5 ms·
Do Rational People Exist?
- onetimeusename 12y agodownvote me if you wish but honestly the rationality movement seems like it is more interested in being elite than anything meaningful. If all the rationality movement can provide as a measure of success is just higher performance on some silly tests designed by psychologists to essentially trick you with wording then I would want nothing to do with it.
- vertex-four 12y agoUnfortunately, one of my social IRC channels - one which used to revolve primarily around respect for emotions - got invaded by a certain well-known rationalist Internet community. Immediately, where channel operators hadn't been required for the past four years, they were left having to enforce simple rules on the new people, which they inevitably argued against. Every other week, there are serious issues involving violation of social etiquette. Now, this isn't a problem with "aspies", as some might think. The channel, before this, had a remarkably high concentration of people with aspergers, and some with autism. This is a problem with people who honestly do not see emotions as a thing that they should care about. That is the rationalist movement at its core, for all they talk about, from my perspective.
- dthunt 12y agoPlease elaborate; I would like to know more about this incident.
- gdewilde 12y agoright! So lets make this a discussion about: Alien abduction Alien implants Alien space crafts Cold fusion Drawing energy from magnetic fields noble gas engines plasma reactors gravity engines making gold from other elements turning water into pure hydrogen or pure oxygen Remote viewing Astral projection Summoning spirits Contacting the after life Wireless electricity HAARP chemtrails / RF chaff And of course animal rain to make it truly Fortean.[0] Try not to make arguments from ignorance, provide sources based on actual research. Oh, and don't confuse the examples for the topic! Enjoy! edit I see the fear of the unknown has already produced 1 down vote. I shouldn't be asking but I'm curious why. Perhaps I should explain a bit more: I think rationality is best tested where most people abandon it. If all of the above are not real we must have rational arguments for each item. I dont claim to know anything about the items beyond a bit of superficial googling. The arguments found on the web left much to be desired. I cant just copy other peoples opinion if they didn't arrive there logically. [0] - http://www.resologist.net/loei.htm http://www.resologist.net/loei.htm
- Liesmith 12y agoA much better question than "do rational people exist" would be "do people generally behave in a rational way?" Who cares if I'm not 100% rational all the time. As long as people in general tend towards rationality then it makes sense to talk about 'rational people.'
- jasode 12y ago>They behave more like ideal economic actors. I believe the author is making the mistake of equating the "rational" in "economics' rational actors" to be people who choose wisely. The type of wise choices that most of society would agree to lead to positive outcomes. My understanding is that formal economics is using "rational" as in "rational choice theory"[1]. It's a specific term-of-art that's different from the everyday usage of "rational." It's not some positive measure to satisfy a global optimum. A "rational actor" is simply someone who reliably arrives at the same consistent choices given the knowledge and preferences he happens to have. If a consumer chooses CocaCola over water even though soda's sugar content causes obesity and teeth decay, the consumer is still classified as "rational" even though it looks like a suboptimal choice within the bigger picture of healthy living. Economics' rational choices satisfy a local optimum (consumer's imperfect preferences) and not a global one. [1]http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rational_actor http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rational_actor
- fnayr 12y agoExactly. Rationality in economics simply means an agent maximizes his (expected) utility from the common and specific knowledge he currently has.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- pash 12y agoYes, that's basically correct. To an economist, you're rational (modulo some technicalities) if (a) when you have to, you can always decide which of two things you want more (yes, it's OK to want some things equally), (b) whenever you want A more than B and B more than C, then you want A more than C, and (c) whatever you say you want (or think you want) your behavior actually reflects (a) and (b). If you're not rational in this sense, please stay indoors, or at least refrain from trading with bearded men in tweed, because a perfectly scrupulous economist will take you for everything you're worth by giving you exactly what you want. :P For details, see these lecture notes [0], particularly the axioms of choice theory on slide 4. (Or take a micro theory course!) 0. http://ocw.mit.edu/courses/economics/14-03-microeconomic-theory-and-public-policy-fall-2010/lecture-notes/MIT14_03F10_lec03.pdf http://ocw.mit.edu/courses/economics/14-03-microeconomic-the...
- natural219 12y agoOkay, so there's a lot to break down here and a lot of conflations taking place. At a base level we can understand, I know people in my life who seem more "rational" in general than people I know who I would describe as more "emotional". In this sense, you can think of "rational" thinking as any thought-pattern that activates the cortex -- roughly speaking, the region of the the brain associated with higher-order and abstract thinking. On a more nuanced level, the author seems to be making a case about capital-R "Rationalism", as espoused by communities like Less Wrong, Effective Altruism, capital-L Libertarians, and the singularity wonks. In this, I feel like the author is making a huge conflation that I feel is kind of misleading and rather insulting to people who don't buy into one small communities ideas about cognitive bias and logical fallacies. Often times, "evidence" of "irrational" behaviors, as displayed for example in the Linda problem and the Wason task, typically fail in that the askers don't understand language or how it's typically used. There are loads of people that have a rational bent that will get these problems wrong, simply because they don't put too much thought into it, or they're trying to answer a question linguistically, rather than purely "Rationally". I have a lot of theories as to why LessWrong / Libertarian types develop this inflated sense of self importance about their "Rational" outlook of the world, but it's pedagogical, and probably insulting to those involved, so I'll leave it for another day.
- whybroke 12y agoAre Libertarians rational? I see absolute primacy given to ownership from people who live on land seized from Indians. A belief in enforcement of contracts on people who didn't sign them, namely people born after the agreements were made. The claim that utilities such as sewage and water supply would be better served if there were countless duplicate sewage systems in each city owned by different companies. The assertion that the current ISP throttling issue would be fixed by eliminating the FCC. The claim that the problem of the commons does not exist. So, I humbly submit, that the claim to rationality is not the same as its possession.
- stcredzero 12y agoFrom my personal experience: If one is able to dig deeply enough, for what I guess to be something like 90% of the population, there is a level where people just declare "I feel that way" and there is no logic, nor even the barest respect for rationality. What's more, these feelings are very often used to justify the arbitrary bad treatment of others who are deemed to be "wrong" or "inferior." All of these feelings have some "rationalization" as window dressing, but ultimately, it comes down to irrational feelings of tribal affiliation. This invariably comes out in politics and professional life. We're goddamned grunting, screaming apes who have the ability to occasionally surpass our primitive nature and are well suited to being organized into groups. The vast majority of us do not have the intellectual integrity to hold consistently to a set of rational principles to the nth degree. In the end, our feelings hold sway, and our empathy often fails. Prejudice is a part of our very nature, and it comes out all the time. There is no need for it to be attached to race or gender, and our society doesn't equip us with the intellectual tools to recognize it at the substrate level. Rather, our present societies are organized around it.
- Swizec 12y agoTo be fair, all of the best decisions I've ever made have come out of "I feel that way" and all of my worst decisions have come out of "This is rationally correct". Life is funny like that.
- stcredzero 12y agoWhenever it comes to potential harm to people of far social distance, well practiced rationality leavened by empathy had better hold sway. Also, if you are a member of a privileged group, you may well have the luxury of just doing what you feel. You also may or may not be insulated from some of the consequences.
- Swizec 12y agoI'm a young white cis straight male from a low middle-class single-parent family currently striking it out on his own on a foreign continent without the safety net of friends, family, or a steady job. Also I'm short to boot (this is bad for men, I'm told) Am I a member of a privileged group? That said, gut feel has always guided me very well when I have incomplete information. I always have incomplete information.
- tehabe 12y agoNo. Next.
- gcanyon 12y agoIt's unfortunate that, as a person interested in puzzles, I've seen almost all of the common tests for rationality, lack of bias, etc., etc. So I have little to no way to assess whether I would pass these tests, because, for example, I first saw the "A bat and ball together cost $1.10. The bat costs a dollar more than the ball. How much does the ball cost?" puzzle when I was in grade school. Has anyone published research-level assessments that I didn't see decades ago?
- skywhopper 12y ago"Rationality" is overrated. Our lives are not pure economics, thank goodness. A purely rational person would likely not experience any joy or love. But if they were capable of doing so, they wouldn't opt to pursue those things because they would need to spend time doing research into each economic decision they made.
- endtime 12y agoThis is commonly known as the Straw Vulcan Fallacy. If a course of action leads to less total utility (including fun, happiness, etc.) then choosing that course of action is irrational. This obviously includes overanalysis. For one data point, I stopped attending the NYC Less Wrong meetup (through which I happen to know the author) when I met my wife (through said meetup) and decided I'd had enough of the sex, drugs, and roc^H^H^Hstrategy games lifestyle.
- lelf 12y ago> A purely rational person would likely not experience any joy or love How do you know that? It's not unrealistic for me that they may found more love and joy
- skywhopper 12y agoI think the most important thing to consider here is that these logic questions they use to test "rationality" are awkward word puzzles, and the test reveals more about how well people can work out what's being asked than their underlying rationality. The fact that most people would jump onto the "bank teller and feminist" option in the conjunction fallacy test is because the question as posed contains mainly feminist-related ideas, and so the brain's natural tendency is to jump to the answer containing the word feminism. That's less about rationality and more about how attuned are you to the likelihood that the questions you're being asked are worded in a tricky way.
- gwern 12y ago> I think the most important thing to consider here is that these logic questions they use to test "rationality" are awkward word puzzles They aren't. Have you looked at the CRT questions? There's nothing tricky about them, the challenge is simply actually checking your answer. And if it's 'just' a word puzzle, why is the correlation with IQ so low? And why does this sort of rationality inversely correlate with screwing your life up in various ways (see the research discussed in my comment in OP)? That's an odd thing for an 'awkward word puzzle' to do. > The fact that most people would jump onto the "bank teller and feminist" option in the conjunction fallacy test is because the question as posed contains mainly feminist-related ideas, and so the brain's natural tendency is to jump to the answer containing the word feminism. You know that was the very first criticism leveled against Kahneman & Tversky's conjunction fallacy results and they long ago showed that other wordings gave the fallacy too?
- dnautics 12y agoI suspect people with asperger's are often 'more rational'.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- haberman 12y agoThe article has an unstated assumption that being more rational is better. While clearly there are benefits to less biased thinking, there are also drawbacks that are supported by research. Martin Seligman wrote a book called Learned Optimism that deeply explores the issue of optimistic vs. pessimistic explanatory styles. To oversimplify, when something bad happens to a pessimist they tell themselves it is permanent, personal, and universal, whereas optimists tell themselves it is temporary, impersonal, and specific. When something good happens, the two groups do the opposite. Here is an excerpt from the book about the unfortunate evidence that depressed people have fewer cognitive biases. Snipped/edited for length: There is considerable evidence that depressed people, though sadder, are wiser. Ten years ago Lauren Alloy and Lyn Abramson, then graduate students at the University of Pennsylvania, did an experiment in which people were given differing degrees of control over the lighting of a light. Some were able to control the light perfectly: It went on every time they pressed a button, and it never went on if they didn't press. The other people, however, had no control at all: The light went on regardless of whether they pressed the button. The people in both groups were asked to judge, as accurately as they could, how much control they had. Depressed people were very accurate, both when they had control and when they didn't. The nondepressed people shocked us. They were accurate when they had control, but when helpless they were undeterred: they still judged that they had a great deal of control. [...] These have been consistent findings over the last decade. Depressed people -- most of whom turn out to be pessimists -- accurately judge how much control they have. Nondepressed people -- optimists, for the most part -- believe they have much more control over things than they actually do, particularly when they are helpless and have no control at all. Another kind of evidence for the thesis that depressed people, though sadder, are wiser involves judgments of skill. Several years ago, Newsweek reported that 80 percent of American men think they are in the top half of social skills. They must have been nondepressed American men, if the results of Peter Lewinsohn, a psychologist at the University of Oregon, and his colleagues are valid. These investigators put depressed and non-depressed patients in a panel discussions and later had the patients judge how well they did. To what extent were they persuasive? Likable? As judged by a panel of observers, depressed patients weren't very persuasive or likable; poor social skills are a symptom of depression. Depressed patients judged their lack of skill accurately. The surprising finding was from the nondepressed group. They markedly overestimated their skills, judging themselves as much more persuasive and appealing than the judges thought they were. [...] Overall, then, there is clear evidence that nondepressed people distort reality in a self-serving direction and depressed people tend to see reality accurately. How does this evidence, which is about depression, tie into optimism and pessimism? Statistically, most depressed people score in the pessimistic range of explanatory style, and most nondepressed people score optimistically. So basically the research is suggesting that unbiased thinkers tend to be more pessimistic and depressed than people who irrationally distort the world into being better than it actually is. What a bummer.
- lilsunnybee 12y agoReally not a fan of the current gray font color trend. -_-
- rejschaap 12y agoAt least we managed to answer the question "do irrational people exist?"