4 ms·
A good question -- and there are at least two dimensions: (1) using traditional publication coverage to evaluate 'notability'; and (2) using traditional publica
by gojomo 17y ago
A good question -- and there are at least two dimensions: (1) using traditional publication coverage to evaluate 'notability'; and (2) using traditional publications as sources of information.
I personally would jettison 'notability' for 'usefulness', and improve the procedures for allowing 'self-published' material -- even up to original research and the testimony of primary sources -- to provide Wikipedia content, as long as it's true.
Yes, that's harder than just deferring to traditional high-reputation news and academic publishers. But those publishers are retreating, while the need for reference information is growing, and this problem needs the boldness of the wiki-model, even as Wikipedia has become squeamish about such experimentalism.
- hughprime 17y agoAt present, though, the bar for wikipedia notability is still set a lot lower than the bar for showing up in a newspaper -- not everything in the newspaper is worth recording for all time in wikipedia. Until that happens you're dealing with a fairly theoretical problem of how to cover notable things which never show up in a reputable source.
- gojomo 17y agoAs long as true articles are being deleted for 'notability', I'm talking about a real problem, not a theoretical one.
- hughprime 17y agoAw nu, not the "anything that's true should be allowed in wikipedia" meme again. Seriously, why haven't all the people who believe this got together and started a new inclusionist encyclopaedia yet, instead of trying to force wikipedia into being something that its guidelines clearly state that it isn't?
- gojomo 17y agoMy hunch is that eventually a tipping point will be reached, and either the guidelines will be boldly edited (for the better), or a new inclusionist alternative will emerge. Until then, that Wikipedia is 'good enough' but stuck in its ways is suppressing the emergence of an even better alternative.
- gchucky 17y agoSo let's say I build some kind of application. And I create a website for it and a Twitter account and whatever else. Should there be a Wikipedia article for that? By having lower notability standards, there would be, as the article could use the sources I created. Seems to me that there shouldn't be an article for that, though, as that's really just a case of self-promotion and advertising. Besides, there really isn't anything particularly notable about the product itself, is there? It's just something I made on my own in a few days.
- gojomo 17y agoBy the 'true and useful' standard, yes. If someone wants to write it, why stop them? Whether your app dies in obscurity or explodes in popularity, if Wikipedia could collect true and useful info about it, why exert extra effort to exclude or erase that info? If there's a topic that only a dozen people in the world (currently) care about, but one or two of them are willing and able to write neutral, reference-style articles about that topic that will be of interest to the next dozen people, why exile that work elsehwere because of traditional standards of 'notability' based on the idea of limited staff time and print-page column-inches?