5 ms·
I've solved a lot of captcha's in my time, and really have never experienced the trouble the author is detailing. Not only am I relieved when I see a reCaptcha
by Alupis 12y ago
I've solved a lot of captcha's in my time, and really have never experienced the trouble the author is detailing. Not only am I relieved when I see a reCaptcha since they are some of the easiest and most forgiving challenges, but I don't recall ever having repeated bad/unsolvable challenges presented on the same page.
Sure, maybe sometimes you get a weird one and fail it. But typically the next challenge is easy to pass. Seems the author cherry-picked some of the worst reCaptcha examples for the article, but wrote it in a way that made it seem they were presented back-to-back.
Besides this -- the article makes no attempt to offer a better solution.
Captcha's are really the best way we have right now to "prove" someone is not a bot. Hidden Form fields, etc, don't work and are easily spoofed. Sure Captcha's can be beaten by bots sometimes -- but I trust Google's scale/volume with ReCaptcha to handle that for me (for the most part).
Captcha's are not going anywhere anytime soon.
- ademarre 12y ago> Captcha's are not going anywhere anytime soon. You're probably right. But the fact remains that captchas aren't good enough. They can be partially automated; blackhats can use captcha solving farms which will be at least as accurate as the average human (probably more accurate, I imagine). A better solution might employ heuristics similar to DDoS mitigation techniques. I really don't know, but there is a need for something better here.
- VLM 12y ago"Captcha's are not going anywhere anytime soon." Its turning in to the new version of "3rd world outsourced phone support" A strong indicator the user simply doesn't care about the customer experience. For some industries / companies, this is perfectly OK and BAU. For others it can be a company-killer. I see a captcha and I know the company doesn't like me, doesn't like what I'm doing, and doesn't care if I know how they feel about me. And for some situations that's perfectly OK. Certainly not all.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- vitd 12y ago>Besides this -- the article makes no attempt to offer a better solution. That's completely irrelevant. Criticism is not about solving the problem. It's about pointing out that the current solution is inadequate. Most movie critics never wrote, directed, or acted in movies. It doesn't invalidate their criticism. In fact, your criticism of the other poster's criticism doesn't offer a better solution than criticism either. You simply criticize that post. (And that's OK, if ironic.)
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- hueving 12y ago>That's completely irrelevant. Criticism is not about solving the problem. It's about pointing out that the current solution is inadequate. Well it's a pointless criticism when everyone knows CAPTCHAs suck. People have spent a lot of time working on them trying to find better ones that work consistently at scale and have failed. It's similar to someone now writing a criticism on the testing procedures at the Chernobyl nuclear power plan.
- prof_hobart 12y agoAbsolutely. I hate with a passion the attitude of "Don't bring me problems. Bring me solutions". Sure, if you've got a solution as well, that's great. But I'd much rather know there's a problem that you don't have a solution to than be completely ignorant of it.
- skj 12y agoI go even a bit further: don't bring me solutions, just tell me what makes your life difficult. As a tools developer, I observe that user-provided solutions almost never address anything outside their specific problem, which is potentially only one of many things the feature with the issue is designed to address. Some of my colleagues tend to point to user feedback as gospel, including the ways suggested to "fix" the issue. But those fixes are often myopic and laden with technical debt. But I will never disbelieve a claim that something is confusing, or hard to use (almost never, anyway; some people are idiots). Just don't be offended if I don't fix it in the way you came up with.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- Kluny 12y agoIf you look farther down the page, you'll notice hashcash launched their proof-of-work captcha replacement thing today. I'm not saying it's related, but both of these are on the front page together.
- beedogs 12y ago> Captcha's are not going anywhere anytime soon. Which is truly unfortunate, as they're a fucking abomination, an embarrassment to the IT industry in general. Try solving these actual examples: https://i.groupme.com/311x122.png.48e978e0def70131a42422000b2204cd.large https://i.groupme.com/311x122.png.48e978e0def70131a42422000b... https://i.groupme.com/495x276.png.4da125f0def70131a42422000b2204cd.large https://i.groupme.com/495x276.png.4da125f0def70131a42422000b...
- mzd348 12y ago> Try solving these actual examples: First one: a rhaval Second one: a onsupsel You need to realize that only one word needs to be entered. For the other word just enter any string (or even no string works in some/all cases).
- mgkimsal 12y agoHow the hell is anyone "to realize that only one word needs to be entered" when that's not what the instructions say to do?
- Perdition 12y agoExperience with reCaptcha. I can totally understand why those would frustrate non-technical users, but on a site like HN I would expect people to know how reCaptcha works. That said I think reCaptcha has been getting much harder recently due to the arms race with bots. I now sometimes fail 3-4 times in a row.
- hueving 12y ago>I would expect people to know how reCaptcha works. Why should you even expect that? Recaptcha was interesting in 2006, but anyone not following the news around that time or around the its acquisition by Google might not have learned this.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- liveoneggs 12y agohave you tried this recently? zendesk's use of recaptcha was so bad that they are getting rid of it. I personally experienced this and can't wait.
- Washuu 12y agoIn the past month the reCAPTCHA challenges I have encountered have been like the article. I just have to hit reload until I can get something remotely readable or I managed to guess the letters correctly.
- jobigoud 12y ago"I've solved a lot of captcha's in my time, and really have never experienced the trouble the author is detailing." That might be the problem right here. Try browsing with Tor or passing through an anonymizing proxy. The more you solve correctly, the easier they get. The more unknown you are, the harder.