4 ms·
From my personal experience: If one is able to dig deeply enough, for what I guess to be something like 90% of the population, there is a level where people jus
by stcredzero 12y ago
From my personal experience: If one is able to dig deeply enough, for what I guess to be something like 90% of the population, there is a level where people just declare "I feel that way" and there is no logic, nor even the barest respect for rationality. What's more, these feelings are very often used to justify the arbitrary bad treatment of others who are deemed to be "wrong" or "inferior."
All of these feelings have some "rationalization" as window dressing, but ultimately, it comes down to irrational feelings of tribal affiliation. This invariably comes out in politics and professional life.
We're goddamned grunting, screaming apes who have the ability to occasionally surpass our primitive nature and are well suited to being organized into groups. The vast majority of us do not have the intellectual integrity to hold consistently to a set of rational principles to the nth degree. In the end, our feelings hold sway, and our empathy often fails.
Prejudice is a part of our very nature, and it comes out all the time. There is no need for it to be attached to race or gender, and our society doesn't equip us with the intellectual tools to recognize it at the substrate level. Rather, our present societies are organized around it.
- Swizec 12y agoTo be fair, all of the best decisions I've ever made have come out of "I feel that way" and all of my worst decisions have come out of "This is rationally correct". Life is funny like that.
- stcredzero 12y agoWhenever it comes to potential harm to people of far social distance, well practiced rationality leavened by empathy had better hold sway. Also, if you are a member of a privileged group, you may well have the luxury of just doing what you feel. You also may or may not be insulated from some of the consequences.
- Swizec 12y agoI'm a young white cis straight male from a low middle-class single-parent family currently striking it out on his own on a foreign continent without the safety net of friends, family, or a steady job. Also I'm short to boot (this is bad for men, I'm told) Am I a member of a privileged group? That said, gut feel has always guided me very well when I have incomplete information. I always have incomplete information.
- skywhopper 12y agoYour privilege depends on your context. You may be privileged in some contexts and not in others.
- bjelkeman-again 12y agoI did the same, with pretty much the same cicomstances. The fact that we had a choice in the matter leaves us pretty much privileged, no doubt in my mind.
- Swizec 12y agoI am a firm believer of the idea that everyone's got a choice. It's the living with the consequences bit that's problematic. Usually what people mean when they say "I don't have a choice" is actually "The probability and cost of catastrophic failure are too high to be worth it".
- tim333 12y ago>To be fair, all of the best decisions I've ever made have come out of "I feel that way" and all of my worst decisions have come out of "This is rationally correct". You could hypothesize things are likely to be that way because there is no rational purpose to life - you do some stuff then die. If anything you could say a successful life is one where you enjoyed the ride which may be maximised by doing what feels right. I guess.
- onnoonno 12y agoIs it really that easy? The 'maximize' part? Maximizing happiness could then be to secure a big supply of heroin and being on an IV drip all the time. Some people feel that way. For some - in the end deep emotional reason, I don't _want_ it to be that way for myself. Even though I probably have more pain that way, going through life.
- danpat 12y agoAn old friend of mine had a theory that the purpose of emotion was to act as a tie breaker when rational decision making becomes deadlocked. In many situations, no matter how rational the person, imperfect information can lead to two choices appearing equivalent. How is a perfectly rational being supposed to act at that point? Making a decision based on some kind of tribal affiliation ("Well, these two things seem the same, but this one is how it's been done in the past") might actually be a useful fallback behaviour, as past successful experience might be an insight when all other things seem equal. It's interesting to note that many of the behavioural patterns that are labelled as "mental illness" often combine "difficulty making decisions" and "lacking emotional response". People who are excessively rational often have trouble functioning in society. Fundamentally, I believe that those deep seated irrational axioms are necessary for us to function. Without them, we'd freeze and crash at the next logical paradox we came across. Without a little bit of irrationality, how do you decide what to do next? What do you do when you get to the end of the decision tree?
- stcredzero 12y agoThis is why I prescribe well practiced rationality leavened with empathy. The problem is not emotions being a tie-breaker per se. The problem is when people aren't clear about which feelings are involved. Most commonly, people tell themselves they are acting "to protect" when they are really acting out of hate and aggression. Also, I don't think it should be excused when someone is confronted with their contradictions, but they deny what they are doing anyways. Sometimes I think that that is my biggest problem with humanity.
- gdewilde 12y agoIf you are on the receiving end of the abuse it does get easier to see it for what it is. If the collective asserts your inferiority you don't have a lot of options besides from thinking for yourself. At the same time it is much harder for those most favored by the community to reject the special treatment... if not impossible. I like how you point out that race, gender and sexual preference are just extreme examples. I was sort of stuck there but it indeed seems to extend to the color of the nail polish, the brand of clothing, the choice of OS, political preference..... and pretty much everything else. I hope this topic doesn't change hn into reddit. (just kidding)
- stcredzero 12y agoreddit is home to many of the worst examples of what I'm talking about. As is HN at times.
- tormeh 12y agoWatch this: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KM4Xe6Dlp0Y https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KM4Xe6Dlp0Y
- gdewilde 12y agolol, her whole life directed for her to the point she can point at her picture and say "that isn't me". Sam Berns would be the other extreme. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=36m1o-tM05g https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=36m1o-tM05g