3 ms·
This will invariably lead to the argument whether government can or should mandate vaccinations. Currently parents probably cannot be prosecuted for not vaccin
by rdtsc 12y ago
This will invariably lead to the argument whether government can or should mandate vaccinations.
Currently parents probably cannot be prosecuted for not vaccinating their kids. I think they should be (child endangerment comes to mind, kind of like putting the child in the car without a special car seat).
But in all likely-hood I can see easier laws being passed that might exclude un-vaccinated people from various venues. Travel (flying is not a right apparently), schools, hospitals, doctors' offices, concerts. "Show your vaccinations card and come and enjoy the music" kind of deal. Parents throwing birthday parties for their kids and checking vaccination cards at the door. Pretty strange, but maybe more viable that forcing vaccinations otherwise (forced medical treatment).
Or to look at it anther way, what is the legal precedent of parents refusing medical treatment over religious beliefs? You know let "Jesus un-break her arm instead of the doctor". Maybe this is in the same category.
- tzs 12y ago> But in all likely-hood I can see easier laws being passed that might exclude un-vaccinated people from various venues What about people who are not vaccinated for medical reasons, such as an allergy to the vaccine?
- jessaustin 12y agoIs that a thing? I mean, how would you know? Many vaccines are administered once or twice in a lifetime...
- couradical 12y agoYou can be allergic to certain common components, e.g. egg albumin. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Egg_allergy#Vaccine_hazard http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Egg_allergy#Vaccine_hazard
- jpollock 12y agoI believe people with severe egg allergies avoid some vaccines because of the presence of egg protein - eggs are used as bioreactors to grow the vaccine. However, it looks like that's only the influenza vaccine, and that's not how the MMR vaccine is produced. http://www.cdc.gov/vaccines/vpd-vac/should-not-vacc.htm http://www.cdc.gov/vaccines/vpd-vac/should-not-vacc.htm
- johnpmayer 12y agoYes, until I outgrew my egg allergy, I could not take certain vaccines. I was too young to remember which ones I could not take. I suppose that I relied on herd immunity for those specific diseases.
- tzs 12y agoThe vaccines are once or twice in a lifetime, but the allergens are not. The MMR vaccine is manufactured using neomycin. The CDC says [1] for the MMR vaccine: Anyone who has ever had a life-threatening allergic reaction to the antibiotic neomycin, or any other component of MMR vaccine, should not get the vaccine. Neomycin is used in many topical creams and ointments, so there are opportunities to find out that you have a problem with it other than through vaccination. Also, as you noted, some vaccines are twice in a lifetime. MMR, for example, is given at ~1 year old, and at 4-6 years old. If someone has a life-threatening reaction the first time, the CDC says that they should not get the second dose. Note that MMR vaccine allergies are very rare, so we aren't talking about a huge number of people who have to go around without MMR vaccination. [1] http://www.cdc.gov/vaccines/hcp/vis/vis-statements/mmr.html http://www.cdc.gov/vaccines/hcp/vis/vis-statements/mmr.html
- rdtsc 12y agoI am sure that is not the reason most people don't vaccinate their children. Maybe, some vaccines have alternative formulations. At least it shouldn't be hard to document and make exceptions for those few cases.
- gamegoblin 12y agoMany states have had vaccine requirements for a child to enter public schools: http://www.immunizationinfo.org/vaccines/state-requirements http://www.immunizationinfo.org/vaccines/state-requirements
- rdtsc 12y agoInterestingly is that a check-mate for people who don't want to vaccinate? Since kids have to be in school But, I guess it forces them to home-school, move, or go to private school that don't have such a requirement?
- objclxt 12y agoIn the majority of states these laws apply to both public and private schools, so home-schooling would be the only option.
- Hello71 12y agomany states also have exemptions for "religious"/"personal" reasons etc.
- chewxy 12y agoBronze age gods know nothing about vaccinations. How can there be religious reasons to refuse vaccinations when vaccinations are a modern invention? Such exceptions in law are idiotic.
- gamegoblin 12y agoSome vaccinations use animals or animal byproducts which are deemed unclean by some religions. Some religions make vague statements about blood and cleanliness, etc. which might be construed one way or another.
- manicdee 12y agoBronze and stone-age gods knew about the blood or meat of certain animals making you sick.
- wisty 12y ago> But in all likely-hood I can see easier laws being passed that might exclude un-vaccinated people from various venues Duty of care, maybe? The school has a duty to protect kids from potential carriers. They know if you admit unvaccinated kids, then herd immunity is lost. Also, maybe anti-discrimination laws would protect kids with genuine medical reasons from being excluded.
- bane 12y agoOne of the interesting policy problems of forcing vaccines is that you have to ensure that people who can't get vaccines for medical conditions are able to get around in society, and that people with absurd anti-vaccine conspiracy beliefs don't get medical waivers. My father, for example, can't get flu vaccines. The last time he got one was decades ago and he ended up hospitalized, completely paralyzed with minimal respiratory and heart functions, able only to move his eyes. He recovered, but it took weeks. They think he has Guillain-Barré syndrome and it kills many people who suffer from it (though they likely don't know until they suffer from it, the flu vaccine is one of the known triggers). The risk of immediate death is so high that he avoids most vaccines altogether.