5 ms·
I really don't see the need to get more women in tech. Its obvious from school age that it just doesn't interest them as much. You never hear of the need to get
by collyw 12y ago
I really don't see the need to get more women in tech. Its obvious from school age that it just doesn't interest them as much. You never hear of the need to get more male nurses, or primary teachers and that is generally not viewed as a problem.
Edit: I stand corrected, apparently there are big movements to get males into the professions I mentioned. Just that I never heard about these movements.
- dublinben 12y ago>You never hear of the need to get more male nurses, or primary teachers and that is generally not viewed as a problem. This actually is a common conversation within those fields, and is certainly viewed as a problem in wider society. Some researchers claim that one reason male students underperform in school is due to the lack of adult male role models in the form of teachers. As a male with some experience in education, I have seen first hand how much my very presence in the classroom can inspire young male students. They yearn for more male teachers, and they don't even know anything about education theory or developmental psychology.
- collyw 12y agoThey doesn't seem to receive as much attention as IT and women type conversions. In fact I have never heard a "we need more men in" for any job role.
- minikites 12y agoYou are 100% wrong on the second point, there is plenty of effort to get men into traditionally female jobs like nursing and teaching: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Men_in_nursing#Increasing_numbers http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Men_in_nursing#Increasing_numbe...
- return0 12y agoStill, it's not nearly as much as the reverse campaign. I have never received any messaging through media etc. about such a campaign. It exists, in theory.
- freehunter 12y agoOutside of HN (and sites linked to from HN), I've never seen a media push to get women into STEM either.
- tormeh 12y agoYou actually do. Just not on HN.
- dang 12y ago> Just not on HN. On the contrary, this is discussed frequently on HN: both the claim that there are no efforts to get men into nursing or primary teaching, and the fact that indeed there are. It gets brought up so often that it's almost a cliché, with people joking about writing bots for it and so on. https://hn.algolia.com/?q=men+nursing#!/comment/forever/0/men%20nursing https://hn.algolia.com/?q=men+nursing#!/comment/forever/0/me... https://hn.algolia.com/?q=male+nurses#!/comment/sort_by_date/0/male%20nurses https://hn.algolia.com/?q=male+nurses#!/comment/sort_by_date...
- tormeh 12y agoYes, but only in the comments. That doesn't count. I'm saying it's never on the front page of HN because, duh, HN is a technology website. Why would HN care about nursing? Except as a strawman in the comments of course..
- nocman 12y ago"in the comments" doesn't count??????!!!!! I'd wager that most people who read Hacker News spend at least twice the amount of time reading the comments as they do reading the actual articles. The discussion is one of the primary reasons for the site to exist! Often the comments section is way more informative than the actual article.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- viraptor 12y agoNot sure about male nurses, but not having male primary teachers is a serious issue (at least in the UK). I keep hearing advice about guys getting into teaching kids (or really leading any kids activities) - "don't". Because the expectation is that you're likely a pedophile. Because doing something completely normal that gets some girl at school surprised will cost you time in court and being able to work with kids in the future. I'm not sure how often it really happens (anecdote != data, etc.), but I've heard enough stories of simple actions being misinterpreted with terrible consequences (I was going to teach some kids at the local sport club) that I really wish there were more male teachers. Just to break the idea that it's something unusual.
- thegeomaster 12y agoI'm curious as to what kinds of actions could be misinterpreted like that. Care to give an example?
- viraptor 12y agoOne of the local stories I heard was about a PE teacher who knocked on the girls' changing room and told them that whatever activities they were doing are starting. He didn't enter, just wanted to get their attention and shouted this through the door. Someone got scared by that, reported that he wanted to enter the changing room and that resulted in lost job - not sure if he was reported anywhere higher in that specific case. (it was mentioned in discussion between coaches, because the local club had changing rooms that had to be used) Would the same thing happen if it was a female teacher? Probably not. Would it happen with female teacher and boys' changing room? I'd say highly unlikely.
- detcader 12y agoit just doesn't interest them as much I'd appreciate if you'd read something: http://reelgirl.com/2013/11/im-not-a-pilot-im-a-pilots-wife-says-3-yr-old-girl/ http://reelgirl.com/2013/11/im-not-a-pilot-im-a-pilots-wife-... Edit: It's telling when people downvote a comment that is nothing but a relevant link. This is a situation in which you either have convictions and are willing to defend them, or are knowingly ignorant about the subject and are willing to try to learn and engage in discourse. If those options feel constricting, all you have to do is close the tab.
- kstenerud 12y agoNot sure why this is being downvoted. It's HIGHLY relevant to the discussion.
- rbehrends 12y ago> Its obvious from school age that it just doesn't interest them as much. [Citation needed]. What you're seeing in school is very likely the effect of early age socialization effects. Which can go both ways, if you look at other cultures, such as Iceland [1]. You may also want to familiarize yourself with the concept of "stereotype threat" [2]. > You never hear of the need to get more male nurses, or primary teachers and that is generally not viewed as a problem. As a matter of fact, this is a source of concern in the relevant circles [3, 4]. For example, much has been written about boys not having enough male role models among teachers in schools. It just doesn't get much coverage in the media because, well, these are considered low-end jobs that few people other than those involved in nursing and teaching care much about. In fact, that is a major theme: If a type of job is dominated by women, it's likely to be poorly paid (stereotypically male jobs can go either way). [1] http://content.time.com/time/magazine/article/0,9171,1032361,00.html http://content.time.com/time/magazine/article/0,9171,1032361... [2] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stereotype_threat http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stereotype_threat [3] http://www.edutopia.org/male-teacher-shortage http://www.edutopia.org/male-teacher-shortage [4] http://www.cbc.ca/thecurrent/episode/2013/02/21/is-the-shortage-of-male-teachers-a-crisis/ http://www.cbc.ca/thecurrent/episode/2013/02/21/is-the-short...
- lnanek2 12y agoNot really. There have been monkey studies showing males like physical things like cars and girls like nurturing things like dolls. It's PC to deny genetic differences in play at this point, but it isn't scientific.
- collyw 12y agohttp://www.psychologytoday.com/blog/the-scientific-fundamentalist/200804/why-do-boys-and-girls-prefer-different-toys http://www.psychologytoday.com/blog/the-scientific-fundament...
- rbehrends 12y agoThis is an often misquoted study [1]. The complete picture is actually different in that the male monkeys had an anti-plush toy bias, but the female monkeys had no clear preference for either wheel or plush toys (regardless of what you want to infer from that): Mirroring the marked sex difference in infant interactions and children’s toy preferences, male monkeys interacted significantly less with plush toys than did female monkeys. By contrast, males and females interacted with wheeled toys comparably, displaying no reliable sex differences. As is the case with sex differences in children’s toy preferences, only male monkeys showed a significant preference for one toy type over the other, preferring wheeled over plush toys. Unlike male monkeys and like girls, female monkeys did not show any reliable preference for either toy type. [1] http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2583786/ http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2583786/
- rickyc091 12y agoThe issues lies in that working with computers or technology is not "cool." Take a look at movies, television shows, etc. A person in tech is typically classified as a geek, a nerd, loser, etc. Middle school and high school are a big popularity contest, but that's also the age where they are very malleable. Until the negative connotations stop, people will continue to be afraid to enter the tech space.
- collyw 12y agoNot sure why you are being downvoted, as I can clearly see a media bias. HN is getting very PC.
- tomp 12y agoPersonally, I don't see any reason to get anyone into anyone. Ideally, people should choose what they want to do, whatever interests them. I chose computers because I couldn't get away from them when I was young, and they interested me more than most other things (sports, history, friends, ...). I see no reason why people should be asked to get into STEM. Should they have the opportunity? Of course! Fortunately, social perceptions about geeks are changing, thanks to shows like Big Bang Theory and because of fortunes made with technology (Facebook, Google, ...). But someone who is not passionate about being a programmer/scientist and is only in it for the money, will in average be less successful in it that someone who's passionate about it.
- viraptor 12y ago> Fortunately, social perceptions about geeks are changing, thanks to shows like Big Bang Theory I'm not a huge fan of many new action movies, but I'm also quite happy seeing people who (in the past) claimed Tolkien or comic books are for nerds only, happily go to see the LotR and Marvel/DC movies now. Movies these days can be criticised for many things - but putting a strong female character in a sci-fi world from time to time is quite a welcome change. (yeah, I know it's not done properly every time, but the shift is visible)
- thegeomaster 12y agoI agree with the gist of your comment, especially the clause that someone who's not passionate about a field shouldn't be forced into that field. However, I'd like to address some other points. >I chose computers because [...] they interested me more than most other things (sports, history, friends, ...) This sounds very sad to me. How do you mean that computers interested you more than friends? I don't see how anyone could come to say this. >social perceptions about geeks are changing, thanks to shows like Big Bang Theory I think TBBT is doing more harm than good to the "geek culture", whatever you want to call the "geek culture". What it's doing is enforce and rehash the stupid "nerd stereotypes" of the old, but somehow present it as "being cool". The world doesn't need that. All cultures need less poseurs, not more. I didn't think I'd ever cite Maddox on HN, but I agree with him spot on. Take a look: http://thebestpageintheuniverse.net/c.cgi?u=youre_not_a_nerd http://thebestpageintheuniverse.net/c.cgi?u=youre_not_a_nerd
- saraid216 12y agoI really don't see the need to get more blacks into the middle class. It's obvious from birth that they're just not interested in anything but subservient labor. Why, you can even look at the shape of their skull and see this plain as day.
- peterwwillis 12y agoOh come on, you can do better than that.
- saraid216 12y agoI'm a programmer, not a comedian. :P
- collyw 12y agoThe difference is that blacks may want to join the middle class. Most women (certainly the ones I have come into contact with) don't aspire to be techies. Very poor comparison.
- saraid216 12y agoThat's just abolitionist propaganda trying to upend the proper order of things. These uppity blacks you're talking about? They've just been fed all sorts of wrong-headed ideas from other people. Envy is a sin, you know.
- peterwwillis 12y agoWell, first off, you're technically correct in the general sense that women don't need tech jobs, and that the tech industry doesn't need women specifically. But STEM does need more people since the number of applicants for STEM jobs is dangerously low in the USA, and our science literacy as a nation is dangerously poor. So since there's all these women on the planet, and they're underrepresented in the STEM field, it makes sense to increase the number of STEM jobs by taking that underrepresented population and moving it toward STEM. Getting more women into STEM helps everyone. As for why you believe there isn't a demand for these things, it's basically confirmation bias. You don't personally hear a need for more people in these sectors so you assume the need doesn't exist. But in fact there's been a lot more need for nurses in the past decade, so male nurses would definitely be welcomed in terms of increasing the applicants for those jobs. Teachers less so because they have a hard enough time making ends meet with miniscule budgets without adding more teachers to the roles. All these industries are different and have different motivators as to whom they try to get more jobs to. But behind any great push to get more people into an industry you'll probably find economic motivators, not a demand for social justice. So focus less on the fact that it's women, and focus more on the fact that it's half the population not going after STEM jobs.
- geebee 12y agoPart of the problem is that it may be individually rational for US citizens to avoid STEM jobs. At the graduate level, the RAND institute concluded that the American aversion to STEM degrees is rational and market-driven: http://www.rand.org/pubs/issue_papers/IP241.html http://www.rand.org/pubs/issue_papers/IP241.html A professor at the University of Washington, William Zumeta, reaches a similar conclusion http://www.issues.org/19.2/p_zumeta.htm http://www.issues.org/19.2/p_zumeta.htm Now, STEM is broad, and software development is a different thing. But a lot of people are surprised to learn that the median wage for registered nurses in San Jose ($122,990) is actually higher than it is for software developers in San Jose ($116,610). In San Francisco, dental hygienists earn 106K a year, only a bit less than software developers (110K a year). I don't really have any problem with this, I'm happy that these workers make good salaries, but it is remarkable that we talk about the urgency of getting more people into an field where there is a severe shortage when other fields in these high cost areas earn about the same amount, and perhaps with considerably better career security as you enter middle age. (see http://money.usnews.com/careers/best-jobs/rankings http://money.usnews.com/careers/best-jobs/rankings) There are good reasons to want to do one or the other, but I certainly wouldn't say that the intangibles clearly break in favor of software development. Silicon valley leaders act like the shortage of STEM workers or software developers is a foregone conclusion. I'm not saying that there's no case to be made for it, but I the evidence suggests that salaries in software development are not remarkable on average, and there are considerable career risks long term. We need to consider the possibility that avoidance of STEM is actually a very economically rational decision for a high talent student. It may be why Americans are avoiding the field, and it may be why women are avoiding it.
- shadowfox 12y agoThere are, in fact, some initiatives to try to get more men in to nursing for various reasons. For example, see this (http://www.minoritynurse.com/article/men-nursing http://www.minoritynurse.com/article/men-nursing). The article has a few references at the bottom which also make for interesting reading. Of course we come across more articles about women in tech because we frequent tech forums. But the topic (of men in nursing, teaching etc) do come up on the relevant forums.