6 ms·
Fragments of an Anarchist Anthropology (2004) [pdf]
- gwern 12y agoIt's a long piece, so one might wonder why I found it interesting; I've excerpted some of the interesting parts at https://plus.google.com/103530621949492999968/posts/Ez6Xh8Ha9KP https://plus.google.com/103530621949492999968/posts/Ez6Xh8Ha... - I particularly found interesting the discussion of how egalitarian tribes regard politicians & power.
- sillysaurus3 12y agoDo you think the underlying theory would ever be a practical way for humans to coexist?
- gwern 12y agoI think to some extent your question is wrong: clearly humans have coexisted outside of Western nation-states.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- eggy 12y agoHe makes the assertion that slavery (pg 71, section 3), where somebody rents you out to another, and wage labor, where you rent yourself out are an equivalent arrangement. This is an emotional appeal, rather than a logical one, and this type of 'reasoning' seems to be at the root of more assertions in the paper. You take the job that is available under the circumstances, primarily to put food in your mouth and a roof over your head, and secondarily, you work and hope for better to reach your goals and dreams.
- dethstar 12y agoYou take the master that is willing to take you, primarily to put food in your mouth and roof over your head. edit: for the down voter(s). Take the time to argue how this is different (feel free to downvote me still) I don't really care about internet points but would rather engage in conversation about this topic.
- svedlin 12y ago"Those sent to work in town often had some input in their choice of master and some, like Frederick Douglass, were allowed to live on their own upon surrender of satisfactory wages." [1] That was probably far from the norm in the 1830's. Frederick Douglass was no less in bondage though. Later in life, Mr. Douglass said: "[E]xperience demonstrates that there may be a slavery of wages only a little less galling and crushing in its effects than chattel slavery, and that this slavery of wages must go down with the other". [2] "Frederick Douglass was an African-American social reformer, orator, writer and statesman. After escaping from slavery, he became a leader of the abolitionist movement[.]" [3] (upvoted you) [1] http://books.google.com/books?id=jI4euhKoEaEC&pg=PA65 http://books.google.com/books?id=jI4euhKoEaEC&pg=PA65 [2] http://books.google.com/books?id=nOt7au3N8FUC&pg=PA676 http://books.google.com/books?id=nOt7au3N8FUC&pg=PA676 [3] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Frederick_Douglass http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Frederick_Douglass
- jvm 12y agoIn anarchism, you take the egalitarian society that is willing to take you, primarily to put food in your mouth and roof over your head. All of this argumentation is primarily emotional. It makes a lot more sense to talk about what you actually want (utility?) and what social changes would be an improvement, than to try to argue that some social institution is intrinsically bad.
- logicchains 12y agoA slave owner makes you worse off than if they didn't exist, by chaining you, beating you, and threatening to kill you if you try to run away. An employer doesn't necessarily make you any worse off than if they didn't exist; if you'd be starving without food/payment from them, then their actions aren't the root cause of your starving, nature is, as if they didn't exist then you'd still be starving.
- asgard1024 12y agoI recall Chomsky saying something along the lines that this position was a common position of most proletariat in the late 19th century. I am sure he has sources to back this up, but I don't know those. So I would be wary to designate that as an "illogical" and not a cultural thing.
- k1m 12y agoTwo videos of Chomsky making this point: 1. Recent interview with Chris Hedges: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bwRf5HHm2Mo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bwRf5HHm2Mo 2. Older interview: http://www.tubechop.com/watch/2860018 http://www.tubechop.com/watch/2860018
- _delirium 12y agoIt used to be a common position of American proto-libertarians as well, in the "individualist" tradition, like Lysander Spooner. There's an old American 18th/19th-century ideal of having your own tools/land/freedom and not having your labor subordinated to a boss/master/government/lord/duke/company/whatever. Even Abraham Lincoln had a very tepid defense of wage work. He argued that working for a wage wasn't slavery or serfdom, in response to southern claims that northern workers weren't free men either. But his argument boiled down to: yes, wage-workers aren't truly free men for now, but since they are paid and not legally compelled to stay, they can save up money and eventually become their own masters, therefore their subordination to a boss should be regarded as merely a temporary condition that they will be able to escape from.
- voyou 12y agoFrom Graeber: "Instead of people selling us or renting us out we rent out ourselves." Graeber is suggesting that renting someone's labour-capacity is fundamentally the same whether the person is renting out their own labour capacity, or the capacity of someone else. Claiming that two things have the same structure is a logical argument; it may be wrong in this case, but it's not "an emotional appeal."
- eggy 12y agoIf you are claiming it is logical because it is an argument from analogy, even if it is a false analogy, then technically I would have to agree to that. My comment about it being emotional is that when an argument from analogy is made between two things that have an obvious, fundamental difference between them, choice vs. force, then I see the person appealing to your emotions under false analogy by using the common term 'rent' for both situations. This is where ad hominem stems from, and although a term in logic, arguments based on it are not logical and usually are filled with emotion.
- jahaja 12y agoIt's not choice vs. force though, it's indirect force vs direct force. To make an actual choice in this case would require that the person about to rent out his or her labor has some alternative to wage labor; such as enough land to be self-sufficient, or perhaps enough capital to work for oneself.
- calibraxis 12y agoA common pro-capitalist talking point is that merely saying "wage slavery" is somehow "emotional". And then this evidence-free rhetoric is supposed to somehow undermine your point. This is basically desperation; of course renting yourself to obey the commands of an order-giver is wage slavery. Capitalist ideology relies on Orwellian propaganda that it's "freedom" to watch your tongue all day, lest you get fired and appeal to some other wage-slaver that you're a useful tool to rent. Also, it helps demonstrate that capitalist economics is mainly scientism. This soft social science hitches a ride on the popular imagery of the solemn-faced scientist.
- dethstar 12y agoThank you this is great. About the first section where it talks about lack of anarchism in academia. My friend is actually working on her master thesis (on history) about anarchism (here, in Mexico). She's always telling me about how she struggles with her teachers and how some of them just want tell her off with no arguments like just telling her that anarchists are violent.
- corpselord420 12y agograeber's 'debt: the first 5000 years' is an very broadly scoped history of the function of debt and the anthropological history of economics and is one of the best books i've read in years; i highly recommend it to anyone who thinks that synopsis sounds at all interesting
- erikpukinskis 12y agoBetween first grade and tenure, collectivism is all but snuffed out of students. Toddlers are allowed to play together, and full faculty often form granting teams that can be legitimate collectives. But mostly everyone is the captain of their own reputation, and will be held personally responsible for their work, which they are considered to own. There is no agreement about the terms of anarchism among anarchists, but collectivism is a common cultural practice and property is pretty antithetical to most anarchist ecologies. Some (high value) academics see the academy as libertarian, but that's how things look when you're being catered to. The idea of individual authorship is pretty unassailable in most employment/admissions decisions so that doesn't leave much space for people living as anarchists. You can have some success at it if your privilege napsack is stocked