3 ms·
Not related,but I would like to mention this regardless: >>No party will suggest the rational solutions: if hard work makes us rich, let’s tax inheritance at 8
by gambiting 12y ago
Not related,but I would like to mention this regardless:
>>No party will suggest the rational solutions: if hard work makes us rich, let’s tax inheritance at 85%, so the children of rich men have to work hard too. But no: that would never do
I never understood this argument. I am not rich by any means,but why would my children have to pay 85% on things that I want to leave them?? It's idiotic - I worked hard to earn those things,why would the government want 85% of their value?? On what basis and logical reason? To make my children "less lazy" by doing so?? They can mind their own children - I will mind mine.
- rjaco31 12y agoYou want to give money/goods to your children so that they have a easier life and need to work less to get the same decent life as anybody. This is totally valid, up to a certain point. Let's take the other extrem, when a child could inherit enough to get a better life without working than someone working his whole life. There is absolutely no need of such a concentration of wealth. That's why inheritance should have a strongly progressive taxation rate.
- gambiting 12y ago>>when a child could inherit enough to get a better life without working than someone working his whole life Why not? If I, as a parent, worked hard enough to make life easy for my child, who are you to tell me that I can't do it?(I mean in general, don't take this personally) I have paid tax on everything that I made, bought, or built - why would they pay tax on the same things again?? Following your argument, we should stop giving our children absolutely anything - you could argue that someone's child should not be given a phone or a car,because it's unfair towards someone else who had to work for it,right? But then why do you care - I worked hard to buy those things to give to my children. Anything else is irrelevant. I can give you another example which makes me hate inheritance tax with passion - I know a family, which had a house which was owned by them for centuries. And then, when the parents died,they didn't have a lot of money, so the only thing left was that house. HMRC enters the scene -> children have to pay inheritance tax on the house. There is no money left,so they have to sell their family house, purely because people think it would be "unfair" for them to keep it. Absolute BS if you ask me.
- acheron 12y agof I, as a parent, worked hard enough to make life easy for my child, who are you to tell me that I can't do it? The point is to increase your children's (that is, everyone's) reliance on the government, of course. The ideal for statists would be to remove parents from the equation completely. You've read Brave New World, right?
- ForHackernews 12y agoIs this a parody of a libertarian comment? The point is that people should stand on their own two feet, and not coast through life on daddy's money (or government largesse, for that matter).
- gambiting 12y agoBut you are talking about extreme cases, where people inherit millions of dollars, and that's probably 0.1% of all inheritance cases. I am arguing that this would hit regular people with regular incomes. You save up $100,000 for your child to go to collage over 25 years of your career, and then happen to die? Well, shit son, your child only gets $15,000, rest is taken by the government to make life more fair. But hey, at least they are not coasting through life on their daddy's money, right?
- ForHackernews 12y ago> I am arguing that this would hit regular people with regular incomes. It won't, and it doesn't. You're misinformed on this topic. There's a blanket exemption for estates up to $5,000,000: http://www.irs.gov/Businesses/Small-Businesses-&-Self-Employed/Estate-Tax http://www.irs.gov/Businesses/Small-Businesses-&-Self-Employ... Nobody is interested in taxing your kid's college fund--we just don't want the Waltons running our country for the next 100 years: http://walmart1percent.org/family/ http://walmart1percent.org/family/
- gambiting 12y ago
- r3m6 12y agoSimple: We need taxes. The questions is only what kind of taxes. The inheritance tax is a very democratic tax and benefits society as a whole. And it is good for your kids. See also http://www.spectator.co.uk/features/269796/listen-to-adam-smith-inheritance-tax-is-good/ http://www.spectator.co.uk/features/269796/listen-to-adam-sm...
- jessaustin 12y agoIt might be fair and it might be progressive, but how is it "democratic"?
- JasonFruit 12y agoBecause it takes from a few people and gives to many. More people would vote for it than not.
- gambiting 12y agoAh, Robin Hood democracy. Of course villagers would vote to take away from the king and give to themselves. It all depends on the perspective - if a regular Joe Smith realized that his child will not be able to keep his house because they would never afford to pay 85% of its value in tax, they might not vote for such a law.
- JasonFruit 12y agoMere details. Certainly one could devise a tax code complex enough that Joe Smith couldn't hope to judge its effect on him.
- gnaritas 12y ago> but why would my children have to pay 85% on things that I want to leave them?? It's idiotic. No, it's not idiotic. It's income to them they receive without working, it should be taxed higher because those who work for their money should not be taxed higher than those who simply have it given to them. > I worked hard to earn those things,why would the government want 85% of their value?? Yes, and that's yours, not your children's. The only person you can give large sums of money to tax free is your spouse; to everyone else, that's new income and it should be taxed, and large sums should be taxed heavily because inherited wealth is anathema to democracy. You can't have a functioning democracy and allow capital accumulation to the elite in such large sums that their children become kings with the power to buy politicians and affect law without having the benefit of having worked for that money and really understanding what it means to not be wealthy. > On what basis and logical reason? To make my children "less lazy" by doing so?? No, to stop them from destroying society. > They can mind their own children - I will mind mine. You live in a community and it's not all about you and yours; try not thinking about yourself so much and look at the bigger picture. Inherited wealth is bad for society, earned wealth is good for society. You earned your money, keep it; your children should earn their own on their own.
- gambiting 12y ago>>It's income to them they receive without working, it should be taxed higher because those who work for their money should not be taxed higher than those who simply have it given to them. This literally does not make any sense. I paid tax on all those things. My children are using the benefits of my work, that is correct - but I paid my duties for the money I made. >> without having the benefit of having worked for that money and really understanding what it means to not be wealthy. So why don't we send everyone for a mandatory work in orphanages or homeless shelters for a couple months,if its about teaching people a lesson? Since when is it the governments job to make people " understand what it means to not be wealthy."? >>inherited wealth is anathema to democracy. So why don't we ban it altogether? Once you hit 18 years of age, you are given a government-built apartament, $1000 pocket money, and off you go, enjoy democracy. Meanwhile, if you die, all your possessions can go to the government who will make sure that your wealth is redistributed to the greatest benefit of the society. Sounds like the right kind of democracy to me.
- mcguire 12y ago85% is way steep, but the general idea is necessary. It prevents the development of a de-facto hereditary aristocracy and also prevents the economy from being winner-take-all. (Citation needed; I can't find it at the moment.)