3 ms·
"All Knuth needs to do is to publicly write about his opinion (perhaps on his website)." Bzzt. Wrong. Knuth needs to write his opinion on his web site, and th
by ubernostrum 17y ago
"All Knuth needs to do is to publicly write about his opinion (perhaps on his website)."
Bzzt. Wrong.
Knuth needs to write his opinion on his web site, and then a mainstream media source needs to report that Knuth wrote his opinion on his web site. If a mainstream media source reports something that contradicts Knuth's word, then that report, and not what Knuth himself wrote, will be considered "correct" for Wikipedia.
- cperciva 17y agoKnuth needs to write his opinion on his web site, and then a mainstream media source needs to report that Knuth wrote his opinion on his web site. I believe wikipedia policy says that self-published sources can be accepted if there is nothing better. If a mainstream media source reports something that contradicts Knuth's word, then that report, and not what Knuth himself wrote, will be considered "correct" for Wikipedia. Yes and no. Biographies of living people have a special caveat that editors should err on the side of removing disputed material.
- ubernostrum 17y ago"Biographies of living people have a special caveat that editors should err on the side of removing disputed material." Oh, there are plenty of policies. Just try getting them enforced when a couple admins decide that they want an article to be a particular way (as has been known to happen with such articles).
- a-priori 17y agoBzzt. Wrong. Since when are we on a game show here? Knuth needs to write his opinion on his web site, and then a mainstream media source needs to report that Knuth wrote his opinion on his web site. If a mainstream media source reports something that contradicts Knuth's word, then that report, and not what Knuth himself wrote, will be considered "correct" for Wikipedia. If the WSJ had an article that reads "Knuth says Wikipedia is junk", well that would be a problem. But in the absence of such an article, his personal web site would suffice as a source.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]