5 ms·
The premise of the article is naive at best You can use web analytics to measure a conversion rate from ads. Hence user clicks ad -> sales happens (in the best
by raverbashing 12y ago
The premise of the article is naive at best
You can use web analytics to measure a conversion rate from ads. Hence user clicks ad -> sales happens (in the best cases). That's Internet Ads 101
In fact, with online ads the "if it works" part is much more measurable than for other medias
"Last year, a group of economists working with eBay’s internal research lab issued a massive experimental study with a simple, startling conclusion: For a large, well-known brand, search ads are probably worthless."
Once again: "For a large, well-known brand"
Well, so do you mean that pumping ads for something everybody already knows (and already gets massive advertisement everywhere else) doesn't work? Color me shocked.
- omonra 12y agoThe point of the article is that the sale would happen regardless of the ad. Ie showing an ad on Google to someone who types 'Ebay' in the search string is a waste of money - since Ebay shows up as the first natural result anyways.
- droopyEyelids 12y agoHowever, this leads to the other flaw in the argument, where eBay has been the company most famous for abusing Google's ads, and using them in a completely nonsensical way. http://www.searchenginejournal.com/how-not-to-run-a-ppc-campaign-inspired-by-ebays-adwords-fail/61025/ http://www.searchenginejournal.com/how-not-to-run-a-ppc-camp... I'm sure you've noticed that a search for any noun called forth an ad for eBay. You're enticed to "buy Dog Vomit on eBay" when your dog is sick. And then, even if it was something eBay plausibly sold, when you clicked through it'd take you to a generic eBay search page or, often, a landing page that was not useful at all.
- unclebucknasty 12y agoWell, there's nothing to say that eBay's research lab was using these horrible PPC ads in their tests. In fact, I would guess that they had to hold the landing page as a constant (e.g. homepage when "ebay" was the keyword), or otherwise account for that variable in the study design. For instance, the study notes that, for one test, they simply turned off their PPC campaigns for one geo and compared results to others. So, presumably, even if they were using their horrible PPC ads during this test, they would have been equally horrible across geos.
- rfergie 12y agoIt is very unfortunate that the extremely interesting ebay study is being ignored by the SEM community because ebay has some bad adverts. The methodology and findings should be something that advertisers look at and learn from (i.e. that traditional methods of tracking do not always do a good job of showing value) but instead people just like to point fingers and call names
- blauwbilgorgel 12y agoIt is not ignored, because eBay has some bad adverts. It did attract significant attention more than a year ago (the study was conducted in 2012, and media reported on it in early 2013). "eBay has no idea if online ads work" would be a better title. Or "eBay can't get their online ads to work". If you looked at eBay's search advertisements in the last years you probably have seen very ridiculous ones, like: Love. Buy it cheap on eBay Low Prices. New and used. This is a significant waste of money, and seems endemic at eBay, not a rare occasion. Though it is too easy to point at this and discard the entire study, it is a relevant prior. As a control they take MSDN/Yahoo vs. Google. The control should be a different advertiser, not a different advertisement network. In the paper they mention removing the term "eBay Shoes" from their keywords, because they rank organically for that. They should have never added it, because it is a bad keyword for them. They should advertise on the brand name shoes they are selling. This ties back to the bad adverts by eBay: Fixing your mistakes and seeing change, is different from performing a controlled experiments on a healthy advertiser. They muse about "the types of consumer that may already be informed about the advertiser’s product". This adds a few problems: those customers may have been informed through the very advertisements they now claim don't work. Suddenly shutting down advertisements does not negate the effects of running advertisements years before that. The paper does not investigate the effect that ads have on brand recognition and brand trust. Usability tests show people clicking on advertisements first, because then they expect quality and a simple commercially interesting proposition. I do think the problem they are describing "some customers may be so aware of a brand, that advertising to them becomes worthless" is valid. Maybe ad networks could help here and implement a form of "demarketing" next to their "remarketing" options: Once a user has enough knowledge of the brand, stop advertising. But a better (and currently available) method could be to apply remarketing and give these power users tailored advertisements. An example could be a buyer's program, promoting a new product from a well-purchased brand, or a referral bonus. To continue offering them advertisements like "eBay shoes" does not make much sense.
- paulgb 12y agoIt's worth noting that display advertisers can and do account for this by running a control group that sees public service announcements instead of the ads they'd normally run.
- rumcajz 12y agoIsn't it a way to prevent eBay's competition to show ads on 'eBay' keyword?
- omonra 12y agoThere are still plenty of other spots in paid results for the competition :)
- mcfunley 12y agoExactly right. If search ads don't work for this kind of activity, we only know that because online ads allow measurement. If your takeaway from the article is that you should go back to buying billboard space instead, you're an idiot. Search ads DO work for plenty of use cases for less-omnipresent companies. And they would probably start working a lot better if the Amazons and Ebays stopped bidding.
- xux 12y agoThe thing with big brand advertising is that they aren't trying to gain new customers. They're cementing their place in existing industry. Coca Cola pretty much captured as much market as possible. Yet they still advertise to refresh their image. "Even a great brand needs investment and caring to maintain its relevance and vitality." - Jobs
- cbsmith 12y ago> You can use web analytics to measure a conversion rate from ads. Hence user clicks ad -> sales happens (in the best cases). That's Internet Ads 101. As the article pointed out though, the ad conversion rate is so low, it is very difficult to separate the signal from the noise, particularly for smaller campaigns. There is also the additional issue that the ad itself doesn't necessarily directly lead to a simple click->convert cycle. Having worked in the industry for the better part of the decade, I can tell you that separating the signal from all the noise absolutely does require a ton of data. There's a reason why "Big Data" rose to prominence in the advertising world.