4 ms·
> place where they can see any and all of their friends' updates. But that's the thing - Facebook have been manipulating your feed for years based on what it t
by madeofpalk 12y ago
> place where they can see any and all of their friends' updates.
But that's the thing - Facebook have been manipulating your feed for years based on what it thought you would be interested in: favoring popular posts, posts from those you interact with frequently, posts that it thinks could be popular etc. There's always been 'most recent' which is a more accurate timeline, and as far as I know Facebook never manipulated that.
While I neither agree nor disagree with whether the study was right or not, it wasnt with this study that they 'misrepresented people and their lives'. Facebook has been doing that for years!
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- walterbell 12y agoThe consequences of an activity are context dependent. http://civic.mit.edu/blog/petey/betraying-expectations-in-user-generated-censorship http://civic.mit.edu/blog/petey/betraying-expectations-in-us... "I've begun to think that if you, like me, found yourself surprised by these case studies, or nodding along with them as variations on a familiar theme of “gaming the system,” then it is because we came to the cases expecting or wanting something else. Some baseline behavior which ought to have been in action, some baseline norm which ought to have been observed, but wasn’t, rendering the results of the process suspect, “altered,” “manipulated,” “unnatural,” relative to some unaltered, unmanipulated, natural baseline, which would exist but for sin and sinners. But what are these baselines? Where do they come from? These are not, as they say, purely academic questions. The answers not only explain why we find some behavior problematic: they create the very possibility of the problem itself. The opportunity for subversion arises from the gap between intended and actual use of a system. James Grimmelmann once wrote that “if we must imagine intellectual property law, it must also imagine us.” When engineers design social systems they must imagine both possible uses and devise methods to make sure the uses are producing desired results, endlessly iterating upon the real to move it closer to the ideal."
- richcollins 12y agoThey ostensibly did that to make the experience better for users. In this case they did it to make them feel worse.
- true_religion 12y agoNo, they did it to study user reaction to a ratio of positive/negative posts. Its entirely possible that people would be more engaged if they received more negative news from their friends because of empathy, schadenfreude, or simply that knowing others aren't perfect provokes people to feel unashamed about posting. Whilst the experiment only looked at a single metric, facebook themselves likely looked at all metrics. Secondly, can we really say people felt 'worse'. Hypothetically, people may feel better if they see brief happy news in a sea of negative news, rather than seeing only happy news all the time with a few negatives since what is rare gets a stronger reaction. Do we know this is true or not? Not without a study...
- bjt 12y agoFrom the article, they know they felt worse because the subjects' own posts subsequently became more negative.
- MarkPNeyer 12y agothat doesn't mean they felt worse. maybe they were matching the tone they were seeing around them? if you're giggly at a funeral, you're going to piss off the people around you and make everyone feel worse. you can keep the giggliness inside and pretend to be all somber and serious without affecting your mood. http://www.today.com/health/stop-cheering-me-some-people-dont-want-hear-it-1D79852039 http://www.today.com/health/stop-cheering-me-some-people-don... if anything, you could argue that facebook helped the people posting negative statuses who got more views, comments, and likes on the things they were struggling with.
- visakanv 12y agoSometimes I write negative things after reading negative things, but it's ultimately an enriching experience for me.