3 ms·
Normally, I make the same point[1], but I think you're falling into the opposite mistake here: if you're using GDP as a proxy for economic activity, regardless
by SilasX 12y ago
Normally, I make the same point[1], but I think you're falling into the opposite mistake here: if you're using GDP as a proxy for economic activity, regardless of cause, then it is correctly capturing the insight that "people started doing more stuff as a result of the disaster [though they may be poorer]". This (usefully) distinguishes it from e.g. "people were impeded from rebuilding, and so continued on as before".
The problem you allude to, rather, is that:
1) People use GDP as a proxy for some kind of "economic goodness" (not simply "activity").
2) The two concepts generally correlate.
3) But there are known cases where the two diverge -- when economic badness happens, and yet GDP goes up.
4) But people still call it good despite the recognition of the special case.
[1] I think the appropriate way to economically characterize window-breaking/repair scenarios is: "It used to be hard to identify good uses of scarce resources; now that vital stuff got destroyed, it's easy." See: http://blog.tyrannyofthemouse.com/2011/12/broken-windows-part-i-pain-of-hard.html http://blog.tyrannyofthemouse.com/2011/12/broken-windows-par...