4 ms·
An amusing conclusion the article fails to make. U.S. health insurance companies have the highest administrative costs in the world; they spend roughly 20 cent
by yummyfajitas 17y ago
An amusing conclusion the article fails to make.
U.S. health insurance companies have the highest administrative costs in the world; they spend roughly 20 cents of every dollar for nonmedical costs, such as paperwork, reviewing claims and marketing.
In Austria and Germany, if a doctor diagnoses a person as "stressed," medical insurance pays for weekends at a health spa.
US health insurance companies put some effort into reviewing claims (i.e. making certain treatment is really needed and avoiding fraud).
In contrast, Austria and Germany apparently pay for any nonsense a doctor recommends. The money they save on paperwork is spent sending people to the spa.
Relevant quantity to measure:
Administrative cost + Waste + Fraud
- bjelkeman-again 17y agoIt seems to me that you presume that sending a stressed person to a health spa is "nonsense". Why would that be? Of course it could be, but it seems like a conclusion which is hasty.
- paulgb 17y agoIn contrast, Austria and Germany apparently pay for any nonsense a doctor recommends. The money they save on paperwork is spent sending people to the spa. Not all of it, it seems. Germany spends 10.7% of the GDP on health care vs. 16% in the USA. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Universal_health_care#Germany http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Universal_health_care#Germany
- yummyfajitas 17y agoYou are asking the wrong question. The question is not, "how much does Germany spend compared to the US?" The relevant question is, "how much could Germany save if they put a greater effort into weeding out waste and fraud?" My point is that you simple can't look at administrative costs alone, since there is an important tradeoff between admin costs and waste/fraud costs. To determine who is closer to the optimum, we need data on (admin+waste+fraud), not simply admin. Similarly, you can't say "GM spends 1% of costs on programmers, while 37signals spends 95% on programmers, therefore GM is more efficient." You have to know what those programmers produce.
- Retric 17y agoNo, it's "how much would Germany spend weeding out waste and fraud compared to how much it would save?" The most effective system for detecting fraud is to investigate a low but random number of cases in depth, and build an algorithm find the most likely cases of waste and fraud and then weed them out. Look at how the IRS operates for a good example of this. PS: If anything the best number to look for would be the quality of care vs cost. The fastest way to save money on US heath care would be to ban or more tightly regulate medical advertising in the US. In one day you could save 8+ billion a year in direct costs and far more than that in indirect costs. (If a drug company is spending a 100 million on advertising they think it's driving more than 100 million in extra sales + 20% over head from insurance companies etc.)
- yummyfajitas 17y agoYour question is the correct one. That's actually what I was thinking, if not what I said. :) Concerning quality of care vs cost, that's also irrelevant. I don't want health care, I want health. Health outcomes vs cost are the relevant quantity, but it has not actually been shown that quality of care significantly affects health outcomes. I submitted an article on this topic previously: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=775284 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=775284
- m0th87 17y ago* As of 2000 (the latest report with country ranking) the WHO rates America #37 in overall effectiveness in healthcare, whereas Germany is #25 (#1 is France, which also has universal coverage): http://www.who.int/whr/2000/en/ http://www.who.int/whr/2000/en/ * According to the CIA world factbook, we're ranked #35 in life expectancy, Germany #23: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_life_expectancy http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_life_expec... * Again according to the CIA world factbook, the US is ranked #46 in lowest infant mortality rate, Germany #15: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_infant_mortality_rate http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_infant_mor... In terms of production, as well as in spending, Germany kicks our butt (as does the UK, France, etc.) If we can reduce costs and at the same time get free spa visits, I'm all for it!
- ZeroGravitas 17y agoI was under the impression that stress was one of the biggest killers in the first world. Why does even the original article put "stressed" in quotes as if talking about the luminiferous aether or some other wild notion. "According to the American Medical Association, stress is a factor in more than 75% of sickness today. And according to the World Health Organization, stress is America’s #1 Health Problem." -- quote from some randomly googled site.
- brandon272 17y agoI have experienced the effects that "stress" can have on the body first hand. It's not pleasant.
- eli 17y agoConsidering how many serious medical conditions are linked to stress, I think it's at least worth considering that health spas are a reasonable medical treatment. Bottom line, the US spends more than Germany AND we don't get free health spas. So we definitely lose on this one.
- jpwagner 17y agoWhile I think your comment is a bit in jest, I'll just point out how dangerous your line of thinking is. The Germans don't get "free" health spas, each person pays more money to the government and the government in turn allocates more funds toward non-life-threatening treatment (so that the voters are kept happy.) I'm not in the position to analyze what that "free spa" is at the cost of (most of us reading this are not), but it's at the cost of something (those with more serious healthcare needs perhaps?). No one "gets free _____" from their government.