5 ms·
I was expecting trite problems, but only one of them (flight) was, the others are real, and difficult. Although two of them (water, food) are not problems in d
by ars 12y ago
I was expecting trite problems, but only one of them (flight) was, the others are real, and difficult.
Although two of them (water, food) are not problems in discovery but in execution. Enough money or attention? Problem solved. This means there will be no one to award the prize to. Plus food is actually just a subset of water.
That leaves 3, and all of them are medical, which is interesting if you are thinking about what to learn in school.
(Flight is silly to include because if you want to stop pollution (of all types) stop China from burning coal, you can eliminate flight completely and it wouldn't make a dent.)
- Tarang 12y agoThere was a BBC Horizon episode that went into each in depth to show that each is not as trivial as they seem. Money and Attention wouldn't really be able to solve what they're aiming for. The example they used of why this prize was a good idea was how it helped sailors centuries ago with the ordinary watch/timepiece. It was not possible to find one's position while at sea quite long ago without accurate time. Money couldn't solve this one, no matter how they tried they couldn't accurately know where they were at sea. There were people with the resources to solve it and they did try many things but were not able to. A prize like this for a working way to find someone's position at sea accurately got someone involved in making a unconventional timepiece that would be accurate at sea. This simple breakthrough probably saved many thousands of ships & probably pushed civilization ahead a few hundred years.
- netcan 12y agoThe importance of the Flight challenge is debatable, I suppose but it is defined well. That's important. "If Flight wins the vote, the challenge for Longitude Prize 2014 will be set to design and build a zero or close-to-zero-carbon aeroplane that is capable of flying from London to Edinburgh, at comparable speed to today’s aircraft." If you don't think its environmentally valuable, at least it's valuable as an engineering challenge. The definition of the Food challenge is much poorer: "If Food wins the vote, the challenge for Longitude Prize 2014 will be set to invent the next big food innovation, helping ensure a future where everyone has enough nutritious, affordable and environmentally sustainable food that people want to eat. A successful solution will demonstrate benefit at a small scale now and show projections of the potential environmental and social impact of scaling up to provide for millions of people." If no one had seen a potato before, growing a field of them could presumably win this challenge. It would be easy to demonstrate on a small scale and make the case for scaling up. The whole problem is scaling up with all the political & economic hair that goes with it. We're pretty good at cheap calories. I disagree about Water: "creating a cheap, environmentally sustainable desalination technology." Clearly defined and would have many high value implementations including many humanitarian ones. The only knock on it is that I think there is sufficient economic incentive that a £10m prize won't make much difference. I could be wrong though.
- ivan_gammel 12y agoThe flight problem isn't really a FLIGHT problem: it's about energy. Is it possible to create a zero-carbon source of energy, or, maybe, an accumulator good enough to power the flight of commercial aircraft? We've already seen that for cars it is possible (Tesla), so now it's time for the next step.