3 ms·
Most comments are discussing the specifics of this event -- and of course Knuth's edit was problematic by a number of established WP policies. But are there ot
by gojomo 17y ago
Most comments are discussing the specifics of this event -- and of course Knuth's edit was problematic by a number of established WP policies.
But are there other policies which could capture this sort of primary-source contribution/correction?
Could primary sources and original researchers prove their identity/credibility and provide reliable material directly to Wikipedia?
Would such alternate policies be a good idea -- and maybe even necessary, given trends in media?
It's convenient to rely on the traditional informational middlemen -- news media and scholarly publishers -- but that world is shrinking, and lagging all the topics Wikipedia could usefully cover.
- Perceval 17y agoGiven the degree to which established academics disagree with one another, often in a vituperative and acerbic manner in public, I'm not sure having direct contribution from 'experts' will improve anything. An encyclopedia is a tertiary source and Wikipedia is an encyclopedia. That means Wikipedia is not a repository for primary source material (that would be Wikisource), and nor is it a place to publish secondary source material. As a tertiary source, it is there to report and summarize the state of the debate between published, verifiable secondary sources.
- gojomo 17y agoThat's the traditional, official-doctrine view. But you're still citing what is rather than what's best. Maybe the working definition of 'encyclopedia' needs to change. No previous encyclopedia welcomed all editors, or changed second-by-second, or had so many articles, or enjoyed the benefits of mass digital storage and instantaneous global networking. Maybe the next steps in redefining a reference encyclopedia will be just as beneficial as the steps taken so far. Someone needs to try to find out. Nupedia::Wikipedia as Wikipedia::TBD