4 ms·
HarvardConnection (later renamed 'ConnectU') looked a lot like the classic "3 business guys hire a part-time coder to implement their 'vision'" startup antipatt
by gojomo 17y ago
HarvardConnection (later renamed 'ConnectU') looked a lot like the classic "3 business guys hire a part-time coder to implement their 'vision'" startup antipattern.
That Zuckerberg, who was already creating social web apps before the 'oral contract' and engagement with HarvardConnection, concluded he didn't need that overhead was his own independent discovery of the YC gospel.
I'm sure the ConnectU crew thinks their special snowflake vision of a social-networking utility that starts on college campuses was a uniquely world-beating idea, but that sort of delusion is common. There are thousands with similar delusions who didn't luck into a brief collaboration with someone who'd eventually make the vision happen, and the accompanying lucrative settlement.
(And a settlement is not an admission of guilt, but a calculation that the costs of fighting exceed the costs of settling. For Facebook, the costs of uncertainty in their fundraising far dominate the potential legal costs/risks, so a settlement says more about the peace of mind wanted by investors than the facts of the case.)
- jacquesm 17y agoSorry, I don't buy the 'he didn't need that overhead'. When you are hired as a programmer to make something that does not give you license to make off with the business plans and designs of your employers. Imagine a contractor making off with the architectural drawings and other details of a building he's supposed to put up because he 'doesn't need that kind of overhead'. It is absolutely without honour. The settlement was likely because there was a fair chance of it sticking in court, the other party decided that 65 million / 3 is good enough for them to not risk losing in court. The costs of fighting were probably a lesser consideration than the cost of losing.
- gojomo 17y agoOf course you can't make off with someone else's preexisting detailed plans. But what if you brought as much or more to the planning as others? If your multitudinous 'partners' want vast credit for concepts and feature requests while you handle all the details and execution? If they're treating you like a 'contractor' (your analogy) when you know you're the prime mover? If there's nothing but vague oral agreements about future possibilities? I see it as: Zuckerburg realized he could better do what he wanted to do -- indeed wanted to do even before meeting HarvardConnection -- on his own. They parted ways after barely 3 months of informal collaboration (while also full-time students). No doubt both sides fumbled a lot of the communication. They were undergrads, after all. What did they know about clear agreements, scoping development efforts, clearly assigning IP rights of side projects, managing expectations, the value and novelty (or not) of ideas? A lot less than they all know now, I'm sure.