3 ms·
I think it's not arguable that our free will is significantly constrained. For example I've never heard of someone willing themselves to float into the air, or
by snowwrestler 12y ago
I think it's not arguable that our free will is significantly constrained. For example I've never heard of someone willing themselves to float into the air, or grow a third arm. I can imagine and think of a dragon, but I cannot bring it into existence by free will.
On top of that I have all sorts of biological activities in my own body that are not subject to my will. I can't simply choose to stop my heart, or to stop breathing, or to not heal a wound in my skin.
And the counter side is true as well: if you damage my brain, I can't just freely choose to continue thinking the same way as before the injury.
On top of that there are the emotional constraints. Even though I physically could kill my family, I won't. But do I freely choose not to do so, or am I prevented from doing so by emotional reactions that I did not choose to feel? Why don't I choose to just starve to death? Why don't I step off of high places, even though I feel a compulsion to do so? Are those examples of free will, or examples of constraints on my free will?
All that said, there are still quite a lot of decisions and actions by an individual person that we cannot predict with any precision or reliability. From a purely practical perspective, it is useful to assume the existence of free will because otherwise, why can't we predict these things?
- pessimizer 12y ago>From a purely practical perspective, it is useful to assume the existence of free will because otherwise, why can't we predict these things? Why? I've never heard a coherent non-religious explanation of what substance or system that free will is even supposed to be. I don't see how it could help at all from a practical perspective. Would it somehow help us understand next weeks weather (that we cannot predict with any precision or reliability) better if we assume that wind and water have free will?
- snowwrestler 12y agoWell the difference between manslaughter and murder is intent. What is the concept of crime if we believe our actions are predetermined? Does that mean there is no crime? Or that every crime is prosecuted under strict liability? Would a person still be pleased and surprised to get a nice birthday card if they believed it was the inevitable result of the clockwork universe?
- pessimizer 12y ago>What is the concept of crime if we believe our actions are predetermined? That's a rationalization of society's reaction to people's behavior. If you need to make up things that you don't absolutely believe exist in order to justify actions that you're taking in the real world, that's bad. >Would a person still be pleased and surprised to get a nice birthday card if they believed it was the inevitable result of the clockwork universe? Not believing in a soul or spirit doesn't give you precognitive powers, other than in the fact that your reasoning about the future doesn't involve magical effects, so is generally going to be more accurate.