4 ms·
We also have bad weather. Right now, where I live at least, a top 10 metro, it's around 90-95degF and 80-90% humidity or it's raining. Suppose I decide to ride
by bane 12y ago
We also have bad weather. Right now, where I live at least, a top 10 metro, it's around 90-95degF and 80-90% humidity or it's raining. Suppose I decide to ride to work. Google puts that at a 1 hour and 13 to 1 hour 23 minute ride depending on my route. It sucks but it's doable.
Now I arrive at work and I'm soaked either from sweat or rain. Now what? I can stink up the office with my B.O. all day while I desperately try to dry my clothes. Or I go through the indignity of getting to work, waiting an hour to cool-down and dry off, then trying to change out of my riding kit into some decent professional work clothes in a dirty stall in the men's room after giving myself a paper towel bath in the sink.
Then at the end of a long work-day, reverse this absurd course of events? Now instead of a 10 minute drive and 8.5 hours at the office followed by a 10 minute drive home (total time commitment under 9 hours), I've succeeded in turning my 9 hours of work time into a 10.5-11.5 hours of work time so I can put myself dangerously out in traffic, exposed to the elements and be uncomfortable the entire day and can't go anywhere else once I'm there?
Even if the stars aligned and I had door-to-door bike trails, I wouldn't partake in this uncivilized madness. I'd much rather just get home earlier, not smelling like exhaust fumes and body odor and go do a leisurely jog around my neighborhood park for a half hour or go to one of the 3 gyms next to my house where I can ride a stationary bike in a temperature controlled environment while watching TV.
Edit: for the record, I support dedicated bike lanes and infrastructure almost everywhere because of all the side benefits it brings. But I'm also not treating it as a religious issue, mindful of acute practicalities that explain the world better than assuming one of the most technologically sophisticated countries on the planet doesn't like to ride bikes to work because they're too stupid to do so.
- stingraycharles 12y agoJust because it isn't your personal preference doesn't mean no one should think about cyclists. There are many pro- and con-cyclist arguments, all of which are irrelevant to this discussion.
- bane 12y agoMy larger point is that painting up bike lanes is probably the last of the issues in the "let's get people biking" discussion.
- andrewliebchen 12y agoYeah, but you don't shy away from setting up straw men you can knock down in service of your "I don't think its feasible to bike to work, so we shouldn't bother making it easier for anyone else" argument.
- bane 12y agoGood thing you didn't read my main comment and decided to get your religion offended instead.
- maxerickson 12y agoYou've made ~10% of the comments for this article and you are dismissing things other people say by accusing them of caring too much about the issue. I'm also not sure repeatedly dismissing the same minor points does much for the conversation (of course repeatedly raising them doesn't do much good either). I think you are probably right that bike lanes alone aren't going to get a lot of people biking, but I think you are wrong that they don't matter. It's a situation where each piece of the puzzle needs to exist, so safe routes probably matter just as much as sensible city planning and shower availability and so on. The existence of safe routes could even impact planning some (because if there is significant interest in using them to commute, it should show up in housing decisions).
- bane 12y ago"You've made ~10% of the comments for this article and you are dismissing things other people say by accusing them of caring too much about the issue. " You say that like it's a bad thing. At least I'm engaged on the issue and am actually trying to solve it rather than just paint lane markings all over creation and expect people to start hoping on bikes. The claim being made, and the source of all my karma shedding on this is that adding more bike lanes will get more people to ride bikes. The "Field of Dreams" argument. My counter argument is that bike lanes, while important, are not sufficient. Much more important, larger and prerequisite issues need to be attended to before bike lanes become part of the discussion. But I'm arguing against people who have a vested interest in biking, and really don't give two rats asses that biking is a horrible inconvenience most everywhere and would rather shoot derision and scorn and the car driving masses. Weather, environment, convenience, terrain, distance, time, hygiene etc. be damned; clearly most people are simply too fat and stupid to enjoy the glories and obvious benefits of riding bikes everywhere. Everywhere is exactly like the Netherlands right? I'm actually a strong supporter of bike lanes for lots of reasons beyond biking. But I'm also not deluding myself and understand that the central claim is flat out wrong. But this is a self-serving religious issue, no amount of reason can penetrate that. This is one of the topics that really pulls out in front the inadequacies of the demographic that tends to be HN readers. It's pretty disappointing to be honest.
- daemin 12y agoYou cool off for a bit and then take a quick shower before starting work proper. Most offices that I've been to have shower/changeroom facilities, and the people that cycle to work use them. Of course if your ride is over an hour you may want to consider alternatives, such as catching a train for part of the journey. I have known plenty of people that have 30-50 minute rides, and also others where riding a bike takes exactly as long as being stuck in traffic.
- marincounty 12y agoI think there are really some morning people, and night people? I can barely muster the energy to get into my car and point it towards work. If I camped, I would be the first one eaten by a Sabertooth Tiger. I quit a job because they required me there an hour earlier than other shops. Even if I have a playmate over--hands off until I wake up. Sorry Miss Simms--it wasen't you, I was tired.
- bane 12y agoIn 20 years, I've only worked in one place that had a shower. To me, for practical and obvious reasons, it sounds like no number of bike lanes will get people riding if that isn't solved.
- andrewliebchen 12y agoI bet your have a gym within walking distance to your office. If you go to the gym when you get home, just shift your gym time to before work. You ride to your gym, take your shower, walk to work. Bam problem solved.
- bane 12y agoNope. Even if I did, now I have to pay a monthly fee so I can have a crap ride to work? No thanks again!
- andrewliebchen 12y agoYou already pay a monthly fee to have a crap drive to work in your car. If only you could be charged for the negative externalities of driving, the actual cost of maintaining the road, to park your car, to fill your gas tank...maybe you'd have a different opinion.
- funkyy 12y agoBecause in London, Amsterdam, Tokyo or Singapore the weather is amazing all the time - this must be a reason for all the bikers there... You prefer comfort over bikes - we get it. But bicycling is not "uncivilized madness". Its common way of transportation in most of the world (with exception of majority of the US). Healthy as well (much more healthy than gym).
- mikeash 12y agoIs it really "most of the world"? Living in France for a couple of years, and visiting London, Rome, and various other parts in that direction, I didn't see any more bicycle traffic than I see in the US. The one place where I have seen a lot of bicycles is Beijing, but that has completely disappeared in the past few years. I wish we could discuss these things without turning it into a "the US is strange and stupid" whinefest.
- bane 12y agoNo, bike riding is incredibly uncommon the world over. Is an inconvenient, slow, tiring way to travel in anyplace without a good climate or near perfect terrain. Edit: keep down voting in spite of your own ignorance. I've been lots of places the world over, and not seen lots of bikes outside of very very few areas with near perfect conditions for them.
- sjy 12y agoI doubt that commuting by car is 8 times faster than cycling, even if you live way out in the suburbs (which exist because of the assumption that everyone drives a car). My commute in city traffic takes 10 minutes by car, or 15 minutes by bike.
- bane 12y agoI can go 60 miles per hour in my car. The average speed of cyclists in Copenhagen is under 10 miles per hour. Add in a couple long hills and you are at 6-8 times faster on any given day.
- deserted 12y agoBut can you average 60 miles per hour in your commute? Maybe if you're going 30 miles on the freeway and only a few blocks on surface streets, but for going short distances within cities, bikes can be comparable or even faster than cars (see: Bike messengers)
- bane 12y agoTo be honest, I probably average more like 50. 3 blocks from my house to the road, then high speed almost all the way and 1 block off the main road to work. It's an easy drive.
- nknighthb 12y agoYour commute looks nothing like the average American's commute.
- bane 12y agoYou're right, the average American commute favors cars much more strongly. At 10 miles I'm remarkably close to my work and have a favorable biking environment most of the route. Yet it still is a bad alternative and in 7 years I have yet to see a single person bike along that route. The question of "why don't Americans bike to work more" is not going to be solved with any number of bike routes (which I support the building more of BTW) until it can be solved for frankly trivial cases like mine. It suggests that local environmental conditions are probably more important to favoring biking than any number of infrastructure initiatives. Simple things like "bad weather" and "showers at places of employment" and "places to store bikes so they won't get stolen during the day" probably have to solved en masse long before bike lanes become part of the discussion. All the unused empty bike lanes in the world aren't going to kick start a biking revolution.
- sleepyhead 12y ago"We also have bad weather." Now that is a huge generalization in a huge country.
- bane 12y agoAbout the only part of the U.S. with a workable decent climate for most of the year is Silicon Valley.
- sleepyhead 12y agoHow would you describe the climate in Copenhagen?
- bane 12y agoSix months of near perfect bike riding temperature with moderate precipitation and unusually warm winters that far north. In fact, the record high ever for the city isn't even within 10 degrees of the temperature I've had where I live over the past two weeks. Our all time average, not average high, is about the same as Copenhagen's record high. Our winters are colder and wetter also.
- grecy 12y agoHere in the Yukon we get a solid month where it's -40C/F and a few months of -25C to -35C. It snows a lot, then the snow turns to hard-pack ice. I ride every day. You can too.
- alphapapa 12y agoI can't help but think of how simple things like injuries and aging affect everyone and how driving practically solves these problems. You want to ride, go ahead. He wants to drive, that's fine. Neither one is more right or wrong than the other. Stop acting like driving is morally wrong (if you're not, many are).
- grecy 12y agoOh, I'm not saying that at all. I'm simply saying that excuses are not valid. If you want to ride, ride. Don't make weak excuses.
- bhandziuk 12y agoI'm surprised a 10 minute drive translates to a potentially 1:20 minute ride. I feel like one of these numbers is exaggerated. Regardless, if it's not right for you it is right for someone on your approximate route. So if you can't be convinced to ride in but they can that's win-win. They have an easier ride into work on a bike and you have a less congested drive in because the biker is one less driver.
- bane 12y agoDo the math, how far can you get in a car doing 60 mph in 10 minutes? How far on a bike doing 10mph? Toss in a couple hills. If there are any people riding bikes on my route I have yet to see them in 7 years.
- ojbyrne 12y agoExcept for traffic - I've found that my commute is almost exactly the same time, bike or car, because of traffic (I'm in Silicon Valley).
- stinos 12y agoSo how much kilometers is it then? (both for the car trip and the bike trip, depending on the area they can vary). Btw I don't know where you get the 10mph figure, but assuming it applies to you without trying it is starting off on the wrong foot. Depending on age, fitness etc that can easily be 15mph, including hills.
- bane 12y agoI don't know why you got downvoted. It's a fair question. https://subsite.kk.dk/sitecore/content/Subsites/CityOfCopenhagen/SubsiteFrontpage/LivingInCopenhagen/CityAndTraffic/CityOfCyclists/CycleStatistics.aspx https://subsite.kk.dk/sitecore/content/Subsites/CityOfCopenh... How fast can you travel through town by bike and car? The average travelling speed in Copenhagen is 15.5 km/h for cyclists and 27 km/hour for cars. In places with green wave for cyclist the average speed is 20.72 km/h.
- 12y ago
- SideburnsOfDoom 12y ago> Now instead of a 10 minute drive Your experience is not universal. I live in a large, crowded city, and I know from repeated experience that in my case, in rush hour, cycling to work takes 30 minutes, public transport takes 40-60 minutes and driving in my own vehicle takes mental insanity and a parking space, which nobody has. Cycling is not only the fastest method, it has the least time variance, and is cheapest.
- bane 12y agoMy experience may not be universal, but I bet it's statistically normal, or even slightly better for cycling than most places. Yet it's still a terrible alternative. The mystery of why more people don't cycle is pretty simple, it's not really viable in most of the world.
- SideburnsOfDoom 12y agoI don't know what "statistically normal" means, but I'd estimate that 20-50% of my colleagues are in the same position as me and so would benefit from better cycle infrastructure.
- bane 12y agoLet's fight both of our "anecdata" with actual data. http://www.reference.com/motif/sports/average-commute-in-miles-for-americans http://www.reference.com/motif/sports/average-commute-in-mil... The average commute in miles for Americans is 16 miles and 26 minutes for one way. That's 32 miles and 52 minutes for a round trip every day. Let's assume we decide we want to get the "Average" American biking to work instead. We have to figure out how we can convince people who spend an hour on the road everyday to spend 8 hours on the road biking instead, or give up their houses and pay more for smaller accommodations closer to their work to shorten the distance.
- empthought 12y ago>That's 32 miles and 52 minutes for a round trip every day. >spend 8 hours on the road biking instead 4mph is a slow running speed...