3 ms·
All economies depend on trade and division of labors to be prosperous. So money going back to India and other countries may help increase global trade.
by kiba 17y ago
All economies depend on trade and division of labors to be prosperous. So money going back to India and other countries may help increase global trade.
- fnid 17y agoIt will increase consumption in those countries, but not necessarily consumption of american goods. I think that money will benefit America more if it stays in America. This will happen if we employ more Americans who spend all of their money in America, rather than sending some of it to family members in other countries.
- rdtsc 17y agoIt's nice to help India's economy, or China or Russia. Unfortunately, US is not in the charitable business of helping developing economies.
- kiba 17y agoYou did not clearly understood the implication of "trade" part. If trade is central to the wealth of society, then more trading with other economies of the world will lead to increased wealth in the US. In fact, we have the largest free trade zone right here in the US. Goods and services in the US, for the most part, move freely.
- fnid 17y agoIncrease in wealth for whom? The upper class or the middle class or the lower class? I think qui bono is the central question in this issue. The wealthy in America benefit, but the middle and lower class does not. Research shows, as the middle class increases in wealth, then so does the whole economy and through increasing H1B's, we are eliminating the middle class american worker to jobs overseas.
- kiba 17y agoCommon sense should already suggest that trade is mutually benefical because well, I get stuff that I wanted, and you get stuff that you want. Why should trade only specifically benefit some certain classes of society? Read the article on comparative advantage. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Comparative_advantage http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Comparative_advantage This is the reason why we specialize and trade, because everybody will be better off.
- rdtsc 17y agoNot necessarily, it depends who controls the trade. There is rarely such a thing as "free trade" or "free market" -- it is a pipe dream. Trade is mostly about controls, tariffs and subsidies. Usually the powerful side control the trade. > largest free trade zone right here in the US. That is true, but I thought we are talking about internation trade.
- pieceofpeace 17y agoThat money goes after tax has been paid, house bought etc. It has many immediate benefit for the host country. The host is not subsidizing the alien's home country.