4 ms·
> but they are also docile in the face of decline and confused about possible solutions. Hanauer fears mobs heading for the castles of Greenwich and Palo Alto,
by rdtsc 12y ago
> but they are also docile in the face of decline and confused about possible solutions. Hanauer fears mobs heading for the castles of Greenwich and Palo Alto, but America’s disaffected these days are more likely to vent their rage behind closed doors as they shake their fists at Fox News or MSNBC and leave cranky
They are docile, that is true. Slavoj Zizek, which is a madman, pop-psychologist, and I often don't agree with, did say something I agree with in one of this talks and that is the tyranny of democracy. Basically the idea that people are managed, treated and groomed ideologically to vote against their own interests. At the end of the day the system on paper is democratic and people believe they are free and have all the possible choices available to them, people can vote, can impeach, recall senators etc etc. Yet so many end up voting against their own interests. In a certain way he makes the case that countries with officially un-free speech and human right have healthier people (psychologically speaking) because everyone knows that they are not free and often they internalize and understand what they are giving up in exchange for security, bread and shelter.
I think it is very instructive to watch or talk to people who watch Fox News or any conservative show, or perhaps just as likely an another ideological show (leftist or liberal too) and observe how propaganda works. Once you start seeing through it it becomes comical and amusing. But one man's comedy and theater is another man's reality.
Another anecdote came from Chomsky, I think, and it was about how those in power (and this doesn't have to be just money it could be power to regulate or control or police etc) are devout closeted Marxists. Well how so, a lot of them a on the complete opposite spectrum usually? Well the twist is instead of identifying with the working class they just identify with the ruling class and act accordingly -- protect their interests, they understand what owning the means of production is, understand how the labor market works and exploit it, they lobby for legislation in their favor, privatize sectors of what used to be owned and managed by the government -- prisons, etc etc. All of that has to be done concurrently with maintaining ideological control over people.
- foolrush 12y agoEgads. Slavoj Žižek is not a madman nor even remotely summons your derogatory term “pop”. He is one of the most topical and compelling minds in the Continental Philosophy stream. As any good Continental Philosopher, he highlights the seeming invisible connections between the hegemony of an ideological system and the unfortunate byproducts. You likely don't agree with him because he is precisely a counterpoint to the Rationalist Noam Chomskys out there. Note, Rationalist is not an accolade here, but rather a reference to one of the other strains of philosophy.
- rdtsc 12y agoI have to say, I do like to listen to him but I treat it more as entertainment. Granted I also haven't read many of his serious books. I like he uses examples and jokes, it make for a very interesting listening experience. But a lot links and conclusions seem rather strenuous. Like you know looking at how toilets are designed and infer political bias from it, or you know Sound Of Music is Nazi Propaganda is disguise.