3 ms·
"if you (as a founder/early employee) are willing to put up with a much smaller talent pool in search of people who really truly fit the culture you want, that'
by greenyoda 12y ago
"if you (as a founder/early employee) are willing to put up with a much smaller talent pool in search of people who really truly fit the culture you want, that's your choice and your business."
It's your choice, unless your cultural norms are systematically (although perhaps not explicitly) discriminating against certain legally protected classes of people who are less likely to "fit in" to your culture. For example:
- Women might not enjoy beer and pizza and sports as much as men do, so they "wouldn't be a good cultural fit".
- People over 40, who have their own families and don't want to spend time socializing at work? They "wouldn't be a good cultural fit".
- Members of religious groups who can't eat the food or drink the alcohol you serve at the office, e.g., religious Jews or Muslims? They just "wouldn't be a good cultural fit".
So whenever these kinds of people apply for jobs at your company, you always pass them up in favor of someone who is a better cultural fit.
See the problem?
- kelnos 12y agoI see the potential legal problem, but I don't see the... moral(?) problem. This goes both ways, though. If I fell into one of these groups you describe, and interviewed at this hypothetical company, assuming I got a good taste of this culture during the interview process, I wouldn't want to work there anyway. So what, should the company give me an offer, and I accept it, only to be miserable because I don't fit in with my colleagues? Real discrimination is a problem. Not hiring women, or people of a particular color or religious group, etc. because you "don't like them" is horrible. But that's not what we're talking about. We're talking about people being deemed a poor culture fit on an individual, case-by-case basis. It's not saying, "we're not going to consider Muslim candidates because they won't drink", it's saying, "we brought this guy in, and after talking with him, we decided not to give him an offer because he doesn't fit socially/culturally". And while his religion might -- coincidentally -- be the root of that, I don't see that as discriminatory in the legal sense. (Of course it's "discriminatory" in the dictionary-definition sense, but so is "discriminating" against someone without the required qualifications.) I see this as people who want to work with people who they really gel with, and while that might be unfortunate (different points of view informed by different backgrounds is almost universally an advantage), I believe it's a valid choice for people in a company (especially a new, small one) to make.
- greenyoda 12y agoThe courts seem to be concerned with the results of hiring criteria, not simply whether they're intentionally discriminatory. For example, there was a ruling that a written employment exam for a fire department that disproportionately more white people than minority people passed was illegal discrimination, since it had no particular relevance to the candidate's ability to be a good firefighter. (On the other hand, a test to see whether you could carry an average-weight person out of a burning building would be OK, even if it excluded most women, since it was job-related.) Similarly, a candidate's willingness to drink has no relevance to their ability to be a good developer.