6 ms·
The economy shrank at an annualized rate of 2.9% over one quarter. That's 2.9% / 4 ~= 0.7% in Q1.
by sp332 12y ago
The economy shrank at an annualized rate of 2.9% over one quarter. That's 2.9% / 4 ~= 0.7% in Q1.
- smrtinsert 12y agoCould you explain this please?
- jerf 12y ago"If every quarter this year was the same as this one, it would be a 2.9% decline for the year." sp332 uses the ~= symbols for approximately equal because technically you can't just divide the percentage by four like that. 2.9%/4 = .725% (exactly), but technically four quarters at .725% shrink each would produce 100%-((100%-.725%)^4) for the year, which is a 2.869...% decrease, not exactly 2.9%. But for small percents being compounded a small number of times it is a decent approximation, in this case thoroughly dominated by measurement inaccuracies and noise levels; the small percentage and the small number of compoundings work together to keep the error very small.
- sp332 12y agoDo you really think it's being compounded like that? I hadn't thought of that.
- jerf 12y agoUh... are you sure you didn't think of that? ;) Anyways, for the reasons given above, it's indistinguishable. If the economy was changing rapidly enough for it to matter, well, since it can pretty much only shrink at sufficient rates to make a difference we'd probably all have better things to do than argue about compounding correctly... But it is worth reminding people you can't do than in general, because it is easy to forget. See also the Rule of 72: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rule_of_72 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rule_of_72
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- kinghajj 12y agoMeaning that if the rate of decline experienced in Q1 continued throughout the year, then the annual shrinkage would be about 3%. 1.0074^4 is about 1.03, so the actual shrinkage for the quarter in question was 0.74%.
- logicallee 12y agoif the economy shrinks by 0.05% on the Sunday before thanksgiving, you could annualize that by multiplying by 365 and getting an 18.25% shrink in the size of the American economy on that day. It would be an extremely false statement to write, "The U.S. Economy contracted by 18.25% on Sunday before Thanksgiving", which is how our title reads. ("The economy shrank almost 3 percent in Q1"). The number 3% doesn't appear anywhere, just as the number 18.25% doesn't appear anywhere. sp332's very good point is that it should include the word "annualized" or read "0.7%". A huge difference!
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- badman_ting 12y agoI remember idle moments during soccer games I played as a kid. I would sometimes think to myself "OK, we're up 1-0. If the rest of the game goes at this rate, we will definitely win." The problem with that reasoning is the word "if".
- clintonc 12y agoMath pedant to the rescue! Actually, rates combine in a multiplicative way -- losing 3% and then 4% does not lose 7%, (though it's close). What if the economy lost 1% each day for a year? It would not lose 365%. If we assume the annualized rate, the economy would be 97.1% of its current size in a year. The fourth root is 99.267%, so the economy shrank about 0.733% this quarter. If it does so for four consecutive quarters, it will decrease by 2.9%. I know that's what you said in the first place, but when extrapolating further into the future, it makes a difference.
- sp332 12y agoActually I didn't think about annualized rates compounding like that, although it makes sense now that you mention it :)
- conistonwater 12y agoMath pedants of the world: If you calculate 1-(1-x)^(1/4), the difference between the true answer and x/4 is approximately 3 * x^2/32. For a figure of y percent, this is a relative error of 0.375 * y percent. Ignore it when y is small. The GDP figure is only known to something like 1 or 2 decimal places.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- mtdewcmu 12y agoIf I'm not mistaken, if you keep following that thread, somehow or other you eventually get e. I hope that wasn't too much pedantry.