3 ms·
Seems rather sad state of our Patent system here in the US where a 19 year old with no prior technical background, who was a Chemical Engineering student, a so
by Alupis 12y ago
Seems rather sad state of our Patent system here in the US where a 19 year old with no prior technical background, who was a Chemical Engineering student, a sophomore no less (meaning barely finished or finishing General Ed. requirements and just starting Major courses), can write and file for a highly-technical patent involving radios, sensors, embedded devices, and the like.
> And we could put a cellphone chip on it, and it could telemeter out to the doctor or the patient what was going on.
It's very doubtful she understood how any of that works, or would work in her product/patent.
Underlying story seems it's absurd this was patent-able.
- jbail 12y agoI think you're underestimating her intelligence and capabilities. Clearly she had the background and the initiative. There are super smart and dedicated people out there. She sounds like one of them. Beyond that, I'm not sure if the patent is absurd or not...but I definitely don't think its absurd for a 19 year old woman to write up and be awarded a patent.
- Alupis 12y agoNo, I was meaning I find it highly unlikely she understood or could actually implement the technology behind her patent. A 19 year old, no matter how smart, is not likely to have a thorough enough background to understand all of the related technologies involved in this patent. This is a medical device, and has to be "done right", or people can be injured or worse. I don't expect even a top-tier CS student could pull it off. I'm not attempting to discredit her intelligence, just pointing out she seems to have been/is an "idea guy". We've all run into "idea guys", they'll pitch a great idea with all this elaborate stuff, but then can't execute on it without outside help. Perhaps she got help, who knows? A patent is, more-or-less, a mere idea (which is absurd in it's own right, ideas should not be patentable imho). So, you are right, it's not "absurd for a 19 year old [gender-is-regardless] to write up and be awarded a patent", it's absurd it was patentable in the first place.
- MaysonL 12y agoBack in 1963, I was tutored in calculus by a 15-year old who won that year's Science Talent Search for his research in nuclear magnetic resonance. He had completed essentially all of undergrad math and physics. I think you have a badly warped view of what is possible for smart people, whatever age.
- mreiland 12y agoNo, I think there's a reason she recruited a professor in that industry who had well over 30 years of experience. That doesn't detract from her intelligence, but I think it's safe to say she would have simply done it herself if she could have. I think simply describing her as an "idea person" is also missing the mark, but so are you. She isn't a magician, she's just a person. And considering she was 19 and in a normal college curriculum, it's very likely her talent is not in being super smart, but in being able to come at a problem sideways.
- pessimizer 12y agoOr in being rich and well-connected.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- ghshephard 12y agoDepends on how motivated the 19 year old was, and how much freedom they had to focus on what was important to them. By the age of 14 or 15, most intelligent and motivated people have enough education to start learning advanced processes and systems. Say you start at 14, if you are focussed, by the time you are 19, you will have had 12,000+ hours of opportunity to develop expertise in your field. And Ms. Holmes sounds very capable (Learned Mandarin in her spare time as a teenager, as a result spent a summer at the Genome Institute in Singapore,etc, etc,...) I would expect that there is a significant (if not excessively large) population of 19 year olds out there that can not only invent, and understand, but also design, and prototype advanced technological platforms of the same complexity identified in this patent. We had a 13 year old in my Computing Science Undergraduate course at SFU who just absorbed and aced every math course he encountered, zero effort at homework or note taking. Some people are capable of great accomplishments at a very young age, and strictly speaking, 19 is not particularly young.
- uireiu89 12y agoare you radical feminist you idiot ? Why are you making gender issue out of nothing ? Put your feminist hat down sometime and see others as human.
- jacquesm 12y ago> Seems rather sad state of our Patent system here in the US where a 19 year old with no prior technical background, who was a Chemical Engineering student, a sophomore no less (meaning barely finished or finishing General Ed. requirements and just starting Major courses), can write and file for a highly-technical patent involving radios, sensors, embedded devices, and the like. > It's very doubtful she understood how any of that works, or would work in her product/patent. I'm not quite sure if I understand you right, do you mean to suggest she should not be able to apply for patents because she's young or because she's a woman or both?
- Alupis 12y agoI'm really not sure why you are attempting to make this a gender issue. If you re-read my comment, gender is not even approached. To summarize my post - I was making a statement regarding how absurd (imho) it is that someone can patent something they are not technically capable of even implementing. It is patentable because here in the US, patents are really just "ideas", so you don't have to actually implement the patent, just think it up. I doubt a 19 year old sophomore chemical engineering student would have the technical background to actually implement this patent... alluding to, she was just another "idea guy".
- jacquesm 12y agoYou should not be questioning the patent based on the person but on the contents of the patent. I know some 19 year olds that would absolutely astound you with what they are capable of. One of the things this website has taught me is to completely overlook the age factor.
- Alupis 12y agoTo implement something described in the article, it requires experience, not intelligence, nor age. It's the experience that is in question. There is a lot of radically different and unique technologies that would be required to be mastered in order to implement a medical device such as this, safely and reliably. Not to mention extreme business prowess to wiggle ones way into a tightly guarded community such as the medical industry. (It's likely she brought in outside help to do the actual implementation, which is normal, other commenters have noted that she came from a family with great means, which would extend her reach by a great margin). Originally, I was commenting on it being absurd that in the US, one can patent an idea that one has no clue how to actually implement/build. Perhaps that was not the case here (although it seems to be), but unfortunately that is the case for an awful lot of patents here in the states. Anyone can think something up -- but to actually do it... that's a whole different beast.
- DaniFong 12y agoSeems like a rather sad state of Hacker News when there is so much doubt heaped on a woman's technical ability just because of her age, and the fact she was unlikely to have completed the relevant formal education. There is rarely an invention 101. Many people can teach themselves.
- Alupis 12y agoI think I should make it clear -- this is not a gender issue. Let's stop trying to make it one. It, perhaps, is a age issue, sure. I have my doubts that an 19 year old chemical engineering student would have enough technical background to implement: radios, embedded systems, various sensors, medical analysis algorithms, database usage, notifications systems, knowledge of cellular technology, agreements with hospitals and insurance companies, etc. However, here in the US, a patent is more-or-less just an idea -- meaning, one can think-up something, and patent it. That is valid. My thoughts are, the article was obviously a puffy PR piece, designed to make the company look good. I believe she was an "idea guy" and was awarded a patent for that idea, then likely brought in outside help to implement it... which is very very common.
- DaniFong 12y agoWell, you'd be mistaken. There are people who learn 3, heck, even 10 times faster than your standard bright university student, in large part because they needn't wait for formal instruction. You have probably learned at this pace on certain topics. Such people can defy the standardized logic of what's possible by a certain age. For example, Howard Hughes: Showing great aptitude in engineering at an early age, Hughes, Jr. built Houston's first "wireless" or radio transmitter when he was 11 years old.[5] He went on to be one of the first licensed ham radio operators in Houston, having the assigned callsign, W5CY (originally 5CY). [6] At 12, Hughes was photographed in the local newspaper, identified as being the first boy in Houston to have a "motorized" bicycle, which he had built himself from parts taken from his father's steam engine.[7] He was an indifferent student with a liking for mathematics, flying, and things mechanical, taking his first flying lesson at 14 and later auditing math and aeronautical engineering courses at Caltech.[5][7] Philo T. Farnsworth: Farnsworth excelled in chemistry and physics at Rigby High School. He asked his high school science teacher, Justin Tolman, for advice about an electronic television system he was contemplating. He provided the teacher with sketches and diagrams covering several blackboards to show how it might be accomplished electronically. He asked his teacher if he should go ahead with his ideas, and he was encouraged to do so.[13] One of the drawings he did on a blackboard for his chemistry teacher was recalled and reproduced for a patent interference case between Farnsworth and Radio Corporation of America (RCA).[14]
- ladytron 12y agoWith "resources" and "consultants, work for hire" anyone with funds can write a pretty decent patent application and drive it through the system. When you file a patent application you can say it's pending, raise funds on it, get yourself a decent engineer, and file a continuation later with more "meat". Patents are an expensive game.
- spartango 12y agoI filed a patent at age 16; there are no laws governing how old you must be to file, and rightfully so. While you may stereotype young people as being unready to write and file patents--and perhaps many are--at least some have developed the right skills and technical knowledge to do so. Judge the patents on their own merits, not their authors.
- Centigonal 12y agoSince there's been so much arguing back and forth about this patent and its legitimacy and what it says about the state of the US patent system, I thought it might be a little useful to post a link to the patent in question: https://www.google.com/patents/WO2005025413A3?cl=en&dq=ininventor:%22Elizabeth+A.+Holmes%22&hl=en&sa=X&ei=nu-sU8uqI46VyASChIDQAg&ved=0CBwQ6AEwAA https://www.google.com/patents/WO2005025413A3?cl=en&dq=ininv... Here's a search of all the patents with Holmes as an inventor: https://www.google.com/search?tbo=p&tbm=pts&hl=en&q=ininventor:%22Elizabeth+A.+Holmes%22#hl=en&q=ininventor%3A%22Elizabeth+A.+Holmes%22&safe=off&tbm=pts&tbs=sbdo:1 https://www.google.com/search?tbo=p&tbm=pts&hl=en&q=ininvent... I hope this helps ground the discussion in fact to some extent.
- presty 12y agoHey, look at this website http://www.thielfellowship.org/home/ http://www.thielfellowship.org/home/ You might find some under-20s that could be in the same category as Elizabeth Holmes.