3 ms·
I know who he is, I did the Google search to try to reconcile the grammar and spelling mistakes that littered the writings being quoted. I found it hard to bel
by RiderOfGiraffes 17y ago
I know who he is, I did the Google search to try to reconcile the grammar and spelling mistakes that littered the writings being quoted. I found it hard to believe. To explain clearly why I used the phrasing I did, I will need to tell you a story. Apologies in advance for its length.
Are you sitting comfortably? Then I'll begin ...
30 months ago we advertised for a programmer. We informed a recruiting agency, and sent them some homework, stipulating that we didn't want any resumes without the answers being provided at the same time. They tried once to send a resume without the answers, but we told them very sharply that this was unacceptable.
A week later we got back a resume that read like a dream. So much so that we actually checked some of their claims before we even looked at their homework. And yes, they had been the lead programmer at a major company, they had produced several pieces of Open Source code that looked competent, without being outstanding, and they generally looked like professional programmers.
Then we looked at the homework. It was littered with errors, both logical and syntactic. The design was opaque, and when we took the time to fix the syntax errors, and largely debug the logical errors, it still didn't do what it was supposed to do.
What to do? Call for interview and get to the bottom of it? Deep six the whole thing and move on? Immediately make an offer?
Despite the impressive track record, my team was talking about the "alleged" programmer, and so the decision made itself. He had too much of a hill to climb to gain their respect. No interview, no hire.
Perhaps the problem here is simply the way I expressed myself. Perhaps I unwittingly used a code phrase from my own experience that isn't known or shared by others here, and hence was misunderstood. I'd still expect a well-known, well-renowned professional journalist of long standing to make fewer errors than I found, but perhaps I just expect too much.
But then again, if he really did want that job, shouldn't he have taken the time to get things right?