3 ms·
Obligatory link to Jason Calcanis's "Why I Emplyed a Felon", from 2009: http://calacanis.com/2009/03/05/why-i-employed-a-felon/ http://calacanis.com/2009/03/05
by danso 12y ago
Obligatory link to Jason Calcanis's "Why I Emplyed a Felon", from 2009:
http://calacanis.com/2009/03/05/why-i-employed-a-felon/ http://calacanis.com/2009/03/05/why-i-employed-a-felon/
-----
Excerpt:
> However, Mark screwed up by not doing a simple Google search on John’s name. If Mark had, he would have easily found out about these crimes, we would never have hired John, and I would not be writing this letter. Why would we even take the risk of hiring a felon hacker? No one would, right?
Months after John’s hiring, our VP of Operations found out about the crimes John had committed. We sat down with John and learned about what he did when he was younger, how he was abused as a child, his anger issues, and how he found some level of peace in being part of the team at Mahalo.
Now I was left with the decision to fire John on the spot and cut my losses and responsibility. This was the easy choice, obviously. If I really wanted to cover my butt, I could turn on one of my best friends, Mark Jeffrey, and fire him for making the only mistake he’s ever made working for me. The other option was to keep John on and deal with the potential firestorm of criticism that we’re now facing.
I chose to put my job and reputation on the line and keep John employed.
At this moment, I’m honestly glad we didn’t know about what John did when we hired him and I’m happy we’ve kept him on board. It’s taught me a lot about society, computer crime and rehabilitation. In John, I see almost every computer programmer from my time “hacking” on BBSes as a kid, attending hacker conferences and hiring “white hat” hackers for a living.
Almost all talented developers push the envelope when they’re young. Anyone in technology knows this dark, dirty little secret
------
- tptacek 12y agoThere's not much to learn from Calacanis' story, unfortunately. Scott Arciszewski's story is very sympathetic. He crossed an invisible (and very poorly understood) line in poking at websites for security flaws. He made a mistake that's very easy to understand, and, while I don't share his politics, it's straightforward to see how someone could get caught up in the moment --- in this case the original Assange drama --- and find themselves in a perfect storm of legal drama. Scott barely "pushed the envelope" at all, and appears to have just been very unlucky. Calacanis' employee is much less sympathetic. He was convicted of running a botnet and, IIRC, using it to steal money from victims. That employee was put into a role where he was given access to the authentication information of thousands of users. Calacanis' employee didn't "push the envelope". He tore it open, took the money from inside it, and passed some of it out to his friends. Be careful about false equivalences. The comparison you're making here is very unfair to Arciszewski.
- danso 12y agoI didn't mean to imply equivalence between the two employees, but just giving one (well-known, and perhaps not widely applicable) example of an employer's mindset on this. Though the fact that Calcanis is a more public figure (and thus subject to more scrutiny by the press), and his employee had more egregiously stepped over the line, seems to be a scenario in which a hire of a felon was less likely than the scenario the OP faces.