6 ms·
At 20 Amazon is bulking up. It is not yet slowing down
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- superdude 12y agoYour first paragraph is hard to read but your second paragraph is impossible.
- Zombieball 12y agoI think I know what you are trying to say, but my understanding is Amazon fails to report profits because they are heavily reinvesting into the company. I don't think it is because they are taking a loss on sales.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- msandford 12y agoAgreed, nobody really understands that. Every dollar earned is a dollar invested without selling additional shares. When they're building hundreds of millions if not billions of dollars worth of infrastructure every year you can't expect them to make much money. Imagine a railroad had just completed the first trans-continental route and was very busy making money on that. Now imagine that they were also putting most of that money into building more track to service ever larger parts of the US directly instead of just NY<->SF. Should they be reporting huge profits? No because that money is going directly into more right-of-way and steel. Amazon is doing exactly the same but somehow almost nobody manages to figure this out.
- coldtea 12y ago>Imagine a railroad had just completed the first trans-continental route and was very busy making money on that. Now imagine that they were also putting most of that money into building more track to service ever larger parts of the US directly instead of just NY<->SF. Should they be reporting huge profits? No because that money is going directly into more right-of-way and steel. Yeah, exactly like that, only it's been 15 years already, and it's not like the don't already have the largest online store, or there's any magic solution for them to rise their margins in the future.
- martinald 12y agoBut is it all going back into infrastructure and the like? What if it is allowing them to subsidise lower prices on products, killing competition? I don't really know of any other company that has managed to not produce really any profit in 20 years of operation, most of that as a public corporation. It doesn't seem sustainable to me. Also, to use your analogy most of the railroads ended up bankrupt/closed down because they vastly overbuilt with the assumption that more passengers and freight would come, despite going into really rural areas. It is perhaps quite apt for where Amazon could end up going.
- msandford 12y agoOkay look at their balance sheet: http://www.google.com/finance?fstype=ii&q=NASDAQ:AMZN http://www.google.com/finance?fstype=ii&q=NASDAQ:AMZN Their R&D was nearly $7 billion in 2013. Could you cut that in half while running Amazon exactly the same way (i.e. not improving it but not making it worse)? I think so, and that would improve profits by roughly 10 fold. Suddenly Amazon's earnings multiplier isn't 500, it's 50. Furthermore there's another $12 billion in the selling/admin/general expenses line item. What's that? Could some of their building spree be contained within that item? Quite possibly. It's safe to say that it's coming from SOMEWHERE. I would be surprised if it cost them $300 per square foot between the building, the shelving, the conveyors, etc to build a new distribution center. At that kind of price a 1.2 million square foot building is a $360 million dollar expense. From what I gather they're building a couple of those every year. That adds up. What happens when they don't need to build new ones and can instead just operate their existing ones profitably? Do you hear stories of people being worked to death at Target and Wal-mart? I hear that at Wal-mar they keep their employees just shy of full-time to deny them benefits, but I don't read stories about how they're asking to do inhuman amounts of work. But I do hear those stories about Amazon. Sounds to me like they probably have a more efficient workforce coupled with cheaper real-estate and very low "shrinkage" (stolen merchandise). If their supply chain is more efficient than Wal-mart or Target and they aren't selling stuff much cheaper (seems like the Amazon discount is about 10% at best these days) then it stands to reason they might be able to make more money. I'm not saying that Amazon has crazy huge margins, but I do think that their margins are quite reasonable. They (Jeff Bezos really) just keep spending all the money they make to keep making the business better. Given how big retail is in the US I find it unlikely that they'll accidentally overbuild and find themselves in quite the predicament. It's not as though Amazon is building giant distribution centers on tiny islands where it makes absolutely zero sense. They're putting them near population centers, where people already buy stuff. Wal-mart did $450 billion in revenue in 2013. Amazon only did $80 billion. Target also did about $80 billion. So Amazon is now as big as Target but not as big as Wal-mart. The reports of Amazon's impending demise seem a bit overblown to me.
- Fomite 12y agoI think much of the skepticism is that they will never reach a point where their reinvestment is "done" and they begin taking profits.
- eclipxe 12y agoThe word you mean is "future" not "feature"
- jessaustin 12y agoInteresting: how little was said about AWS.
- rgbrenner 12y agoAWS was 4% of Amazon's revenue for 2013. I think about 4% of the article was about AWS too... Seems appropriate.
- omonra 12y agoThat said, AWS has something like 80% profit margin [1] vs almost no margin for the rest of the business :) [1] http://venturebeat.com/2013/09/05/amazons-mountain-of-margin-in-cloud-services-over-80-profit/ http://venturebeat.com/2013/09/05/amazons-mountain-of-margin...
- rgbrenner 12y agoI agree that AWS almost certainly has a great profit margin.. but that article includes no details. He says AWS has X in costs, trust me. I have no idea how he arrived at that number.
- sharpy 12y agoDisclaimer: I'm a software engineer working for AWS. But not on EC2. I feel the margin number conclusion is deeply flawed for variety of reasons. There are some questions the author cannot have answers for, that greatly change the margin numbers for EC2. A couple that comes to mind are: 1. What percentage of time are customers being charged for the available servers? 2. What percentage of instance hours are being charged at on-demand prices, vs reserved instance? Also it completely ignores services that makes EC2 stand out from plain hosting, and adds much value, such as AutoScaling, CloudWatch, Elastic Load Balancing, OpsWorks, and Elastic BeanStalk. And believe me when I say that support cost is NOT trivial. In many cases, the number of engineer hours involved makes the support pricing look like a real bargain.
- saosebastiao 12y agoEven if this analysis was correct, it doesn't say anything about the margins of the rest of the business. There is plenty of gross margin in almost every business Amazon is involved in, but it will never show up in the net profit line until Amazon decides to stop reinvesting every cent of cash flow.
- mathattack 12y agoI'm amazed by Amazon. Some of their moves follow a playbook. Books -> Clothes -> Diapers. A non-technical CEO turning the company into an API machine that outsources it's own technology... Every textbook would say crazy, but he's on to something. Makes one wonder about the drones.
- donflamenco 12y agoBezos graduated with a CS degree from Princeton. I wouldn't call that non-technical. He is extremely sharp.
- mathattack 12y agoMonstorously smart. I consider him one of the top CEOs of all time because he succeeds on so many levels: Business design, technology enablement, hiring, surviving market ups and downs, investor relations... I had (wrongly) assumed he was a business person first since he had most recently worked at Bankers Trust and DE Shaw. Thank you for the clarification. This explains his insights that would drive AWS.
- michaeldhopkins 12y agoDE Shaw is a quant firm and tends to hire out of STEM fields, not arts like business.
- mathattack 12y agoYes. I should have caught this.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- coldtea 12y ago>I'm amazed by Amazon I, on the other hand, am underwhelmed. Their AWS services is a pretty cool tech and business. But as for their other stuff: 1) Their core business (the store) barely makes any profit. Their profit margins are razor-thin, and until recently operated at a loss IIRC. 2) Their ebooks and music store are ho-hum. 3) Their hardwares, Kindles (Fire and plain) are simply loss leaders for content sales. Which (1) is not that profitable in itself anyway. Not that difficult to sell stuff like readers and tablets at a cost or slight loss. Anything else I forget about?
- holri 12y agoReasons not to buy from Amazon: https://stallman.org/amazon.html https://stallman.org/amazon.html
- yeukhon 12y agoHmm. Every time I see the name Stallman I just conclude it's all about materials not distributed freely. Essentially, don't buy anything from anybody who don't support free redistribution (iTunes, App store, Play Store, etc).
- holri 12y agoTo conclude something from a name without reading the works and criticizing it factually is just prejudice.
- hga 12y agoBut in cases like this, it's useful prejudice. I for one don't need to read every rant by RMS against Digital Restrictions Management, even if I agree with him by and large. I have much better things to do with my time. A lot of useful prejudice work that way in a lot of domains. I have my own personal boycotting policies, and one of them is to never, ever buy digital media with DRM. Which, strangely enough, Amazon has long allowed me to avoid if the rights holder allows, e.g. I have a nice set of MP3s I got from them for a CD of Scandinavian music that in physical form was by then out of print and way too expensive. They also tell you if a Kindle digital book has no DRM at the bottom of it's description. They don't really care, and I respect their choice to abide by rights holder's restrictions and sell the stuff anyway.
- holri 12y agoNo it is not useful in this case, because Stallmanns page is much more about than just materials not distributed freely. For your convenience the headers of his page about Amazon: * Restricting and Shafting Customers * Censorship * Exploiting workers mercilessly * Shafting others in the publishing world * Dodging taxes * Political harm