3 ms·
>It would be a dream come true for me someone prosecutes AirBnb and puts the founders behind bars. What have they done wrong? Made it easier for people to shar
by wyager 12y ago
>It would be a dream come true for me someone prosecutes AirBnb and puts the founders behind bars.
What have they done wrong? Made it easier for people to share living space? God forbid people make tools that make travel easier and more accessible.
- dominotw 12y ago>Made it easier for people to share living space? Did you read the article?
- sheetjs 12y agoAirBnB violates NY's illegal hotel law (e.g. http://www.scribd.com/doc/142650911/Decision-and-Order-for-NOV-35006622J http://www.scribd.com/doc/142650911/Decision-and-Order-for-N...). AirBnB actively promotes in New York (they have been actively airing ads on local TV) and made no effort (at least, when the issue first flared up) to make users aware of the relevant laws.
- wyager 12y agoOK, so they broke NYC law. I probably do that 25 times a day. So does everyone else. Did they do anything morally wrong? I mean the developers, not the people renting their apartments.
- bradleyjg 12y agoThese are not victimless crimes, the neighbors are the victims, and AirBnb is willfully facilitating illegal and antisocial behavior. That's plainly immoral.
- neurobro 12y agoRenting your residence to vacationers is antisocial now. Ok. I have to wonder what proportion of Airbnb's transactions ever cause any kind of disturbance to anyone. If it's the rule rather than the exception that "vacationers" turn out to be party animals who tear up the place, it's surprising that tenants in prosocial environments would even continue to take that risk.
- notlisted 12y agoLet me clarify... the noise is one thing, the constant flow of people another, and the issue of not feeling/being secure yet another (and not the least). Add to that the effects it has on rents and available apartments, and you might see my point that regulation of illegal short-term sublets by tenants in an apartment building is indeed in need of regulation.
- neurobro 12y agoWhen I was an apartment dweller, the noise, constant flow of people, and feeling of insecurity (and silverfish) went with the territory because that's the type of place I could afford. If I had been in a nice, quiet apartment with pleasant neighbors, I would have been wary of being evicted for violating the lease unless the risk of my "guests" causing a problem was very low. That's why I have to wonder what the real situation is. I see a few complaints about disturbances with nothing being done by the landlord (which is what I'd expect at my old slum apartment), but nobody complaining about being evicted for using Airbnb (which is what I'd expect if a tenant were to turn a nice apartment building into a party hotel, as some complainers insinuate). In any case, this seems like a problem that already has a resolution: Evict people for subletting if the contract prohibits it, regardless of whether the customers were found on a web site or in the back alley.
- avalaunch 12y agoIs the guy running a crack house doing anything morally wrong if he isn't selling crack himself - simply taking a cut from those that are?
- wpietri 12y agoI don't mind a reasoned argument, but willful ignorance of viewpoints you don't like is an embarrassingly bad approach. It's transparently dumb.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- wyager 12y ago>willful ignorance of viewpoints you don't like Maybe it's not willful, and that's why I'm asking? Would you care to help alleviate my ignorance? FWIW, I've actually heard a lot of viewpoints against AirBnB; I just think they're all poorly reasoned.
- kaliblack 12y ago> Would you care to help alleviate my ignorance? People don't want to be regularly woken by strangers in their building.
- wyager 12y agoWell unfortunately, that happens in any apartment building. It's not specific to AirBnB. Anything else?
- wpietri 12y agoIf it isn't willful, then you need to demonstrate that that you're not totally ignorant of the concerns people have. Educating yourself isn't our job; it's yours.