6 ms·
If it weren't for philosophy, you wouldn't have the scientific method in the first place. I'd consider that to be astoundingly useful for physics research. A si
by vacri 12y ago
If it weren't for philosophy, you wouldn't have the scientific method in the first place. I'd consider that to be astoundingly useful for physics research. A simple example: ever make a hypothesis? Congratulations, you've just done some philosophy. Tested for or against that hypothesis? Now you're using methods developed by philosophy.
The whole idea of what is robust investigation and what is weak is philosophy. It doesn't come naturally - quite the opposite. Doing science 'right' is hard and counter-intuitive, but it was philosophy that figured out how to do it in a robust fashion.
If you don't see how philosophy is entwined with physics (or other sciences), then the fault is your misunderstanding of philosophy, not philosophy itself (philosophy is not another name for religion or the supernatural). And any time someone says "Before we test for X, we have to first define what we mean by X" is doing the fundamental function of philosophy. Given that physics has done a lot of defining and solidifying of terms over the last century, philosophy has definitely had a hand.
- snowwrestler 12y agoI find this argument to be condescending and wholly unconvincing. Scientists know what the scientific method is; they don't need philosophers to tell them. And certainly no living philosopher can claim to have defined or invented the scientific method. If you want to play epistemological parent trap, then before philosophy there were other attempts to understand things. Should we argue that all philosophy is actually just a subset of whatever that was? Does philosophy get priority just because we happen to have a word for it today?
- vacri 12y agoScientists know what the scientific method is; they don't need philosophers to tell them. Whoah. And you say my statement is condescending. The scientific method is not natural or intuitive. It is hard and counter-intuitive. People don't 'just know it'. They have to be trained in it, in logic, in fallacies, in null hypothesis and so forth. The mistake you're making is that scientists and philosophers are separate and distinct creatures. They're not. Should we argue that all philosophy is actually just a subset of whatever that was? I'd like to hear you articulate what it is you're talking about here, rather than just appeal to a mysterious authority. Does philosophy get priority just because we happen to have a word for it today? By 'today', do you mean 'pretty much all of recorded history'? These word games you're playing to denigrate philosophy in favour of science... are philosophy. If you think philosophy is so useless, then why engage in arguments around semantics?
- snowwrestler 12y agoThey are, today, separate and distinct. Little proto-scientists are trained in the scientific method in science classes. You can go to any school in the U.S. and science is taught by scientists in science classes in the science department. They are not in the philosophy department. At my college, philosophy was housed in the humanities department. Philosophers love love love to relive the history of philosophy, but it's history, not present fact. Newton called himself a "natural philosopher"--true. But today most folks call him a scientist. The question is not "where did science come from," the question is what does philosophy do for scientists today. The structure of that question assumes the very division that you are trying to erase. I happen to think that there are actual answers to that question; but "all of science is actually philosophy" is not one of them.
- vacri 12y agoPhilosophers love love love to relive the history of philosophy, but it's history, not present fact. Please read back over our discussion - you were the one who brought in ancient history. The things I have mentioned are all aspects of philosophy that are relevant in the current day. Newton called himself a "natural philosopher"--true. But today most folks call him a scientist. There is no dichotomy. Being a scientist and doing philosophy are not only not mutually exclusive, but you can't do good science without engaging in philosophy to some degree. This is not the same as 'all of science is actually philosophy', but a comment that the methods of good science require philosophy. the question is what does philosophy do for scientists today Why does philosophy need to find factoids or bring something fresh every year in order to be valid? "And philosophy is not the only discipline that engages in studying the workings of science. So do history and sociology of science, and yet I never heard you dismiss those fields on the grounds that they haven't discovered the Higgs boson." - http://www.huffingtonpost.com/massimo-pigliucci/neil-degrasse-tyson-and-the-value-of-philosophy_b_5330216.html http://www.huffingtonpost.com/massimo-pigliucci/neil-degrass... That quote comes from an interesting article, well worth reading. The author is countering Tyson's public misrepresentation of philosophy - with the postscript that Tyson apparently accepts these criticisms. The philosophy of science is similar to mathematics in what it offers science - you find a new technique that gives good results, so you use it in future. "What does philosophy do for scientists today?" is like saying "What does calculus do for scientists today?".
- guygurari 12y agoIt used to be that philosophers/scientists/mathematicians etc. had a lot of overlap. That is why I constrained my question to the last 100 years. I agree with you that philosophy had useful input for scientific research in the distant past. Can you offer more recent examples? It seems to me philosophy has not been relevant for a long time.
- vacri 12y agoThe entire arena of String Theory was a clearly philosophical detour in physics. It captured the hearts and minds of the physics world for years... yet it was pretty much entirely conjectural.
- guygurari 12y ago> clearly philosophical detour No. I am a string theorist. String theory was created by physicists to solve concrete theoretical challenges -- first the description the strong force (this did not work as intended), and later quantum gravity. These were longstanding open questions in physics. I am familiar with the history of string theory, and as far as I know no philosophers had any influence on it. Perhaps my question wasn't clear, so let me rephrase. What contribution did philosophers make to science in the last 100 years?
- vacri 12y agoThere's a significant fault in your reasoning, that 'philosophy' is only performed by people who are socially recognised as being 'philosophers'. It's like saying that the only people who cook food are chefs - professionals recognised as food cookers. People who are professionally recognised as 'philosphers' are a miniscule fraction of the people who use and engage in philosophy, just like chefs are a miniscule fraction of the people who cook. What you describe about string theory is philosophy. It's just not your personal definition of philosophy, which is based on a faulty stereotype. The funny thing is that it's only because you assign philosophy a stigma that you want to distance yourself from it.
- 12y ago