3 ms·
They are, today, separate and distinct. Little proto-scientists are trained in the scientific method in science classes. You can go to any school in the U.S. an
by snowwrestler 12y ago
They are, today, separate and distinct. Little proto-scientists are trained in the scientific method in science classes. You can go to any school in the U.S. and science is taught by scientists in science classes in the science department. They are not in the philosophy department. At my college, philosophy was housed in the humanities department.
Philosophers love love love to relive the history of philosophy, but it's history, not present fact. Newton called himself a "natural philosopher"--true. But today most folks call him a scientist.
The question is not "where did science come from," the question is what does philosophy do for scientists today. The structure of that question assumes the very division that you are trying to erase.
I happen to think that there are actual answers to that question; but "all of science is actually philosophy" is not one of them.
- vacri 12y agoPhilosophers love love love to relive the history of philosophy, but it's history, not present fact. Please read back over our discussion - you were the one who brought in ancient history. The things I have mentioned are all aspects of philosophy that are relevant in the current day. Newton called himself a "natural philosopher"--true. But today most folks call him a scientist. There is no dichotomy. Being a scientist and doing philosophy are not only not mutually exclusive, but you can't do good science without engaging in philosophy to some degree. This is not the same as 'all of science is actually philosophy', but a comment that the methods of good science require philosophy. the question is what does philosophy do for scientists today Why does philosophy need to find factoids or bring something fresh every year in order to be valid? "And philosophy is not the only discipline that engages in studying the workings of science. So do history and sociology of science, and yet I never heard you dismiss those fields on the grounds that they haven't discovered the Higgs boson." - http://www.huffingtonpost.com/massimo-pigliucci/neil-degrasse-tyson-and-the-value-of-philosophy_b_5330216.html http://www.huffingtonpost.com/massimo-pigliucci/neil-degrass... That quote comes from an interesting article, well worth reading. The author is countering Tyson's public misrepresentation of philosophy - with the postscript that Tyson apparently accepts these criticisms. The philosophy of science is similar to mathematics in what it offers science - you find a new technique that gives good results, so you use it in future. "What does philosophy do for scientists today?" is like saying "What does calculus do for scientists today?".
- snowwrestler 12y ago> guygurari: What new thing did philosophy contribute to physics in the last 100 years? > vacri: If it weren't for philosophy, you wouldn't have the scientific method in the first place. That's arguing from history. > There is no dichotomy. Not in your mind there isn't, but obviously there is in the minds of a lot of scientists, including for example the author of the linked article, every scientist he mentions by name, and guygurari, the person to whom you responded. You can keep asserting it over and over but that doesn't mean it's true from all perspectives.
- vacri 12y agoThat's arguing from history. If you think that the way science is performed hasn't been significantly changed and refined in the past 100 years, the original timeframe suggested... I don't know what to say. Much of what we call the scientific method has been defined, refined, and expanded in this last 100 years. dichotomy stuff The things you're referring to are occupations. 'Philosophers' and 'physicists'. Not 'philosophy' and 'physics'. The article author quite clearly states that physicists (the occupation) can make good use of philosophy(the realm of knowledge). The realms of physics and philosophy are not mutually exclusive - they are not two wholly separate things; not a dichotomy. And the scientists the article author is mentioning by name are people he's saying have this problem with the faulty perception of philosophy - it's the point of the article. In any case, like I said at the end of my last comment - philosophy gives us robust techniques for doing science, just like maths does. How do these become 'stale', 'not valid', or 'not useful', just because there hasn't been a recent breakthrough? We don't demand the same of techniques from the realm of mathematics.
- snowwrestler 12y ago> If you think that the way science is performed hasn't been significantly changed and refined in the past 100 years, the original timeframe suggested... I don't know what to say. Much of what we call the scientific method has been defined, refined, and expanded in this last 100 years. Yes, by scientists.