4 ms·

It was a discussion of the long term trend, not specific to that instance. So you are saying more people lie about owning a gun to a nosy stranger than they di

It was a discussion of the long term trend, not specific to that instance. So you are saying more people lie about owning a gun to a nosy stranger than they did over the past 40 years? It also isn't a democrat or republican issue. The growth in gun purchases began in 2002. Since it won't let me reply yet: "But by the mid-2000s, the federal government stopped asking the questions, leaving researchers to rely on much smaller surveys, like the General Social Survey, which is conducted by NORC, a research center at the University of Chicago. Measuring the level of gun ownership can be a vexing problem, with various recent national polls reporting rates between 35 percent and 52 percent. Responses can vary because the survey designs and the wording of questions differ. But researchers say the survey done by the center at the University of Chicago is crucial because it has consistently tracked gun ownership since 1973, asking if respondents “happen to have in your home (or garage) any guns or revolvers.” The center’s 2012 survey, conducted mostly in person but also by phone, involved interviews with about 2,000 people from March to September and had a margin of sampling error of plus or minus three percentage points. Gallup, which asks a similar question but has a different survey design, shows a higher ownership rate and a more moderate decrease. No national survey tracks the number of guns within households." Key flaw here is the fact it doesn't track nationwide [and there isn't one, even by the NRA and other gun rights groups]. The article itself shows a decline from about 50% to about 30%. I don't think reading the rest would really help you pick apart what I've said.

hga 12y ago
"It was a discussion of the long term trend, not specific to that instance." Well, point me at a source I can read, or quote the relevant parts, or email me them (see my profile). Or just tell me which polling outfit did it, e.g. Gallup puts this sort of stuff on-line and without a paywall. "So you are saying more people lie about owning a gun to a nosy stranger than they did over the past 40 years?" See above WRT my not being able to know what you're asking, but I wouldn't be at all surprised by such a trend, though I'd really like to look at the endpoints; also note phone surveys have had an increasing problem with just getting people to even answer questions of any sort. The errors in all too many election based surveys ought to give you pause in taking this claim so far. And, as I said, the math doesn't work. That should be enough to falsify this claim. "It also isn't a democrat or republican issue. The growth in gun purchases began in 2002." Which just might be why I said in my original posting above that "it started post-9/11, I believe because the government made it clear we were on our own".

hga 12y ago

"It was a discussion of the long term trend, not specific to that instance." Well, point me at a source I can read, or quote the relevant parts, or email me them (see my profile). Or just tell me which polling outfit did it, e.g. Gallup puts this sort of stuff on-line and without a paywall. "So you are saying more people lie about owning a gun to a nosy stranger than they did over the past 40 years?" See above WRT my not being able to know what you're asking, but I wouldn't be at all surprised by such a trend, though I'd really like to look at the endpoints; also note phone surveys have had an increasing problem with just getting people to even answer questions of any sort. The errors in all too many election based surveys ought to give you pause in taking this claim so far. And, as I said, the math doesn't work. That should be enough to falsify this claim. "It also isn't a democrat or republican issue. The growth in gun purchases began in 2002." Which just might be why I said in my original posting above that "it started post-9/11, I believe because the government made it clear we were on our own".