5 ms·
I've always thought that one of the best way to address those issues would be to have a simple tax sheet to decide where your tax money goes - one of the best w
by ekianjo 12y ago
I've always thought that one of the best way to address those issues would be to have a simple tax sheet to decide where your tax money goes - one of the best ways to vote with your money. Want to support drones programs ? Tick the box. If you don't, while you can't stop the program by yourself, at least you are not financing it.
- gw 12y agoThis would essentially be voluntary taxation, which I certainly support but is not something any legislature would ever willingly pass.
- ekianjo 12y agoHow to get there is certainly a problem in itself, but if more people start talking about it, eventually it will gain momentum. Note that I am not for a 100% voluntary taxation policy, I don't mind having a "predefined base" + optional taxation kind of system.
- gw 12y agoIf it isn't voluntary, the money will eventually find its way there. It's a fungible commodity, and as Congress has often demonstrated, earmarking it for specific uses is notoriously subjective.
- ekianjo 12y agoWell swapping funds around has limits - if you clearly spend the money planned for road improvements or welfare for other uses like war purposes, a simple audit of spending will be able to highlight the misuse - and I'd wage we would need an extremely severe judicial system to punish those involved with the misuse of public money.
- cyphunk 12y agoThis may happen regardless of tax policy. Many propose forcing it by slowly taking away the weight of the currency base by using alternate currencies: https://medium.com/@cyphunk/use-a-crypto-currency-end-a-war-166816dc4f2 https://medium.com/@cyphunk/use-a-crypto-currency-end-a-war-...
- grinich 12y agoEveryone has one vote. The problem with dollars is that some people have more. Many, many more. So while I agree in principle that we should close the gap between citizens and decision-making, I'm not confident the right way to do it is with currency.
- Rangi42 12y agoPeople would probably underfund boring but necessary programs like the interstate highway system and industrial regulations, and would mostly check boxes for a few highly visible programs that fit with their politics (NASA, the EPA, new fighter jets, etc). I expect that a lot of programs would end up being designated as "necessary", with choices allowed for only a few which are deemed inessential. And of course, drones would end up being classified as necessary.
- ekianjo 12y agoImplementation/execution is another story. I would call "necessary" everything that falls into everyday life needs (and that could be clearly defined and spelled out and agreed in the first place) - and it would be relatively easy to define "optional" -> warring outside of your own borders is probably hard to justify as ultimately necessary.
- stefan_kendall3 12y agoPaying for things you want, and not paying for things you don't want? It's called the "free market", and it is the antithesis of government.