3 ms·
> motherhood provided the crucial, emotionally satisfying transition into adult life. I know someone who worked at a treatment center for disadvantaged inner c
by rdtsc 12y ago
> motherhood provided the crucial, emotionally satisfying transition into adult life.
I know someone who worked at a treatment center for disadvantaged inner city girls (drug treatment, mostly court mandated). From what I understood motherhood is a status symbol, also a right of passage. A way to earn respect. All of the sudden people pay more attention to you. It also affords a pass into a club of other unwed mothers, many older ones, that might have served as role models growing up. Like the observation said, it is seen as the next step in life.
One deeper level, I think it also provides companionship and family where there is none. Deadbeat deads or moms, girlfriends and hookups who are abusive, come in an out, but this one little person, will be there looking up to them never going anywhere, providing love and attachment that they never got much. That is at least my interpretation of it. It is unfortunate because in most cases these children and parents will have a hard time. It is very selfish to bring children into the world just to be used a status symbol or someone to provide companionship when there are just no resources to raise safely.
On an even deeper, perhaps unconscious, level, maybe having children can be seen as giving up on accomplishing more in life and instead choosing to procreate, hoping maybe the offspring might have a better shot at it.
> The good father is somebody like your friend.”
I can see how that would be an attempt at reversal or mend their own experience with their fathers growing up. Their father wasn't there. Their father wasn't their "friend". Their father used to beat them and be harsh. So they vow to be the opposite.
The one hope in this is that it would also reverse some of the stereotypes about men. Men are the default guilty party in family disputes. They are the stereotypical predator and abuser while women are given a a great leeway and only with concrete and absolute evidence will they be considered as unfit to take care of the child. This mentality has permeated the court system, the school system, the culture in general. Hopefully this leads at least to a re-evaluation of those stereotypes.
- svantana 12y ago> It is very selfish to bring children into the world [...] Would you say there are any unselfish reasons for having kids? I believe poor and rich folks do it for the same reasons, although the circumstances are different.
- rdtsc 12y ago> Would you say there are any unselfish reasons for having kids? I didn't say it was selfish reasons. I said it was a selfish act. There is a difference. You can make the argument that there aren't unselfish reason -- everything one does can be linked to benefit to oneself. In this case it is a selfish act. It is selfish because it exposes this new human being to most likely a bad environment, poverty, abuse, danger. To make it unselfish would be to have better guarantees that the child will have stable home, parents who can provide, other caretakers, make sure that well police doesn't get called to the neighborhood every Friday night and there is no need to duck if you hear loud noises that sound like gunshots.
- gwern 12y ago> From what I understood motherhood is a status symbol, also a right of passage. _Promises I Can Keep_ is a good book on this topic.