5 ms·
I don't understand the hatred for Wonga. So, there's this idea called 'usury', which Wikipedia [1] defines as "the practice of making unethical or immoral mone
by michaelt 12y ago
I don't understand the hatred for Wonga.
So, there's this idea called 'usury', which Wikipedia [1] defines as "the practice of making unethical or immoral monetary loans [...] A loan may be considered usurious because of excessive or abusive interest rates or other factors".
People have been condemning it as immoral since about 1,200 BC (vedic texts) and continue to do so in the present day.
When I visit Wonga [2] I am offered a loan at "Representative 5853% APR" and if that isn't usury, what is? (Wonga contend APR is a poor measure, as they charge a mere 22% in interest and fees over 18 days, which happens to be 5853% annualised)
About the only good thing you can say about Wonga is they don't literally break debtors legs.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Usury https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Usury
[2] https://www.wonga.com/ https://www.wonga.com/
- gadders 12y agoBut Wonga isn't for lending money for a year. It's for lending money for a few days or weeks. It's like going to Avis to rent a car for a week and them having to quote you the cost for a years rental.
- maaku 12y agoSo? The cost of money doesn't increase.
- gadders 12y agoSo you are against all compound interest?
- maaku 12y agoNo, although you'd be excused for thinking so -- I co-invented Freicoin afterall (http://freico.in/ http://freico.in/). I'm against nominal interest, which is the non-risk portion of the interest rate. But that is of zero relevance here. The point is that when I make a loan the interest rate is based on the risk of default, not how quickly it will be paid back. The rate shouldn't go up just because it's a short-term loan. Additionally, none of this loans are carrying enough risk to justify 5000% APR. This is pure extortion.
- antr 12y agoThe cost depends on the counterparty risk, and at the same time the overall liquidity to provide that type of loan is not provided by your every day bank. I don't think that Wonga has a great reputation, I don't like their business, but they are providing a service no one else is.
- rahimnathwani 12y agoThe other thing people miss is that the cost of things like a credit report, staff time (underwriting, admin, collections) and bank fees don't vary with the size of the loan.
- SideburnsOfDoom 12y agoEh, If I offered to kick people in the head at £10 a go, I'd be "providing a service no one else is". If it's legal, ethical or something that people will pay for is a different matter.
- antr 12y ago> Eh, If I offered to kick people in the head at £10 a go, I'd be "providing a service no one else is". Don't be silly. People use Wonga because people need very short term loans. Full stop. Barclays, Lloyds, HSBC, Santander, RBS, etc, do not provide that service (and they won't).
- SideburnsOfDoom 12y agoSome people need crack too, but we can decide to make it illegal to provide that service if we as a society don't think that meeting it is a good idea.
- antr 12y agoThanks, I'll leave it here https://www.goodreads.com/quotes/539027-never-argue-with-stupid-people-they-will-drag-you-down https://www.goodreads.com/quotes/539027-never-argue-with-stu...
- bertil 12y agoIndeed. I think a more telling example to the HN crowd would be: it's like asking a senior freelance consultant to charge only by the hour of "effective, proven work", taking a yearly salary of a junior coded divided by 50 weeks * 60 h/w = 3000, i.e. $25 -- and regularly demand free detailed estimates, to be sent signed within three-hours, at all hours. Wonga difference to that (or leasing a car) is that they don't really switch you to a long-term plan when they see you'd rather need one.
- mbesto 12y ago> It's like going to Avis to rent a car for a week and them having to quote you the cost for a years rental. The difference is that money is fungible, whereas a car is not. You can return the car and be done with it. In other words, the asset is Wonga can charge you for perpetuity if you don't repay the money within the agreement, and hence making 5000%+ APR applicable.
- cm2012 12y agoIn what world does 5000% make any sense when talking about a $30 fee on an $150 loan? APR is clearly the wrong metric in this context. It is legally mandated to be shown but does not aid in decision making or customer understanding.
- rahimnathwani 12y agoI agree it is of limited use, but I don't see a better way for a customer to quickly compare loans with different terms (e.g. 1 month or 6 months), whether from the same lender or different ones.
- Loughla 12y agoIt aids in comparison to standard loans for individuals with little to no understanding of how loans or finance in general work. Tell me your thoughts on payday loan companies or car-title loan companies, please.
- DanBC 12y agoAPR is misleading for Wonga. They lend money for a few days, and they make a charge for it. The fuss about Wonga and similar companies should not be about the high APR, but about their failure to scan out people with no hope of repaying the loan; the use of further debt to pay off existing debt; or extending debt. These trap people into debt holes where they have no hope of escaping the debt.
- cm2012 12y agoTo be fair to Wonga, I imagine that they try really hard to "scan out people with no hope of repaying the loan". After all, their business model rests on being able to do that!
- frogpelt 12y agoIn a lot of cases here in the States, pay day lenders also do title pawn which is where the person hands over their car title as collateral for a small loan. The lender then repossesses the car if the debtor doesn't pay.
- rahimnathwani 12y agoThis type of title loan is _much_ less common in the UK.
- rahimnathwani 12y agoDanBC may be suggesting that people can't _completely_ repay the loan, but instead need to keep refinancing it forever. Effectively they would just be paying interest and fees, the total amount of which would dwarf the initial capital, which would never be repaid. I don't think legal lenders typically do this. It's not nice, and it's not likely to generate positive word of mouth.