5 ms·
Patent Trolls Are Mortally Wounded
- higherpurpose 12y agoIt seems to me that in almost all cases, the "specialty" Courts tend to rule on the side of what they were meant to "judge". If it's a "patent Court", then they will almost always rule in favor of the patents. If it's a spying Court (FISC), then they will rule in favor of the spying, and become a rubberstamp Court for surveillance requests. So maybe we should get rid of specialty Courts, no?
- nickff 12y agoIt is rather unfair to lump the "FISC" system in with all the courts, because it is more of a board, panel, committee, in camera hearing, or administrative proceeding. "FISC" lacks the essential qualities of a court, as the defendant has no right to appear, they are not represented by counsel, charges are not presented, evidence is not disclosed, and there is no right to trial by a jury of the accused's peers.[1] [1] https://www.aclu.org/files/assets/order_granting_governments_motion_to_dismiss_and_denying_aclu_motion_for_preliminary_injunction.pdf https://www.aclu.org/files/assets/order_granting_governments...
- jessaustin 12y agoYes it's dreadfully unfair. Little children are crying. And yet GP's observation that "specialty" Courts tend to rule on the side of what they were meant to "judge" is true, without consideration for particular procedural differences.
- tzs 12y agoPart of this is due to the fact the courts like CAFC are appeals courts. By the time CAFC sees a patent, a lot of experts have already looked at it and said it is good. These include: 1. The patent attorney or agent who advised the inventor during the application process. 2. One or more examiners at the patent office. 3. When the patent owner was considering his lawsuit, he would have hired patent attorneys, non-attorney patent experts, and subject matter experts to evaluate the patent and the alleged infringing product, in order to determine if it was worth going through with a lawsuit. It would be surprising if patents that get through this gauntlet did not tend to be approved by the CAFC.
- throwawaykf05 12y agoActually, the meme that CAFC tends to rule too much on the side of patent owners is more of an urban legend based on grumblings of some patent lawyers, which was then picked up and spread by certain "journalists" (hi, binarybits!) and regularly parroted by others, like TFA. But this is belied by the actual data -- see this older post of mine: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7849386 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7849386 It cites a number of empirical studies and statistics that shows that the Supreme Court and the District Courts agree with the Federal Circuit way more often than not. Further, if you look at the EU, patent cases there AFAIK are handled by specialty courts, and they tend to result in much cheaper, faster and more consistent resolutions. This seems to be because they are decided entirely by the judges, who not only are already intimately knowledgeable about the laws they are dealing with, but most of whom seem to have technical backgrounds. This means no messing around with juries and expert witnesses. (More knowledgeable people, please correct me.) Based on the evidence from the EU, I actually think the solution to the litigation problem is the opposite of what you propose: move the role of the CAFC much lower down the patent litigation chain, i.e. all patent cases go directly to the Federal Circuit or some equivalent thereof. Not only could this have the same benefits as the EU system, it would neutralize the whole game of forum-shopping.
- rbehrends 12y ago> Further, if you look at the EU, patent cases there AFAIK are handled by specialty courts, and they tend to result in much cheaper, faster and more consistent resolutions. The "cheaper and faster" aspect is more likely to be an artifact of civil law systems vs. adversarial systems (especially the absence of a jury in civil cases), since it is not specific to patent cases. And it's very much debatable whether they are more consistent. Also, European specialty courts are just as prone to regulatory capture. See, e.g., the fascinating holding of the EPO Board in "Auction Method/Hitachi": "The Board is aware that its comparatively broad interpretation of the term 'invention' in Article 52(1) EPC will include activities which are so familiar that their technical character tends to be overlooked, such as the act of writing using pen and paper." A holding that flew in the face of decades of European patent jurisprudence and was a fairly blatant end run around the requirements of article 52 of the EPC.
- WildUtah 12y agoI know the author didn't write the headline, but trolls are not "mortally wounded;" they're barely scratched. This ruling will have little effect. The Supreme court declined to offer any guidance about what "abstract" means, so courts will go on making it up according to the feelings of the presiding judge. Legislation like the Innovation Act that could be brought back next year would be much more important.
- stcredzero 12y agoso courts will go on making it up according to the feelings of the presiding judge Keep in mind: a lawyer tried to attack the crypto credibility of Whit Diffie! http://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2013/11/newegg-trial-crypto-legend-diffie-takes-the-stand-to-knock-out-patent/ http://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2013/11/newegg-trial-cryp... For some reason patent attorneys wonder why so many of us programmers regard the legalese surreality around patents as a Kafkaesque morass.
- WildUtah 12y agoKeep in mind: a lawyer tried to attack the crypto credibility of Whit Diffie! Remember, that lawyer who attacked Diffie won the case! The jury decided that the Patent Office knew better than Whitfield Diffie about encryption and awarded millions to the guy who claimed to invent asymmetric transport cryptography in the 1990s.
- throwawaykf05 12y agoWell, the jury decided on the facts that the lawyer presented, which were facts that Diffie could not deny. He was introduced by the defense as the "inventor of asymmetric key exchange". But the plaintiff simply pointed out that, since somebody at GCHQ had already invented it secretly, he was not the true inventor. Yet because the prior GCHQ invention was secret, it did not count as prior art, which was why the DH patent was still valid! And here's the kicker: the defense was actually arguing that the plaintiff's invention had already been invented by DH and as such was invalid, and the plaintiff had already pointed out that DH's work was not published and hence could not invalidate their patent. Exactly like the GCHQ work did not invalidate DH's patent. Given that the plaintiffs argument was "secret prior art does not invalidate patents", it probably wasn't the best idea for the defense to bring in living proof of one of the better known examples of the plaintiff's argument to support them.
- radley 12y agoMost of the worst software patents do exactly what the court said they couldn’t: present an idea (like hedging risk, one-click shopping, etc.) and say that, because it’s executed on a computer, or a generic piece of hardware, it is not just an idea anymore. Does this mean Amazon will lose their one-click patent?
- chris_wot 12y agoHopefully. And refund all the money people lost due to being unable to implement the idea and fight it in court.
- zmmmmm 12y agoI'm still scratching my head trying to understand what principle drives the distinction between an abstract idea and a non-abstract one. It seems to me that the very definition of a computer program is the description of an idea - in pedantic detail, yes, but it will always come back to an idea. If that is true, and if, as many say, it is only a matter of time before "software eats the world", is there anything left that will be patentable? The court decision this week seems to entangle two things; the fact that the abstract idea was not novel, and the fact that it was abstract. It is not clear to me: had the abstract idea itself been truly novel - would that have changed the outcome? A lot of people are saying this ruling is against patenting abstract ideas but it seems to me that it is mostly about the fact that directly transcribing an idea to a computer doesn't ADD concreteness (or novelty?), NOT a judgement about the veracity of the original idea. Would love to hear any insight about this.
- chris_wot 12y agoWell, that's the fundamental problem of patents. They restrict the free dissemination of ideas. In a free market, the idea of a patent is fundamentally flawed. Soft patents are the reductio ad absurdum of the whole concept.
- tadfisher 12y agoYou have it completely backward. Patents were introduced because it is in society's interest to disseminate ideas as widely as possible. This is why patented IP reverts to the public domain after a certain period. Were it not for patents, inventors would resort to the only tool at their disposal to limit free implementation of their ideas: the trade secret.
- pistle 12y agoI'm disappointed that the post's title was not literal. Don't DO that.