5 ms·
Just sending checks to all citizens is politically difficult, because it starts conversations about “class warfare” and “socialism”, and implies that the federa
by jacobolus 12y ago
Just sending checks to all citizens is politically difficult, because it starts conversations about “class warfare” and “socialism”, and implies that the federal government should have a policy of explicit wealth redistribution, rather than the current hodge-podge of means tested welfare programs and monetary policy tools.
But to answer your question: yes, we’d increase liquidity, reduce unemployment and dramatically improve the lives of basically everyone in the society if we taxed capital gains as income, restored inheritance taxes to historical levels, raised the top marginal income tax rates, and closed various corporate tax loopholes, and then just took the resulting pool of cash and distributed it equally among citizens.
In the long term, the great-great grandchildren of today’s billionaires would probably end up richer, too, since the whole society would be richer.
- nostromo 12y agoLet's put aside the Federal Government (and taxes and spending) for a moment and focus on the Federal Reserve. The Federal Reserve printed a large amount of money in response to the crisis. (That was a silent tax on anyone holding cash.) To inject this money into the economy, they bought a bunch of securities. My question is simply: why use asset buying as a vehicle for injecting money into the economy and not cash to citizens? Cash to citizens seems more fair than picking winners and losers and propping up assets that would otherwise be worth much less. It seems the Federal Reserve's strategy of the past 5 years has done very little to reboot the economy, and has worsened wealth inequality dramatically.
- jacobolus 12y agoThat would help too (the effects are somewhat similar: inflation is sort of a flat tax on wealth, and wealth distribution is extremely unequal in this country; debtors would greatly benefit), but again, you’re going to get cries of “socialism”.
- maxxxxx 12y agoI think the 2008 events have shown that the Fed's purpose is to keep the "financial system" happy. Regular citizens don't really count anymore.
- waps 12y agoBut don't you think that if the financial system gets unhappy, you'll quickly follow in that unhappiness ? 2008 was really bad for the financial system. 2009 was really, really bad for everyone else. One was the direct cause of the other.
- dragonwriter 12y ago> The Federal Reserve printed a large amount of money in response to the crisis. (That was a silent tax on anyone holding cash.) To inject this money into the economy, they bought a bunch of securities. My question is simply: why use asset buying as a vehicle for injecting money into the economy and not cash to citizens? Because that's all that the Federal Reserve can do. If you want someone to do something else, you'll need to talk to the government, not the Fed (even if that is just talking to the government about changing the rules on what the Fed can do.) Of course, the more you give flexibility to the Fed to do more of the things that otherwise would be within the domain of the government, the more you undercut the whole point of an independent central bank (while simultaneously undercutting democratic accountability.) > It seems the Federal Reserve's strategy of the past 5 years has done very little to reboot the economy, and has worsened wealth inequality dramatically. The Federal Reserve, by design, does not have a general set of tools for dealing with the economy, but a very limited set of tools for managing the money supply.
- 001sky 12y agoBecause that's all that the Federal Reserve can do. Yes. Pretty much. Problem is "unemployment" is such a fake number the entire mandate of the fed has been based on flawed stats. The fed is happy to lower the "unemployment" rate by forcing people onto "disability" (permanent welfare) and un-paid leave of the workforce. That's not reducing unemployment in any meaningful sense. Its just statistical arbitrage/3-card-monty.
- jlmorton 12y agoBecause just as the Federal Reserve can arbitrarily expand its balance sheet to purchase assets, it can also arbitrarily shrink its balance sheet when it sells those assets. In other words, the Fed can print money to buy assets, increasing money supply, but given the large increases during the recovery, if inflation picks up the Fed might want to shrink the money supply. It can only do that by selling assets and destroying the money it receives.
- grantbachman 12y agoBecause all the Fed can do is issue/buy back treasuries (and MBS since Bernanke), as well as act as a lender of last resort. Banks are the ones who hold the vast majority of treasuries so they're the ones who are getting the cash for them. How else do you expect it to work?
- jqm 12y agoWhen the fed buys securities, the securities go on their balance sheet. Now... granted some of the securities may be junk, but there is an entry on the balance sheet. What would go on their balance sheet if they gave away money? The fed is a bank. Not a government. It's (arguably) the governments job to redistribute income. Not the job of a private institution.
- chuckcode 12y agoPart of the reason for the purchase of securities was to lower the interest rate on longer term securities like the 10 year treasury note. This lowered the rate a lot of consumer loans like mortgages, car loans, etc. with the hope of stimulating the economy. Usually the Federal Reserve just changes the discount rate (overnight rate to banks) to try and stimulate the economy but lowering the discount rate through 2007 and 2008 wasn't lowering the longer term interest rates and thus consumer borrowing rates. Thus Bernanke took the unprecedented step of buying the securities to drive down the longer term interest rates as well. In effect they printed money to do this but inflation remained quite low by standard measures. Bernanke requested Congress to help stimulate the economy in the near term, but politically it was impossible for Congress to achieve even a short term second stimulus package. History will be the final judge of the extraordinary actions taken by the Federal Reserve but to me it seemed like the best of a lot of bad options. Even as I'm glad that some agency was trying to stimulate the economy I'm concerned about the historical precedent that a small unelected group can decide to take on so much debt with no public comment.
- kaonashi 12y ago> (That was a silent tax on anyone holding cash.) Not really, because... > To inject this money into the economy, they bought a bunch of securities. Trading one financial asset for another is not the same thing as handing out cash for nothing. Unless you want to make the case that a torrent of spending was being frustrated by being stuck in illiquid assets (and has subsequently materialized but has not been reflected in official statistics).
- oldmanjay 12y agoWhat I like about wealth redistribution scenarios is how they're so much easier to sell when you ignore the potential negative effects.
- iammyIP 12y agoWhat potential negative effects would that be?
- arg01 12y agoDepends on the type of redistribution. It's not hard to imagine inflation as an effect for a lot of them (though the inflation could have a net positive effect depending on the redistribution scheme). At the very least people may quit horrible jobs for low pay if they can feed themselves without doing them (you can at least nominally call that bad from one point of view).
- jqm 12y agoRedistributing some wealth would be a positive for the economy at this point and time. It's like playing monopoly and someone wins all the money. The game is over at that point. Now sure... some people try to keep it going by lending money. But when the winner gets all that as well and the other party eventually has mortgaged and sold everything there is no more money for the winner to get. Getting money out of the hands of accumulators and hoarders (oh, I mean, "investors") and back into the hands of consumers would be the best thing that could happen to everyone at this point in time. It would re-energize the system. But... give that the hoarders have much more political clout this is difficult to do. Even if it is ultimately in their best interest.
- crazy1van 12y ago> Getting money out of the hands of accumulators and hoarders (oh, I mean, "investors") and back into the hands of consumers The banking system may be seriously flawed, but I'm not following your critique of accumulators / hoarders / investors. When people acquire excess money, they rarely put in under a mattress. They don't need it right now so they enter into a transaction with someone who does need it in return for more money later. For example, when a "hoarder" puts money into a bank account, the bank doesn't just stare at it. It lends it to someone who needs money now. The bank gets paid back interest and some of that goes to pay interest to the "hoarder". Obviously, this is a simplification, but the idea is the bank is an intermediary that matches people who want more money later with people who want money now.
- mullingitover 12y ago> Just sending checks to all citizens is politically difficult, because it starts conversations about “class warfare” and “socialism”, and implies that the federal government should have a policy of explicit wealth redistribution, rather than the current hodge-podge of means tested welfare programs and monetary policy tools. I seem to recall a round of stimulus checks that were sent out in 2008, before things went to hell. Even better than a one-time stimulus, I think the permanent removal of payroll taxes would be best, possibly even replacing them with permanent (albeit small) subsidies. The idea of taxing the socially beneficial act of working and hiring workers is pretty repugnant anyway.
- jqm 12y ago"The idea of taxing the socially beneficial act of working and hiring workers is pretty repugnant anyway." HEAR! HEAR! Payroll taxes are essentially a form of slavery. Every week you work X number of hours for the government. Almost like you were hauling pyramind blocks under a whip. And, on this point, conservatives (who are often wrong) are exactly right. Taxing innovation and labor are hardly incentives to provide more of it. Tax something else. Tax emissions. Tax fuel. Tax aluminum. Tax land. This would encourage efficiency and conservation anyway. Encourage innovation and productivity. Discourage waste and trashing of common resources. It's more fair and would lead to much better outcomes.
- mikeyouse 12y agoPayroll taxes are nothing like slavery. You do yourself no favors with such ridiculous comparisons.
- jqm 12y agoI didn't say "payroll taxes are LIKE slavery" (which would be a comparison). I said "payroll taxes are a FORM" of slavery. (along with being a form of theft). Just because we have been doing it and you are used to it doesn't negate this. If one WERE to compare payroll taxes and slavery, I would say the common element is involuntary appropriation of the fruits of labor. So they are not "nothing" alike. They do share at least one very strong common trait. If you find the phrase "slavery" inflammatory or "ridiculous" as you put it... fine. I think you are wrong, but it's irrelevant to the larger point I was making anyway. And that point is... it is better to tax resource usage than to tax labor for a number of reasons. Justice being a primary one, and conservation and improved productivity being others. I'd love to hear your opinion on the actual point being raised if you have one.
- TacticalCoder 12y agoOK but France has crazy high taxes: capital gain taxes, income tax of more than 50% for not that well paying jobs and up to 75% income tax for rich people, a yearly tax on your belongings if you're "rich", 21% VAT, up to 70% inheritance taxes, etc. The private sector is suffocating and closing SMEs left and right, leading to more and more unemployment. So it is not working for France. Unemployment is as crazy high as their taxes are and the situation is overall very, very bad (it's a non-democratic party who won the recent european election in France). I'm not saying I know which level of taxation is correct but once you start hammering people so much that they leave the country or that they simply decide to live of wellfare instead of trying to be entrepreneurs, then it's reasonably safe to ask the question as to whether or not you're too far right on the Laffer curve. Now I'm not saying there aren't country which are socialists and which do better than France: what I'm saying it's that it's not as easy as "tax everything" (which is what you suggest: capital gain taxes, inheritance taxes, more income taxes, etc.). On my own anecdoctical level: my brother left France to go work in Switzerland and I'm personally considering throwing the towel in and moving to a country which doesn't hate his entrepreneurs as much as the country I'm in...
- opendais 12y ago> OK but France has crazy high taxes: capital gain taxes, income tax of more than 50% for not that well paying jobs and up to 75% income tax for rich people, a yearly tax on your belongings if you're "rich", 21% VAT, up to 70% inheritance taxes, etc. Comparing France [44.6% of GDP in tax revenue] vs. US [26.9% of GDP in tax revenue] is a bit disingenuous. The historic norm for the US [c. 1950] taxes he is talking is about 3 to 3.5% of our total GDP higher. France would still be a good 15% GDP ahead in taxes. Ideally, the US would shift burdens and lower destructive spending. France, on the other hand, should be lowering taxes and restructuring its spending. http://www.outsidethebeltway.com/federal-taxes-at-lowest-rate-since-1950/ http://www.outsidethebeltway.com/federal-taxes-at-lowest-rat...