3 ms·
> Yes, but when the better is significantly better, and only a small marginal cost, it's worth doing. No, it's not significantly better, and I'm not sure if it
by gwern 12y ago
> Yes, but when the better is significantly better, and only a small marginal cost, it's worth doing.
No, it's not significantly better, and I'm not sure if it's better at all. Timestamping in the Bitcoin block chain is easy to use, cheap, convenient, highly secure, and relatively easy to explain to others. Your solution does not exist yet, and from the sound of it, even when it exists will have only one of those properties (highly secure), optimistically.
> though that was not the question asked.
Indeed. I don't expect humanity to be around in 100b years. I don't expect money to be around in 100b years. And I certainly don't expect SHA-256 or the elliptic curves used in Bitcoin to all remain intact over 100 billion years. (What's the longest a cryptographic hash in wide use has ever survived so far? 30 years? What about public key systems? 40 years maybe?)
> Actually I am and have:
I see. I upgrade my assessment of you from 'preachy asshole' to simply 'clueless person who doesn't understand people and their needs and builds castles in the air'.