3 ms·
> It is cheaper to just hand over USD$1K per month to anyone that bothers to show up at the BI office than to support an army of social workers and bureaucrats
by prostoalex 12y ago
> It is cheaper to just hand over USD$1K per month to anyone that bothers to show up at the BI office than to support an army of social workers and bureaucrats
Your worst case scenario under this program is 300,000,000 Americans showing up during a downturn in the economy. That's $300 billion a month, $3.6 trillion a year, or roughly 100% of current US budget expenditure (with entitlement, defense, discretionary, etc.)
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_federal_budget#Major_expenditure_categories http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_federal_budget#Ma...
So it's definitely not cheaper, even when you account for the cost of maintaining the bureaucracy.
- hollerith 12y ago>That's $300 billion a month, $36 trillion a year Math error here.
- prostoalex 12y agoThanks, corrected.
- jacobgreenleaf 12y agoAt the height of the great depression only ~23% of workers were out of jobs. That's hardly 100% during a "downturn." At 100% unemployment do you really think our current system of privately owned property would fare any better? Personally I think at 100% unemployment the masses would seize all the property, and probably rightfully so.
- Domenic_S 12y agoBI is typically given to everyone as a basic right - including those with jobs.
- prostoalex 12y agoSo are you inserting a qualification for being unemployed and no longer allowing just anybody to walk in and demand their share of basic income? Then you're back to the problem of needing to hire more bureaucracy with respective office leases, equipment, etc., to verify the employment status. Unemployment is also a weak estimate, what you want is unemployment + the negative labor force participation - kids and retirees are not unemployed in the sense that they're actively seeking employment, but would probably not pass up an opportunity for free cash.
- rahimnathwani 12y agoUS government expenditure is more than $6.3 trillion. The $3.6 trillion you quoted is just federal spending, and does not include state and local spending: http://www.usgovernmentspending.com/total http://www.usgovernmentspending.com/total So, it's more like 50-something percent, not 100%. Also, some of the money would come back as sales tax etc., so the real impact would be less than 50%.