3 ms·
No, it's not. The shadow inventory (and home vacancy rate) in the US is still massive due to overbuilding during the housing bubble. House prices and sales are
by pessimizer 12y ago
No, it's not. The shadow inventory (and home vacancy rate) in the US is still massive due to overbuilding during the housing bubble. House prices and sales are dropping for 80% of the market, and banks are releasing inventory in dribs and drabs in order to keep prices from collapsing completely.
I have no idea which of these graphs is supposed to represent something other than a period of extreme overbuilding and speculation, followed by a reduction in building and a gradual rise in the rate of shelter cost increase which hasn't even reached trend yet. What difference would you expect to see 7 years after the collapse of a massive housing bubble if there weren't some pending shortage of rental housing?
edit: The distressed housing, as it is released and foreclosures are actually completed instead of artificially being held in limbo, will of course largely be converted to rentals. Virtually all current residential construction is in multifamily units intended for rental. It's the only profitable segment of the housing market other than luxury.
edit2: an image from that same blog that shows the enormous amount of vacant housing that isn't on the market: http://4.bp.blogspot.com/-GWjstiIc_No/UfQTK38X-TI/AAAAAAAAaQA/EjHfwxmEAn8/s1600/Vacanices.PNG http://4.bp.blogspot.com/-GWjstiIc_No/UfQTK38X-TI/AAAAAAAAaQ... from http://soberlook.com/2013/07/for-many-americans-rising-home-prices.html http://soberlook.com/2013/07/for-many-americans-rising-home-...
This is yet another press release from the 'I want to build upwards in newly hot urban neighborhoods and get some of that upper-middle class 20-something moving from the suburbs into the city' money.
edit3: Annual Rental Vacancy Rates for the United States and Regions: 1968–2013
http://www.census.gov/housing/hvs/data/charts/fig03.pdf http://www.census.gov/housing/hvs/data/charts/fig03.pdf
Show me the problem here before we start building 80 unit buildings on the corner lots of quiet residential neighborhoods.
- bunderbunder 12y ago> This is yet another press release from the 'I want to build upwards in newly hot urban neighborhoods and get some of that upper-middle class 20-something moving from the suburbs into the city' money. I'll take it. The "I want to build condos so I can cash out ASAP, and then turn around and stick that money into mortgage-backed securities so I can also cash in over the long haul, perhaps at the expense of those same people I just sold a condo to" money has been dominating the conversation for far too long. Back in the 2000s I got kicked out of a perfectly fine apartment along with everyone else living in the building so that the property owner could flip all the units over to condos. Last I checked the building's still at ~50% occupancy, down from 100% when I was living there. And about half the units that are occupied are also for sale. It's far from the only former apartment building in that neighborhood with a similar story to tell, either. Yes, that does mean that there's an incredible amount of vacancy in the area. But - and this is critical - the amount of vacancy that's a reasonable option for people who aren't in a good position to take out a 30-year is very, very small. If you're in your 20s and single with no kids, a 1-bedroom apartment is a great idea. But unless you're confident that you'll remain single with no kids for the rest of your life, a 1-bedroom condo (that you probably won't be allowed to sublet) is a kind of stupid idea. And all those empty condos units are difficult to flip back to rental because condminium developments have legal encumbrances that make things more difficult. So for now they're going to stay vacant and continue being a senseless waste.
- pessimizer 12y agoIt's purely a survival decision from the banks. Enough single-family housing was built during the bubble to safely house us all well into the next decade. Every homebuilder in the country is smart enough not to invest in adding to that overhang. The prices/sales are dropping now - what will they look like a year from now? These articles are like those skills-shortage rationalizations for the current level of prime-age employment that ignore the fact that neither hours or wages are rising, so there clearly isn't a shortage that is having an economic impact.
- bunderbunder 12y agoAbsolutely, a lot of housing was built during the bubble. At least around here, it takes the form of a bunch of McMansions way out in the 'burbs. It's housing that was designed by baby boomers for baby boomers - the demographic whose current vector points out of the mainstream housing market and into retirement communities. For young folks entering the market, many have decided there's just way too much time, money, and gasoline in between those houses and the desirable jobs. You might as well say, "Well there are plenty of houses up for grabs in Detroit." That's well and true, but also pretty much irrelevant to someone trying to make a career in the job sectors that are currently growing. I'm sure the market will eventually sort it out; the current situation is creating plenty of opportunities to make a buck for someone smarter than the banks have proven to be. But that doesn't mean it isn't an irritating situation.
- brownbat 12y ago> smart enough not to invest in adding to that overhang This is interesting... new housing and old housing affect each others' prices, but aren't quite fungible. I'm surprised some developers aren't just confidently outcompeting existing stock with better quality newer homes. Are newer homes absorbing an equal or larger share of the vacancies than older homes? Is there some class of home that is absorbing a disproportionate share of the vacancies?
- zanny 12y agoSounds like a great time to live in studio condos. What cities are the most vulnerable right now in that regard? Getting a good deal on housing can offset thousands a year in income loss from relocating.
- jqm 12y agoThank you. I came here to say exactly that. There is still an oversupply of houses from the housing bubble.
- sseveran 12y agoThis is generally not true in areas that are desirable to live in. Lots of slack capacity has been removed from the market.
- jqm 12y agoDesirable is relative. I wouldn't live in SF for 3 times my current salary. It just isn't my thing and lifestyle is extremely important to me. Maybe you mean a few highly populated cities that are booming at the moment. If so, I'm sure you are correct on that point.
- njharman 12y agoNot in Austin, TX. It's sellers market, with bids over asking, tons of construction, etc. never had much of a bubble or weak economy. People be moving here in droves. Where they came from might have surplus, but not here.
- pessimizer 12y agoI was in Austin a couple of weeks ago, and it was jarring compared to when I used to live there (in the late 1990s.) Someone told me that 110 people move to Austin every day, now. It's the fastest growing city in the country, and it's an anomaly within an anomaly (Texas had its housing bubble and crash long before everyone else did.)
- bdcravens 12y agoMy cousin has lived in Austin a long time. She's a traditional "country" girl, coming from the smallish country city I came from in North Texas, and is typically conservative. She told me that it's ironic that in the state capitol you can almost see Texas.
- ufmace 12y agoSame in Houston. I just sold some property, and I got a full-price offer the day it was put on the market, before the pictures were even up. Another guy in my office got ~10 offers in a week, including some all-cash offers, for a ordinary, slightly-run-down house in a suburban area here. Everyone I've spoken to in the real estate market here this year has some story about how hot the market is right now.