3 ms·
No sports have enough data to say that "the best team won". There just simply aren't enough matches. But most people's enjoyment of sports comes from watching
by jedberg 12y ago
No sports have enough data to say that "the best team won". There just simply aren't enough matches.
But most people's enjoyment of sports comes from watching the execution, not the stats. The stats are just icing.
Yes, there are people who get enjoyment just from the stats (baseball is notorious for this), but for the most part the stats are just an interesting side show for the main event.
- ownagefool 12y agoActually, all the sports I know of have a pretty simple method of dictating who the better team on the day was. Otherwise, how would we know who won? Still, for many the debate is part of the fun. :)
- taeric 12y agoI think the assertion is that "who won the game" is not, strictly speaking, the same as "who is the better team." That is, it could be akin to saying that "this particular coin shows heads today" because that is what the last flip did. Definitely true, but does not tell you anything about the nature of the coin.
- ownagefool 12y agoWhen the object of the game is to win, you can pretty much determine the better team by result. You might not always agree with how they achieve it, but you can't really argue results. That said, I was specific to say 'On the day'. Typically, it's pretty poor sportsmanship that sees most of us arguing that the better team lost.
- taeric 12y agoBut can you? Imagine if your goal was to find which coin is the biased one, but you could only flip once a week. Though, I should be clear that I doubt the better team loses most of the time. More that I just think the static view where there is a clear "better" team is flawed anyway.
- taejo 12y agoConsider a sport Chess--, which is very similar to chess, except that before making each move, the player rolls a 100-sided die, and if it comes up 100 they instantly win. If Magnus Carlsen plays Chess-- against me, and is one move away from checkmate when I throw the 100, did the best player win?
- ownagefool 12y agoNot so much Chess, poker would be more apt. We then veer into the territory of deciding what is and isn't a sport.
- smackfu 12y agoBaseball is probably closest, where you play 19 games per season against each of the teams in your own division. Too bad they don't use the same pitchers in every game, since that adds two more significant variables.
- pnathan 12y agoI think that Cricket Test matches (take place over 5 days) also seem to stress team capability fairly well. But I'm not a cricket expert (I would need to be introduced by someone knowledgable), so I may be quite wrong!