4 ms·
From the article: In February, he sued the city on behalf of medallion owners, brokers, managers, financiers and cab affiliations. The suit argues
by CamperBob2 12y ago
From the article:
In February, he sued the city on behalf of medallion
owners, brokers, managers, financiers and cab
affiliations. The suit argues that the city has violated
their rights by allowing new companies to provide an
essentially identical transportation service without
complying with existing regulation. By eliminating the
exclusive right of medallion owners to provide that
service, the suit argues, the city has taken away the
thing that gives medallions their value as property
under Illinois law.
“If you think it’s an improvement to change the rules,
maybe you can do that,” says Edward Feldman, a partner
with Shakman. “But you have to provide compensation for
the property rights you’re destroying. And that’s the
Constitution.”
Medallions represent a promise, he says. And on that
promise, medallion owners took out mortgage-size loans.
If the city backs out of that promise, it must make them
whole.
So, if I buy a fishing license but fail to catch any fish, can I sue my state's Department of Fish and Wildlife for a refund of my $50? I wonder what people would say if I tried?
- 7Figures2Commas 12y agoThat's an invalid analogy. A valid analogy would be that you purchased a fishing license from your state's Department of Fish and Wildlife because you were told one was legally required to fish in a certain location, but the Department of Fish and Wildlife then failed to take action against others who began fishing in that same location without a license. Good idea or horrible idea, certain cities created licensing regimes that promised to protect taxi drivers from competition if they paid for medallions. Now that others are flouting the law and circumventing the licensing regime, the taxi drivers want their protection money back if they're not going to receive the protection they were promised.
- xmodem 12y agoIn terms of individual taxi drivers who took out massive loans this is a valid argument. In terms of the rent-seeking institutional investors who lobbied the government to create an asset class which diverts most of the profits away from the people actually doing the work and makes taxis more expensive for no return in public benefit. I have no issue with government regulation of the taxi industry - quite the opposite. Certainly I think that it's important to mandate vehicle safety inspections. But if taxi licenses are going to be supply constrained, they should be issued by the government for a flat fee on a first-come first-served, use-it-or-lose-it basis. They should only be purchasable by the driver that will be driving the taxi and they should not be transferrable.