6 ms·
At the limit, I'm not sure those two are distinguishable. There was a story a while back about a law firm that discovered its escrow account was empty, even th
by wpietri 12y ago
At the limit, I'm not sure those two are distinguishable.
There was a story a while back about a law firm that discovered its escrow account was empty, even though it should have had millions in it. Turns out a legal secretary had gotten caught up in a Nigerian scam. She started out sending a small amount of her own money. They'd tell her they just needed a little more and then she'd get it all back plus a lot more. As she got deeper in trouble, at some point she started "borrowing" from her employer. Incompetence led to pressure that created ethical failure.
My guess (as uninformed as anybody's) is that Karpeles started out merely incompetent and with underdeveloped ethics. As he got in deeper, he just focused on trying to stay out of trouble in the short term. That led to massive snowballing of problems. His very modest helpings of competence and ethical backbone were quickly overrun, demoted in priority to the same level as getting enough niacin in his diet. The best liars I know aren't people who know that they're lying; they're people who focus on saying what you want to hear while ignoring entirely what the truth might be.
For those unfamiliar with the Dunning-Kruger effect, it also seems relevant here: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dunning%E2%80%93Kruger_effect http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dunning%E2%80%93Kruger_effect
- argc 12y agoSeems likely, any references that support your theory? Many people on /r/bitcoin and such places seemed to think that he outright stole it, but could be pure speculation (I didn't follow the story, don't take my word for it).
- streptomycin 12y agoThe theory I've heard along those lines is that he lost the Bitcoins years ago due to incompetence and was trying to make back the losses so that he wouldn't have to own up to it. You can imagine how that strategy might have spiraled out of control as the price of Bitcoins increased. It's mostly speculation. But nearly everything we know at this point is speculation, other than that Karpeles has a history of both technical and ethical shortcomings, which basically means that anything is possible.
- Cyther606 12y agoThis is because embezzlement is rampant in the Bitcoin space, e.g.: Inputs.io, TradeFortress, MyBitcoin, Silk Road 2.0, GBL, I could go on. Embezzlement, as in you get "hacked", oops, we lost everyone's money, everyone move along, nothing to see here. Anyone who thinks Mark Karpeles isn't guilty of embezzlement at a minimum - MINIMUM - just isn't viewing the situation in light of the massive amounts of operator fraud that have historically taken place, not to mention copious amounts of evidence suggesting Mark Karpeles' talking points have been entirely fabricated from the beginning. Remember, he stole over a _billion_ dollars: 850,000 * 1200. He only relinquished control of 200,000 of those 850,000 after being called out on it by the community. At this point the legal system is the least of Karpeles' worries.
- michaelt 12y agoWhile you're right that embezzlement is rampant, it's possible the embezzlement was by an employee rather than Karpelès himself. It doesn't sound like they had very strict change control policies.
- danielweber 12y agoA private key is 256 bits, right? A determined insider given the chance to visually see the key once per day could probably take the whole thing out in his brain in a few weeks.
- aianus 12y agoWhy would he want to be a laughingstock digital billionaire under police scrutiny in bankruptcy court when he's already a successful business owner with tens of millions? It really doesn't make sense that he up and decided to steal them. If he did it he'll die having spent less of his stolen fortune than he would have spent of his legitimate fortune. Seems a lot more likely he's an idiot who got in over his head.
- Cyther606 12y agoSorry, but your line of thinking takes for granted that criminality doesn't pay. On the contrary. Having a hidden fortune is more valuable than having a pubilc fortune, objectively in that you pay less taxes and forego frivilous lawsuits and subjectively in that you can walk around less paranoid of kidnappings. Second of all, there's no way to stop Karpeles from mixing his coins. People who don't have much experience using Bitcoin are often operating in the PayPal model, where it takes a trusted third party to spend your money and even if not, the other person is known. In the Bitcoin space, there is no trusted third party, and if your coins are mixed and you and the other person are behind Tor, there's effectively no identifiable information involved in the transaction. Embezzling Bitcoins is the perfect crime. As has been mentioned already, Karpeles has a history of computer fraud, so embezzling digital money would be right up his alley. He had the means, motive and opportunity to do so. When you consider the rampant embezzlement in a historical context ... it's pretty much case closed. Your argument boils down to "this time it's different". Also, laughing stock digital billionaire? Sorry but there's no such thing as a laughing stock billionaire. I'd take a billion knowing it would make me the "laughing stock" of the world, and so would anyone with a brain. If the community hadn't called Karpeles out on using transaction malleability as a fictional excuse for losing 850,000 BTC, and we had all believed Karpeles, he would in all likelihood be looking at Japanese bankruptcy court followed by a lifetime of traveling the world with a hidden fortune rivaling Satoshi's.
- danielweber 12y agoWithout any specific evidence, the null hypothesis ought be "did small mistakes that kept on compounding on themselves." It's quite normal human behavior. If there were an oracle that could answer, I'd comfortably bet even odds that he started out with some rather small mistake, and then thought "well, I just need to keep things afloat a while to cover for it, and then we will all be good." Oh, I'll borrow a little money from my spouse. Oh, I'll just take some money from my neighbor without him knowing, but I'll get it back and return it to him later. Lots of gambling addicts flame out this way, and my gut tells me that the Bitcoin community has more than its fair share of gambling-addictive personalities.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- AJ007 12y agoFor those effected, the two are not distinguishable. If the bank robs you or loses your money, it is still a loss. When it comes to the law, neither is "I don't know" perhaps gives some lenience at sentencing. When your business involves holding money on deposit for people, you have a very high moral and legal standard to follow. Unfortunately the very legal leverage and fractional reserve lending by financial institutions makes that line very blurry. A single technical misstep and you are now an insolvent ponzi scheme. Being lazy or "over your head" in this area is like laying down in front of a moving truck. US laws relating to money laundering and finance are very strict, accidents and lapses still lead to convictions. I don't know anything about Japanese law. I'll take a page from the BNP Paribas case and say that because Mt Gox used US dollars it falls under US jurisdiction and must also follow US law, not just Japan's.
- tim333 12y agoThere's a critical difference in this case. If the lost bitcoins are now in the possession of some random hackers then Karpeles is incompetent. If they are in fact effectively in the possession of Karpeles then he is a competent thief. It's hard to tell but in the future they may catch him cashing some coins in to buy a yacht or pay the rent or some such at which point it would be distinguishable in a meaningful way. Being in Japan I guess he'd get away with it but in the US they'd be tapping his phones and so on.