3 ms·
> An altogether different matter of course is whether you agree with the Belmont report principles in the first place, or the adequacy of principlism for social
by gwern 12y ago
> An altogether different matter of course is whether you agree with the Belmont report principles in the first place, or the adequacy of principlism for social science research in general
Absolutely. I've always found 'informed consent' to be a bizarre and ill-founded moral concept, with no place in consequentialist ethics, and this is an example of why: so, here is an experiment, of great importance to our understanding of social interactions & community design, where the intervention was just one of countless influences on the subjects and not a large one at that (what about the 'lack of informed consent' that is inherent with every form of advertising?), which did not harm them, and yet... this is somehow bad? Why? Uh, because 'informed consent!'
It all seems like so much angel-counting, when I read absurdities like "Near-Death-Experience Experiment: Ethical Concerns" http://www.csicop.org/si/show/nde_experiment_ethical_concerns/ http://www.csicop.org/si/show/nde_experiment_ethical_concern...