6 ms·
Evidence of massive-scale emotional contagion through social networks
- pitchups 12y agoSometimes one can't help but wonder if the long term impact of everyone being connected, all the time, is not going to be one planet-scale hive mind!
- chenelson 12y agoHodos ano kato.
- mtdewcmu 12y agoThe same probably applies to TV, radio, newspapers, novels, and plays. So I don't think anyone should panic.
- leorocky 12y agoI've read about studies where just seeing someone else smile and be happy makes others who see it also happier. Like a happy person gets on a bus full of less than happy people and the entire bus ends up happier. I don't think this is really that new, except maybe to the degree it scales the distribution. I imagine words create a smaller impact than a face to face encounter, but I'll leave that to a study to figure out.
- bphogan 12y agoThe person who mentored me when I first became a college instructor mentioned the importance of appearing warm and engaging on the first day to remove anxiety of the new students. There's probably some truth to that "just seeing someone else smile" thing. :)
- mjklin 12y agoGood old P-nas
- jbattle 12y agoIt seems far more plausible people are picking up behavioral norms than being emotionally influenced. If none of your friends ever complain on facebook, are you going to be the one "grump"? I didnt read the study admittedly but this feels off. I thought it was axiomatic by now that what people post to facebook is 90% about how people want to be percieved, not who they really are.
- jmromer 12y agoI think that heuristic attributes more foresight to people than they actually exercise in practice. It's more like the impressions one anticipates making on others create incentives and disincentives that shape behavior...but this applies offline as well. Even IRL, everyone's behavior tends to be bounded by "how people want to be perceived, not who they really are."
- msane 12y agoSure, the reason why people replicate each other's sentiments is often to be normative. The interesting part about publicly expressed sentiments though is that they tend to be subconsciously adopted by those expressing them even in the case of initial insincerity. This is essentially Cialdini's consistency principle.
- danso 12y agoThere's a related test that is far more basic, and more directly relevant to Facebook's bottom line, that must have been studied at some point: does seeing good/negative things in the newsfeed affect a user's re-visit behavior? If I had to take a cynical guess, I would guess that negativity, and even tragedy, would draw people in more...for the same reason that conflict makes both fiction and non-fiction media interesting. I'm also going to cynically guess that Facebook has probably studied this but probably doesn't find it in their best interest to reveal the optimal mix of emotion. Although positivity/negativity may be a minor factor compared to the other factors that influence what shows up on your feed...for me, my feed seems to be heavily weighted toward: "the last 20 people you've interacted with on Facebook"
- Swizec 12y ago> for me, my feed seems to be heavily weighted toward: "the last 20 people you've interacted with on Facebook" Lucky. For me it's more like "the last 34543532514543254 brands you happened to glance at, oh and you have like 3 friends who sometimes post stuff too" Except for profile picture changes. You see every single bloody profile picture change. Every single one of them.
- Swizec 12y agoBreaking news: human culture spreads through social contact. It's almost like we're social animals or something. Although granted, it's very interesting that with modern distribution methods the effects can span continents rather than villages.
- jacquesm 12y agoYou'd say the 'social' in social networks would give the game away.
- ivv 12y agoThe study basically concludes that reading sad stuff makes one sad, which in turn makes one post stuff that is also sad. The unique thing about it is that one is both a reader and an author. Otherwise, movie and TV studios have been testing and tweaking movies for a particular emotional effect since forever.
- ChuckMcM 12y agoAlthough perhaps more importantly that constant exposure to emotional bias can put that bias in you. There was a much less credible study of whether or not watching Fox News made you more conservative (the unspoken threat there was that watching any consistently biased narrative would align you to that narrative) but the Facebook study has better statistics. So one wonders if all the kids programming is consistently biased towards some topic, will it bias that generation? Sort of a weird inception sort of hypothesis. For me it just confirmed my own experience that being around people who are sad makes me feel sad (not sure if I'm sad for them or me, but what ever) and so being optimistic around people might keep them going. But again not a lot of science there.
- shawn-butler 12y ago>>> As such, it was consistent with Facebook’s Data Use Policy, to which all users agree prior to creating an account on Facebook, constituting informed consent for this research >>> Wait, what?
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- judk 12y agoIt's a shame that a reputable journal accepted the bogus claim of "informed consent". Not a big deal in an observational study like this, but sets a horrible precedent for EULA-based fraudulent claims of informed consent.
- cjbprime 12y agoPNAS' policies[1] say that experiments on humans must go through review by an ethics board before they will publish them, so it's especially strange that PNAS published this without any apparent review (none is mentioned in the paper). It's not up to the researchers to decide whether informed consent was obtained, it's up to the ethics board. [1]: http://www.pnas.org/site/authors/journal.xhtml http://www.pnas.org/site/authors/journal.xhtml (vii)
- tomjen3 12y agoWhere do you complain, though? Do you write a stern letter to the editor?
- GrumpySimon 12y agoHaving submitted to that journal before, I suspect the authors just ticked a check box that said something like "Relevant ethics approval was obtained for this paper".
- jtwaleson 12y agoOh wow, what if someone in the negatively influenced group committed suicide? It would be unlikely that the tinkering actually caused the suicide, but the media would probably jump to this conclusion quickly.
- GrumpySimon 12y agoOr flip it around - what if the next time Facebook sees you post 5 negative things in a row, it decides to positively skew what it shows you? i.e. trying to cheer up depressed people and stop suicide. It's creepy, eh?
- jtwaleson 12y agoBoth sides are really creepy. A possible benefit of this experiment is gaining more insight into detecting whether people are happy or sad. Advertisers might soon be able to adapt their ads to a user's mood, thereby reinforcing the artificial connection between the company and the user. Users will feel like the brand really understands them.
- egypturnash 12y agoThat's pretty damn creepy too.
- nardi 12y agoThis study has an enormous sample size, but an incredibly small effect. They're measuring effects of less than 0.1%. Admittedly, they have the statistical power to do this, but it's not a very impressive result. "Reading Others' Emotional Posts on Social Networks Can Very, Very Slightly Affect Your Mood" doesn't sound as cool.
- pknight 12y agoA "small" effect size doesn't make it any less interesting or less impressive. If anything it underlines how even the most trivial human interactions can make a meaningful impact, positively or negatively.
- thaumasiotes 12y agoHuh? A small effect size is the opposite of a meaningful impact.
- pknight 12y agoNo, what is meaningful is not what the effect size (a number) is measuring, it's just a statistical metric. So in this case, I think it's clearly meaningful if humans have the power to impact other humans inner-state non-verbally. For example, if one smile to a stranger makes their inner-state more positive, that's impactful and they then have the same power for their emotional state to impact others. A trivial encounter can, in such, make a significant positive or negative impact. This study proves that the effect is extremely robust in both directions. Effect size tends to get smaller the bigger the sample size for any kind of psychological/sociological study. This was a study of over half a million N, most studies use < 1000. In other words, the effect size is impressive despite looking small. Side note: It's interesting to note that paranormal researchers often get criticized for finding small effect sizes in their studies. (Part of that is thinking that it's more likely due to chance or noise) For all intents and purposes, if you believe the effect to be real but small, it would still have paradigm changing consequences on how we view the way brains work, a radical departure from what mainstream science currently believes. It's another example of why a small effect size can be incredibly interesting, course altering even.
- textient 12y agoWe believe this is a significant finding . The contagion effect should be seriously looked at by organisations/brand which is engaging its (prospective) customers significantly through social media channels for marketing, campaigns and reputation management. A number of organisations today are involved in setting up dedicated customer care handles on FB,Twitter,G+ so on.. Social media is increasingly transferring the power to the end users/customers. Perhaps it's high time for organisations to make sure that their business creates either a positive or a negative contagion effect on FB and other social channels. The contagion effect also means that probably we have more work to do on Social media monitoring and analysis front going forward!
- dschiptsov 12y agoWanna see emotional contagion? Try /b/.