reporting. What he is an opponent of is bad patent reform.
What people in software often forget is that patent trolls are almost always using software patents or business method patents. In industries whose patents are not on software or business methods, trolling activity is very low. The patent system in those industries generally is working reasonably well. The major players in those industries are not opposed to reform to deal with the troll problem, but they want it to be aimed narrowly so as to not disturb things in their industries.
- hyperpape 12y agoYou call it misleading reporting, but don't actually explain what was bad about the legislation he's opposed or how it could hurt industries where the patent system works. Not saying you're wrong, because I don't know the guy's work, but you haven't actually said anything to convince me.
- tzs 12y agoHere's what he submitted to Congress: http://www.patentsmatter.com/issue/pdfs/JohnsonSenateJudiciaryCommitteeStatement20131217.pdf http://www.patentsmatter.com/issue/pdfs/JohnsonSenateJudicia...
- 001sky 12y ago"The major players in those industries are not opposed to reform ... but they want it to be aimed narrowly so as to not disturb things in their industries." Non-disturbance of the status quo? I'm sure there is a more original definition of "regulatory capture" somewhere, but this is pretty good starting point. What about Patents in healthcare, drugs, science, universities...there are loads of things where the public is paying money to finance artificial mini-monopolies, especially ones extended beyond their initial term by gaming the current system in various ways.
- throwawaykf05 12y agoJeff John Roberts is up there with binarybits, techdirt and Joe Mullin (arstechnica) when it comes to misleading reporting on patents.
- DannyBee 12y agoSorry, but my experience working on reform for seven years tells me you are simply wrong. They want zero change. They see anything as a threat. Narrow targeting does not being them on board because they don't want to be narrowly targeted themselves in the future
- rayiner 12y agoHere's a neat chart describing various patent reform/anti-reform groups: http://www.vox.com/2014/4/28/5661526/grocery-stores-really-want-patent-reform-pharma-really-doesnt http://www.vox.com/2014/4/28/5661526/grocery-stores-really-w.... I think very few companies oppose, in principle, shutting down trolls.[1] What they're worried about is collateral damage. Microsoft or IBM don't really care about bond requirements or loser pays, because the cost of patent litigation is a drop in the bucket to them. They do care, however, about measures to make software unpatentable. Companies like Qualcomm have don't just rely on patents on technologies implemented in an ASIC, but also on patents on technologies implemented in software on the baseband processor. Making software unpatentable also raises questions about whether those same algorithms would be unpatentable if implemented in hardware. That said, I think in practice the ideological spectrum above collapses when you're talking about specific reform efforts. The Partnership for American Innovation is cagey about it's specific stance on reform, but it launched just a month before the most recent patent reform effort was killed, and days before published an article extolling the virtues of the existing patent system. Even though companies like Microsoft and Apple may not oppose patent reform in principle, they have nothing to gain from reform, and will in practice oppose any specific reform measure for fear of collateral consequences. [1] Defined as companies that abuse legal process to get settlements for cases they wouldn't win in court.